As I understand the project it aims to “lower the barriers to entry” by inventing things that have already been invented, except that it will make its designs free. Is that the key aim?
So, for instance, it might come up with the design for a Compressed Earth Brick Press and then other people can go make such a press and use it without paying royalties. The open-source project itself does not intend to make stuff for people, but only make designs and prototypes. Is that correct?
The assumption seems to be that the cost of design is an important cost. Is this true? If so, this is the part that I don’t understand.
Added:
For instance, take the brick-maker. I assume that someone has checked that such a device can actually add value to people’s lives. Taking that as assumed, there are two objectives one may pursue:
- A brickmaker that is far better than what’s available today (in terms of quality, cost, etc.); or,
- A brickmaker that is a similar ballpark as today’s machines, but is open-source
Of course the project would like to achieve both objectives, but which one is primary? Is the open-source nature of any real significance to the outcomes? Would the project pursue a machine that is just slightly better, but open-source?
Hello, I’ve forgotten how to put the fancy quote box around other peoples stuff, could someone remind me? Thanks.
“As I understand the project it aims to “lower the barriers to entry” by inventing things that have already been invented, except that it will make its designs free. Is that the key aim?”
-Sort of- we are re-inventing them to improve the designs so they are cheaper, easier to make, easier to maintain, will last a lifetime and are modular.
“So, for instance, it might come up with the design for a Compressed Earth Brick Press and then other people can go make such a press and use it without paying royalties. The open-source project itself does not intend to make stuff for people, but only make designs and prototypes. Is that correct?”
-Another sort-of. We came to realize that funding by donation is incredibly impractical, so we’ve begun to manufacture and sell some of our designs to fund the project. The money is not the goal though, the prototypes are. When I went out there, I made 4 brick presses, 2 of which we sold. The goal in earnings for next year is 250k.
“The assumption seems to be that the cost of design is an important cost. Is this true? If so, this is the part that I don’t understand.”
-Not sure what you’re asking. Yes it is an important cost. Most of it has been volunteers, but for some of the harder prototypes like the steam engine, wind turbine, and aluminum extraction from clay, we’ll probably need to pay experts.
" Added: For instance, take the brick-maker. I assume that someone has checked that such a device can actually add value to people’s lives. Taking that as assumed, there are two objectives one may pursue:•A brickmaker that is far better than what’s available today (in terms of quality, cost, etc.); or,•A brickmaker that is a similar ballpark as today’s machines, but is open-source Of course the project would like to achieve both objectives, but which one is primary? Is the open-source nature of any real significance to the outcomes? Would the project pursue a machine that is just slightly better, but open-source?"
-I would say its the former, and all of the prototypes so far have been superior to other models, especially in terms of cost. The ease of maintenence is a big one too, our machines are far easier to fix than other ones because that was a key design feature. However, the fact that its open source is key to the project. But,its not like we accept just anybodys designs or anyones help. The founder is pretty selective about who works on what project because we don’t want the quality affected by the masses. The end goal of this is to have the set of all 50 machines and start a small society with them to prove it can be done. A “Galts gulch” if you will.