Not to knock on gretzky, but he had his own goons making sure that the opposing goons dont touch him, and that is one major reason why he could skate rings around goons and never resorted to violence. He didnt have to, as he had other people doing it for him. Therefore, Gretzky is in my opinion not even remotely comparable to Tiger, who seems to be an amazing human being, and has to do everything he achieves himself. So many atlethes with talent just “wing it” and “hope for the best”, but Tiger is one who 1) seems to be very goal-oriented and have a clear vision of what he wants to achieve, 2) he goes after his goals with the use of his mind, and seemingly enjoying every moment in the process and 3) he does not apologize for being great, is neither humble nor arrogant, and does not seem to play for the sake of having some imaginary “duty” to someone, or for the sake of sacrifice.
Not saying that the likes of Gretzky or Jordan just “winged” it, but all in all, Tiger seems like a extremely special individual, and i would not rank 99 and MJ in the same category.
I am going to agree with you here, particulary point #1. The entirety of Tiger’s life–literally all of it–has been devoted to becoming great in one thing, and he has never strayed from that goal. Golf fans will know about how he stormed onto the tour, winning by double digits at the Masters and at Pebble Beach. He had a tough patch from 2002ish to 2004, when he got rid of his old swing coach, brought in a new one, and changed his swing. The new swing did not pay dividends for several years, and nearly every reporter/journalist was eager to claim Tiger as fading out. Many commentators expressed doubts about his newer swing, saying he should not have ever changed it. Tiger never deviated from his goal, and stuck with trying to work out a new swing, perfecting it. Within the last few years, he has obviously played better than he ever has, with the new swing and coach to his credit.
In my estimation, there is not an athelete in recent history who has been able to integrate his body, mind, and entire character into the likes of his own image of himself as well as Tiger has. When the guy was a few years old he knew what he was going to do. I have read the book written by his Dad. I remember in it, somewhere, his Dad was talking about how Tiger would beg night and day to be taken to the course. I also remember his Dad writing about Tiger’s mental state, and the exercises he would do for himself to train it (i.e. he used to have someone throw his ball into the worst place imaginable on any given hole, and challenge himself to make par from that particularly awkward spot, and wouldn’t leave the course that day until he did).