Greetings,
I’m new to Objectivism, as a formal philosophy, but not in belief and practice.
Since become familiar with the formal philosophy, Ayn Rand and others I’ve been reading more on the subject. Two issues in particular have really bugged me as I’ve read through the online and printed material. I was hoping that folks could provide some insight on the positions, the justifications for the position and any links, quotes, etc that may be helpful.
Item 1
I’ve come across this quote in a few places and it really is bugging me - although I can’t figure out who wrote it.
“Reality, the external world, exists independent of man’s consciousness, independent of any observer’s knowledge, beliefs, feelings, desires or fears. This means that A is A, that facts are facts, that things are what they are—and that the task of man’s consciousness is to perceive reality, not to create or invent it.” Thus Objectivism rejects any belief in the supernatural—and any claim that individuals or groups create their own reality.
I’m completely comfortable with the first two sentences (ending with “.. not to create or invite it”). However, two items are particularly frustrating in the last sentence. The first is the use of the word “thus”. In this context and use the author is saying “for this reason” or “in light of the previous two sentences”. Yet, the conclusion reached is a leap of logic that, coming from an author who obviously esteems logic as much, if not more than me, is very hard to understand.
Rightly, the author states “the task of man’s consciousness is to perceive reality”. I can only assume that the author believes that this is done through man’s natural senses, cognition, reason, logic, etc. Yet, all of these things are natural (i.e. of nature) and are limited in their ability to perceive what is even here referred to as “above natural”. In other words, if man’s perception, cognition, reason and logic is limited to the natural, what use is it in the determination of the supernatural? It’s a bit like saying “If my thermostate cannot detect the barometric pressure we reject any belief in barometric pressure”. Or, it is very much like a fish declaring that a world outside his tank does not exist simply because the fish has not (and is incapable of) perceiving it.
Of course, the affirmation of the supernatural is equally problematic on these grounds.
Moreover, there is the difficulty related to proving a negative here.
Thus, does logic not demand agnosticism, not atheism?
Item 2
Secondly, I’ve always been pro-life on the grounds of what most here identify with objectivist core beliefs. Yet, I read that Rand supported abortion. I’m not really interested in debating abortion but more concerned with what I see, again, as a failure of logic. Rand seemed to side-step this issue by identifying the unborn baby / fetus as only a “potential” human and gives several, very weak arguments why. Any thoughts on this?
Thanks in advance!
DoxaPar