Understanding Causality

Hi, I believe this deserves its own topic, as my last question only partially goes over this. My question is, what is causality? What does it imply? Why is it important?

I really have no references in my mind when I bring this up, like I would have with identity, and would appreciate understasnding what this means. Thanks.

What is causality?

Causality is the concept which denotes the fact that things of a certain kind act a certain way.

“things of a certain kind” literally means a given thing’s, identity.

“act a certain way” literally means the identity of the behavior(s) resulting from a given thing’s, identity.

The identity of a thing’s behavior, following from and/or as a result of a thing’s nature.

If you want to understand this concept fully O’ist’s recommend taking a “causality walk”, which is to literally, go out and walk around looking for thing’s of a specific type and/or nature, behaving in certain ways because of their specific nature.

Regards,

Here’s a related quote from a member which is a good statement about causality.

Related O’ism Online Forum quote from member: Thomas M. Miovas, Jr.

I will add something that I think a lot of people overlook, and that is that causality is a corollary to identity: A thing is what it is and does what it does because it is what it is. In former philosophies, Aristotle and Aquinas, this was phrased as a thing acts according to its nature. But this can lead to confusions, especially rationalistic confusions, that somehow “its nature” is super-added to what a thing is. In Objectivism it is recognized that a thing is what it is,including everything that it is, and it being what it is brings about its capabilities – its potentials, if you will. A ball can roll because it is a ball and not a block of wood or not a glob of jelly or not a gas cloud, etc. It is what it is, and causality is a recognition of identity when a things acts or changes. That is, to underscore an ancient mistake, a thing does not become something different just because it changes – a ball does not become a not-ball just because it is set in motion. And when wood changes from wood to ash when it is burned, that burning and that transition is possible because it is wood.

In Objectivism, the axioms and their corollaries are given in perception as understood by a conceptual mind. A dog can see a ball rolling and chase after it, but it cannot grasp causality, which is a conceptual level integration of observations.

Regards,

Ok, so it seems like what the idea is, is when a thing acts or changes, it is still acting in accordance with its identity. So, a phone sitting staticly on a table is identity, while that phone dropping and shattering is causality (not a good examples because phones don’t usually shatter though)

I’ll have to try out that ‘causality walk’ next time I go for a walk. Sounds entertaining.

Here’s a related quote from a member which is a good statement about causality.

Related O’ism Online Forum quote from member: Thomas M. Miovas, Jr.

Regards,

Thanks. I also have written quite a bit about causality over the years. On my website, I have an elaboration of what I referred to in the above quote:

http://appliedphilosophyonline.com/causality.htm

Ok, so it seems like what the idea is, is when a thing acts or changes, it is still acting in accordance with its identity. So, a phone sitting staticly on a table is identity, while that phone dropping and shattering is causality (not a good examples because phones don’t usually shatter though)

Well, I would say… almost. But the phones behavior of “sitting” on the table is an action. Causality is not just about the physical movement of objects. The fact that its sits is an example of an entity of a certain kind acting a certain way. Because of the identity of the phone, the table, and the universe it is in, the phone sits there.

Just as the phone’s behavior of “falling” or “shattering” is due to its identity or nature. If the phone was instead a balloon, it would behave differently, but in accordance to its nature.

Pushing a ball makes it roll, but if the ball was filled with sand it would behave differently if left alone and/or if it interacts with other objects of a certain kind and/or identity.

Regards,

Also, it may not be helpful, but I like to think about the fact that even if objects are perceivably still like the phone sitting on the table, at our micro level, the entire system/planet is moving through space at thousands of miles an hour. The whole system, when conceived as a unity is an object of a certain kind acting a certain way, while at the same time each individual object making up the system, interact and behave in a manner in accordance with their nature. Everything is what it is (identity), and does what it does. (causality)

Warning: this does not invalidate human volition or freewill, and is not meant to imply the philosophy of “Determinism.” Consciousness when conceived as a unity is an object of a certain kind acting a certain way; i.e., consciousness is such a thing which has an identity which allows it to behave in a volitional manner. But that’s another topic.

What does it imply?

It implies a GREAT deal. Most of our plans we make and carry out, depend on and make our lives and/or the enhancement of our lives possible are statements about how to take advantage of things of a certain kind acting a certain way.

