28 minutes ago, Boydstun said:
Yes, SL, thanks, and thanks to all. SL, did you put this under the sector Physics and Mathematics because of some parallels or intersections with mathematical conjectures proven to be not provable and problems proven to be not computable?
I incline to think Q is stating something about a particular sentence, and is therefore meaningful, but is false because its form, by convention, insinuates that it is stating some fact beyond itself, which it is not doing. It is claiming implicitly to be able to deliver something that it is not able to deliver. By contrast, the statement _Existence exists, _unparticular as it might be, makes a statement about some things not itself.
By that analysis, the second conjunct of K is also false, therefore K is false.
Thank you Boydstun. Another interesting twist.
You seem to indicate that a string of words can be meaningful and a sentence if it tries to state something about an identifiable referent… even if that something is inapplicable, or nonexistent. The result is a sentence which is false.
“This sentence” is surely a referent. The purported something about the sentence, is its truth or falsity. Let us consider what “truth” or falsity" is. Objectively it identifies a state of the relationship between the “something said” and the referent. As such, the term “true” or “false” must have its own referent, the relationship. Here the content (something) attempted is “truth” but “truth” as such presupposes antecedent relationship which it cannot itself supply.
So in a sense, only the content is meaningless, or better, missing. The string of words says nothing about “This sentence” although it promises to. So what about “is true”… do we treat it as inapplicable, nonsensical, or missing entirely?
“This sentence is furry.”
Here “is furry” is inapplicable to words. But is the sentence meaningful? Certainly the referent is clear. But the content is categorically inapplicable, words can never possess furriness or non-furriness. Is this simply an error of degree akin to “this sentence has 2 words in it” or is it an error of a different kind?
In some sense this is cleaner than “This sentence is true” because it does not mislead one (quite as much) to presume something… namely that the sentence can be evaluated as true or false… since most sentences can be evaluated as true or false, it sucks us in… whereas since we know sentences cannot be valuated on furriness “This sentence is furry” can easily be dismissed as nonsensical.
In what sense can something be nonsensical but meaningful?
Alternatively should we adjudge based on higher principles that all sentences which are not true are simply FALSE, and any attempt to distinguish between meaningful, non-meaningful, sensible or nonsensical is somehow artificial?
This reminds me in a very indirect way the impotence of the zero…
What I like about dropping the idea of meaningful versus meaningless falsehoods, is that it wipes away all the confusions about the so called indeterminate cases. It also seems to take care of fiction.
Everything that does not qualify as TRUE is simply FALSE.
Now if we ground truth in objectivity, then the referent, the something, and the relationship all each have to be identified with words in a meaningful and rational manner. The words must identify valid concepts and their valid relationships in a logically cogent manner.
“This sentence is true” cannot be objectively true, it is nonsensical, meaningfulness is beside the point?
Do I have anything to say anymore? Is my OP in any sense useful?
I’m not sure…