Collateral stands out for a few reasons, including giving Tom Cruise material outside his usual Hollywood hero type and showing Jamie Foxx is a legitamate dramatic actor. Best of all, though, is the direction from Michael Mann.
Most action films these days are frenetic messes, rock-video blurs of fight scenes and explosions strung together by sorry excuses for plots. Cases in point: any movie with “The Rock”; or most recently, The Bourne Supremacy. In the latter, I think they borrowed the cameraman from NYPD Blue and gave him as much crack as he could consume. The camera never stops moving, to the point where I literally could not tell what was happening on screen. And I don’t mean that in the usual sense, which is that the conceptual level of the film has problems (that is, the story and characters); rather, the problem is at the perceptual level. I first became aware of this in a couple scenes in Armageddon, in which I actually got mild motion sickness in the theater.
With very rare exceptions (such as the incredible Kill Bill volumes) modern action movies have abandoned plot and character. Perhaps the clearest measure of this is the James Bond series, from the romanticism of Dr. No down through the camp of Moonraker to the mindlessness of Die Another Day. Even First Blood, the first Rambo movie, focused on plot and character, using action as a part of the film, rather than as the focus of the film.
Collateral actually takes the time to tell a story, to which the action sequences are dramatic flourishes adjunct to the main story. They are integral to the story, given the nature of Cruise’s character, but do not overshadow it. In that regard it is particularly noteworthy, perhaps as much for what it indicates other movies lack as it is for its own high overall quality. It is a good action flick with an interesting tale and characters. The contrast in character between Cruise’s and Foxx’s characters is worth watching.
If you can find it playing near you, Zatoichi is the other action movie currently playing that stands apart from the pack. It is in Japanese with English subtitles. Perhaps because it is not a Hollywood movie, it doesn’t suffer from the usual Hollywood problems. It is very creative, though not to the extent of a Tarantino flick. The movie starts off as a samurai feature, but doesn’t stop there. If you like novelty in film, this one is worth a look. I’d like to discuss it more, but I would hate to spoil it. This is not your typical samurai movie. Very well made. Probably the best action movie of the summer, and I’d recommend it over Collateral. It is interesting to see the level of integration in the movie: action, plot, character, mystery, drama, comedy, music, dancing…
Happy movie watching!