Voluntarily funded government

This is an interesting bit of information from wikipedia, it says that the oregon state government generated $604 million dollars through lottery alone. Maybe Rand was right about funding the government entirely off of lottery, heres the link. <a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oregon” target=“_blank”>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oregon</a>

No, not without force. A private lottery which keeps a smaller part of the money will drive the government’s lottery from the market.

I don’t support the idea of a government lottery. I don’t see why the government has any more business competing with private lottery companies than they do with other private businesses.

I don’t support the idea of a government lottery. I don’t see why the government has any more business competing with private lottery companies than they do with other private businesses.

I think a government lottery is perfectly fine so long as participation is voluntary and it is done on a not-for-profit basis for the sake of fund raising. No force is initiated in this context, not even against privately owned and operated lotteries.

I think a government lottery is perfectly fine so long as participation is voluntary and it is done on a not-for-profit basis for the sake of fund raising.

Okay, let’s pursue this. What about govenment-run TV and radio; water, gas, electric; groceries, hardware, shoes? In general, is it okay for government to engage in business as long as participation is voluntary and all profits are limited to whatever is necessary to run the government?

Okay, let’s pursue this. What about govenment-run TV and radio; water, gas, electric; groceries, hardware, shoes? In general, is it okay for government to engage in business as long as participation is voluntary and all profits are limited to whatever is necessary to run the government?

Fair enough question. Let me preface my response with that permitting government financing through a voluntary lottery is not a conviction of mine but just a mechanism that seems to be acceptable.

After cursory contemplation, my answer to your questions is no, primarily because the examples you have cited are not great vehicles for government fund raising. All of these entrepreneurial ventures would involve significant investments in infrastructure, personnel and resource procurement. Unlike a lottery, there is a considerable chance that these pursuits would not even generate a positive income. On the other hand, a lottery, if I am not mistaken, should be easy to run, low risk for the government and the accounting should be very transparent.

Needless to say, I see the principle you are driving towards.

What do you think?

After cursory contemplation, my answer to your questions is no, primarily because the examples you have cited are not great vehicles for government fund raising. All of these entrepreneurial ventures would involve significant investments in infrastructure, personnel and resource procurement.

I agree. These investments could only come from those funds reserved for the proper functions of government, thereby unnecessarily depleting those funds. Plus, you would be expecting government to do that which government does worst–outdo private industry. When the government shoe store closes because it puts out shoddy, inferior shoes, what then? Who would decide which boondoggle should be pursued next? And at what cost? Risks should be left to the entrepreneurs, not the state. As for lotteries, where gambling is not regulated or prohibited by the state, I wonder just how much interest there would be in state run lotteries anyway.

As for lotteries, where gambling is not regulated or prohibited by the state, I wonder just how much interest there would be in state run lotteries anyway.

Analogous to how a school or a church bake sale does not intend to compete with local bakeries, I think a government financing lottery would (and should) not seek to compete with the gambling industry. Thus, the participants in such a lottery would not be primarily motivated from enthusiasm for gambling but from interest in donating more money for a (hopefully legitimate) government venture.

Needless to say, I see the principle you are driving towards.

What do you think?

The obvious answer is a combination of voluntary contributions and recovery from violators (i.e. asset seizure from rights-violators). As far as investment, management and infrastructurial issues go, a realistic version of a state lottery involves substantial infrastructure, unless tickets are only sold in the State Lottery Office downtown. There are substantial insurance, ticket creation and distribution issues that aren’t free (and are necessary because of the fraud problem and the need to insure against erroneously selling 1,000 winning numbers). So I’m not sure that running a lottery is cheaper than selling milk.

I’m trying to identify the essential principle regarding the proper means of government financing. Obvious being voluntary is a sine qua non. The principle which I would offer is that government should not compete with private business, that the proper spheres of government and the free market do not overlap, which is because of the nature of government (the nature of government is entirely different from the nature of free trade). The alternative, whereby government is allowed to compete with business, seems to me to make government just be a special case of business: it’s a business which in addition to ordinary free trade activities, has a monopoly right to the use of force in protection of rights.

This can lead to some major problems of conflict of interest; the government is entering into voluntary business contracts with individuals, but at the same time is also charged with the obligation to make decisions as to what those contracts require. You surely wouldn’t enter into a contract with a company if the company had the sole discretion to interpret and enforce the terms of the contract. So that would mean, to extend that principle to adjudication of governmental profit-making contracts, that there should be an objective government within a government which enforces contracts. That’s rather messy, and these problems do not arise if we recognise that the nature of governemnt is entirely different from the nature of business, and that government should not compete with business for goods and services at all.