If we follow the rule of looking both ways before crossing the street; such a rule definitely helps keep us alive and makes possible the extension and enjoyment of our lives.

However, notice that such a rule is based on causality. My body is an object of a certain kind. Cars are entities of a certain kind, and when they interact under the conditions of crossing a street, bad things can result (injury, death).

But, those, “bad” things which can happen are expression of causality. The fact that a 1000 pound accelerated object running into us can damage our bodies, is due to the fact that the materials of our body, when conceived as a unity, is a composite object of a certain kind acting a certain way, when interacting with the other object, the car.

If our bodies were made of different materials, or the car’s materials were different, and/or if the environmental factors, conditions where different, the interactions would be different, as would the resulting expression of causality. E.g., a “car” made of balloons, such as a balloon float, running into us at 1 mile and hour is a very different set of objects of a certain kind, acting a certain way, in conjunction with each other.

The great divisions of subjects we study are nothing more than the formalized study of groupings of certain kinds of objects being examined to discover more about their identity, including the identity of their behaviors. E.g., biology, studies a certain subset of objects of a certain kind, living beings, while Geology another.

Philosophy, also studies an object(s) of a certain kind. It’s principle object of study, is man.

Each branch of philosophy studies aspects of man, his nature as a living being, and the universe where he lives.

Why is it important?

Causality is important because all our knowledge which helps us gain the food, clothing, shelter, friends, etc, which sustain and/or enhance our lives, are encoded expressions of aspects of causality, i.e., we form conceptual statements of our perceptions of objects of a certain kind acting and interacting in certain ways.

We use these statements to form plans to guide our lives.

The subject of morality in some sense is the science of values, and values are objects of a certain kind, which interact with us (men) in a certain way, such that they either sustain and/or enhance our lives.

Values are the necessary conditions for our lives, and we need values, because of our nature as living beings. We are a certain kind of thing, which acts a certain way, and part of that behavior gives rise to the need for sustenance both physical and mental. In other words, as men, we are objects of a certain kind, and thus we act a certain way.

Our livingness, because of what it is, has certain requirements, and when conceptualized, we call this class of objects of a certain kind: values.

We even go so far as to mentally project what kinds of attributes a object needs to have to enhance our lives and we construct it in that way, to give it the behavior we want. E.g., we make cars, clothes, containers, goods, and services, constructing them by making use of the expected behaviors the component objects a given product will have. A different make of tire, may act a certain better way, given our goals. A different fabric may be better in the cold weather, while another better for us in hot weather. Certain chemicals of a certain kind such as aspirin, when interacting with our bodies of a certain kind relieve pain, where as other chemicals kill us.

Therefore, to even ask what is important or not important, and why, is really asking about the “important” thing in questions nature/identity, in relation to our nature/identity as men. If the thing is found to be “important” then it is an object of a certain kind which acts in certain human life sustaining and beneficial ways when interacting with us as object of a certain kind.

Causality is “important” because the nature of causality, when conceived as a unity, is also an object of a certain kind acting a certain way; and the object of causality nature, as a concept gives rise to knowledge as such, which we as men need to sustain our lives.

sorry, please remove this post

I’ve had trouble understanding the meaning of the concept of causation in Objectivism too (and still have).

I hope my post is accepted in this topic, because I feel my question is not worth a topic of it’s own.

As far as I know causation and the law of identity say that a certain entity always acts according to it’s nature.

“Every entity has a nature; … it has certain attributes and no others. Such an entity must act in accordance with its nature. The only alternatives would be for an entity to act apart from its nature or against it; both of those are impossible. … In any given set of circumstances, therefore, there is only one action possible to an entity, the action expressive of its identity. This is the action it will take, the action that is caused and necessitated by its nature.” (Objectivism: the Philosophy of Ayn Rand, 14.) With a volitional being, being the only exception, because it can act in multiple ways.

My question now is, why (it seems) that Objectivism rejects the Coppenhagen-interpretation of quantum mechanics. The argument is, that the Coppenhagen-interpretation says that there are entities that can act in multiple ways in a certain set of circumstances, which violates the law of identity.