DarkWaters, what makes a government run lottery different from any other government run business?

The obvious answer is a combination of voluntary contributions and recovery from violators (i.e. asset seizure from rights-violators).

…government should not compete with business for goods and services at all.

If the gov’t seizes assets from rights-violators, do you think the gov’t should sell those assets? If so, wouldn’t that be taking part in business for goods and services?

If the gov’t seizes assets from rights-violators, do you think the gov’t should sell those assets? If so, wouldn’t that be taking part in business for goods and services?

But the state would not be involved in the manufacture and production of new products, just the sale of used/like new products. It would be the equivalent of an estate sale. While that may pose some sort of competition to, say, the neighborhood Walmart, it is not the same as opening a Govmart to engage Walmart in direct competition.

I was just wondering how Objectivism takes in to account the economic free rider problem when it comes to a voluntary funded government.

Wikipedia link to refresher on what a free rider is

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_rider_problem

I was just wondering how Objectivism takes in to account the economic free rider problem when it comes to a voluntary funded government.

I haven’t seen a clearly Objectivist discussion of the matter, but I don’t see that it’s a problem. What if we rename it the “free rider possibility”? Does that help?

DarkWaters, what makes a government run lottery different from any other government run business?

Please see my answer here.

The obvious answer is a combination of voluntary contributions and recovery from violators (i.e. asset seizure from rights-violators). As far as investment, management and infrastructurial issues go, a realistic version of a state lottery involves substantial infrastructure, unless tickets are only sold in the State Lottery Office downtown. There are substantial insurance, ticket creation and distribution issues that aren’t free (and are necessary because of the fraud problem and the need to insure against erroneously selling 1,000 winning numbers). So I’m not sure that running a lottery is cheaper than selling milk.

I’m trying to identify the essential principle regarding the proper means of government financing. Obvious being voluntary is a sine qua non. The principle which I would offer is that government should not compete with private business, that the proper spheres of government and the free market do not overlap, which is because of the nature of government (the nature of government is entirely different from the nature of free trade). The alternative, whereby government is allowed to compete with business, seems to me to make government just be a special case of business: it’s a business which in addition to ordinary free trade activities, has a monopoly right to the use of force in protection of rights.

This can lead to some major problems of conflict of interest; the government is entering into voluntary business contracts with individuals, but at the same time is also charged with the obligation to make decisions as to what those contracts require. You surely wouldn’t enter into a contract with a company if the company had the sole discretion to interpret and enforce the terms of the contract. So that would mean, to extend that principle to adjudication of governmental profit-making contracts, that there should be an objective government within a government which enforces contracts. That’s rather messy, and these problems do not arise if we recognise that the nature of governemnt is entirely different from the nature of business, and that government should not compete with business for goods and services at all.

There are two important issues in your post that I would like to explore. First, how cheap is it to have a state-run lottery? Second, and more importantly, does a state-run lottery truly compete with the private lottery market?

I am not really sure how to answer the first question. Although it was just a side comment, I would surmise that running a lottery for the purpose of raising voluntary funds is cheaper and less risky on a per capita basis than being a vertically integrated producer and distributor of milk. Milk production involves significant investments in both land and livestock. The cost of each are highly dependent on several other sectors of the agricultural market. For example corn, as it is a significant component to cattle feed. It also involves bulk transportation of a commodity with specific refridgeration requirements (thus, special transportation containers are required) as well as significant inventory planning as milk is highly perishable. Finally, given the serious threat of milk supply-chains being tainted with botulinum toxin, the cost of milk is most likely going to increase from homeland security precautions. But I digress for no great reason.

I am not really sure how to answer the second question either. If a school offers a bake sale as a fundraiser, does it necessarily compete with local bakeries? My guess is no, mainly because the customers who purchase baked goods from a school bake sale are not primarily there to purchase pastries but instead want to help the school. The pastry is just a side benefit. Analogously, my perception of a state-run lottery is not meant to appeal to citizens who primarily want to buy lottery tickets but instead to those who just want to contribute to the government.

Does this make it clear that a state-run lottery is permissable under laissez-faire capitalism? Certainly not to me. I am still exploring this idea. It still seems as if this system would always be less moral than a system where funds were raised without the use of a lottery.