I fail to understand why this must be the case, when consciousness (or volition) is obviously not a violation of the law of identity.

Why can’t I just say, that it is the nature of an electron to “act in a stochastic way”?

Why can’t I just say, that it is the nature of an electron to “act in a stochastic way”?

You can. The problem is the particular version of Copenhagen that claims there is something special about the atoms that make up your brain that empower it to collapse wavefunctions, and that wavefunctions don’t collapse until a consciousness observes them. Schrödinger’s cat is quite capable of observing its own death, and for that matter so are the interior surfaces of Schrödinger’s box.

So the problem is, that Copenhagen claims, that there is no objective reality?

(By the way: How does Objectivism argue that reality must be objective?)

Couldn’t I still claim that it is simply the nature of elementary particles to act the way you described?

So the problem is, that Copenhagen claims, that there is no objective reality?

(By the way: How does Objectivism argue that reality must be objective?)

Couldn’t I still claim that it is simply the nature of elementary particles to act the way you described?

We know that reality is objective because we observe reality the way it really is – that is, reality is the standard of objective thought. It is not as if we come up with the rules of reality a priori to observing it and conceptualizing it; and we observe that reality is consistent.

The Copenhagen interpretation of QM mistakes an inability to measure within a certain accuracy (epistemology) with stating that a particle doesn’t have an identity within certain parameters (metaphysics). But we observe that a thing is what it is and acts the way it does because it is what it is; the fact that we cannot measure within a certain accuracy (using light and modern methods) does not make the particle not a particle. Of course, at this time, due to the measurement difficulties, we cannot exactly say what a particle is; but we can say that a particle cannot be both a particle and a wave at the same time and in the same respect (the law of non-contradiction). When one is at the outer edge of scientific discovery, some issues are unresolved, but reality is what it is and our uncertainty has no baring on the nature of reality (primacy of existence over primacy of consciousness).

We know that reality is objective because we observe reality the way it really is – that is, reality is the standard of objective thought. It is not as if we come up with the rules of reality a priori to observing it and conceptualizing it; and we observe that reality is consistent.

Isn’t that saying reality must be objective, because reality is objective? In other words I feel this is one of those things (like volition) that I would categorize as impossible to prove and/or disprove and more or less a matter of believe.

IE: I see no possible way to find a clear argument against someone who holds the contrary position and claims that reality is fundamentally tied to a subject and that the there will always be parts of reality that can not be described objectively without loosing or distorting information.

Further such a person will claim that QM is in fact proof of his position.

The Copenhagen interpretation of QM mistakes an inability to measure within a certain accuracy (epistemology) with stating that a particle doesn’t have an identity within certain parameters (metaphysics). But we observe that a thing is what it is and acts the way it does because it is what it is; the fact that we cannot measure within a certain accuracy (using light and modern methods) does not make the particle not a particle. Of course, at this time, due to the measurement difficulties, we cannot exactly say what a particle is; but we can say that a particle cannot be both a particle and a wave at the same time and in the same respect (the law of non-contradiction). When one is at the outer edge of scientific discovery, some issues are unresolved, but reality is what it is and our uncertainty has no baring on the nature of reality (primacy of existence over primacy of consciousness).

As far as I know (only through secondary literature), there is no scientific accepted theory that states that QM can be measured in a way comparable to the newton mechanics… I’m not really sure on this one.

Don’t have much time right now. I’ll post more later and hopefully I can order my thoughts properly.

Objectivity as it appears in Objectivism has almost nothing to do with physics. Objectivity is an epistemological principle which is derived from the ‘primacy of existence’ principle.

Illuminating a particle with a photon alters the particle. This can be described as the subject modifying the object and is technically accurate but it is a gross equivocation of the word ‘subject’ (as in logical fallacy: equivocation) to then switch contexts to the ordinary macroscopic non-quantum everyday life and insist conscious subjects have the power to alter the objects of consciousness. Magical thinking has nothing to do with physics.

You are completely free to explore any and all theories of physics without caring about philosophical incompatibility so long as a theory is consistent with itself, consistent with observation, and in its full implications results in the ordinary world we live in (this last is just a repetition of ‘consistent with observation’).

edit: added link