If I remember correctly, in Ayn Rand’s essay Government Financing in a Free Society, Ms. Rand expresses that a lottery would be an acceptable way to raise government funds. I assume that when she wrote this she had an idea how this could be done without violating anyone’s rights. Needless to say, I am not trying to advance an argument from authority. Instead, I am just citing my motivation for wanting to explore this idea further.

I was just wondering how Objectivism takes in to account the economic free rider problem when it comes to a voluntary funded government.

If there is good reason to believe that individuals are “free riding” under laissez-faire capitalism, perhaps the amount of each individual’s contribution could be made publically available? Individuals who would try “free riding”, that is contribute less than the monetary equivalent value of maintaining a government actually is to them, might otherwise be less inclined to undercontribute if others could see the level of their donations.

Needless to say, this is another example of why ethics is a more fundamental branch of philosophy than politics. Voluntary financing of government will not work if most individuals think it is morally acceptable to unconditionally receive government protection at someone else’s expense.

I was just wondering how Objectivism takes in to account the economic free rider problem when it comes to a voluntary funded government.

Wikipedia link to refresher on what a free rider is

<a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_rider_problem” target=“_blank”>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_rider_problem</a>

Freerider problem will not apply if all parties agree that the government holds the monopoly of using force.

Not everyone profits equally from a voluntarily funded government, companies with a large business volume profit more from a properly funded government than the rest.

The more income a company has, the more transactions it will do, the more property it owns, the larger is the incentive to donate in order to have a functioning government. The larger the company is, the more it is dependent on voluntary trade, i.e. it can’t start openly using force or violate the agreement that the government holds the monopoly of using force.

This of course applies only to proper governments which do not redistribute the money but instead invest it in the three branches of government. When, through a democratic process, the government decides to spend the money on some other things, the donations will decrease.

Freerider problem will not apply if all parties agree that the government holds the monopoly of using force.

Perhaps I am mistaken, but I believe the question was along the lines of how a laissez-faire capitalist state would handle individuals who depend on the government for protection but refuse to donate to sustain it.

If there is good reason to believe that individuals are “free riding” under laissez-faire capitalism, perhaps the amount of each individual’s contribution could be made publically available? Individuals who would try “free riding”, that is contribute less than the monetary equivalent value of maintaining a government actually is to them, might otherwise be less inclined to undercontribute if others could see the level of their donations.

Needless to say, this is another example of why ethics is a more fundamental branch of philosophy than politics. Voluntary financing of government will not work if most individuals think it is morally acceptable to unconditionally receive government protection at someone else’s expense.

The social ostracism method. I would think this might work on a local level, in smaller communities, but I think it is possible for the accepted “normal” government contribution to vary over larger regions around the country. It would depend on the ability for people, or groups of people. to rationalize their behavior. And most important of all, it would depend on full public disclosure of your income in order to know whether someone’s contribution was adequate.

But the state would not be involved in the manufacture and production of new products, just the sale of used/like new products.

Lots of businesses don’t manufacture their own products. They acquire other people’s products. The only difference from that and gov’t selling those seized items is the way they are acquired.

Maybe DavidOdden would be kind enough to explain to me why selling assets that the gov’t seized from rights-violators isn’t an act of competition with business for goods and services. Pretty please.

There are two important issues in your post that I would like to explore. First, how cheap is it to have a state-run lottery? Second, and more importantly, does a state-run lottery truly compete with the private lottery market?

  1. I would surmise that running a lottery for the purpose of raising voluntary funds is cheaper and less risky on a per capita basis than being a vertically integrated producer and distributor of milk.

  2. my perception of a state-run lottery is not meant to appeal to citizens who primarily want to buy lottery tickets but instead to those who just want to contribute to the government. (Little competition to private businesses)

Does this make it clear that a state-run lottery is permissable under laissez-faire capitalism? Certainly not to me. I am still exploring this idea. It still seems as if this system would always be less moral than a system where funds were raised without the use of a lottery.

Before exploring the detailed details, the first and foremost thing you need to figure out is a rational principle that a govt run lottery would be based upon. The principles you have implied so far are, 1)if the govt business costs X and projected sales are X, 2)if the govt business doesn’t cause much competition for private businesses. Those obviously are not sound because other govt businesses could easily be created on those same principles, which would just cause the laissez-faire society to become non-existent.

Maybe DavidOdden would be kind enough to explain to me why selling assets that the gov’t seized from rights-violators isn’t an act of competition with business for goods and services.

There’s no business of “seizing and selling goods”.