There’s no business of “seizing and selling goods”.
Well what exactly is the best definition for ‘business?’ I’m searching around but I’m having a hard time piecing that together.
There’s no business of “seizing and selling goods”.
Well what exactly is the best definition for ‘business?’ I’m searching around but I’m having a hard time piecing that together.
Before exploring the detailed details, the first and foremost thing you need to figure out is a rational principle that a govt run lottery would be based upon.
The principle is that in a laissez-faire society, government funding should be voluntary. The issue is if voluntary funding that takes place in the form of a charity lottery is a moral mechanism for collecting such funding.
The principles you have implied so far are, 1)if the govt business costs X and projected sales are X, 2)if the govt business doesn’t cause much competition for private businesses. Those obviously are not sound because other govt businesses could easily be created on those same principles, which would just cause the laissez-faire society to become non-existent.
These are not principles and they were not implied by me. Besides, you are dropping the context that this is intended to be a charitable lottery, not any arbitrary business venture.
Perhaps there is legitimate confusion on this thread because different individuals have different perspectives on what a state-run lottery for the purposes of fund-raising implies. I can try to clarify this in a future post.
And most important of all, it would depend on full public disclosure of your income in order to know whether someone’s contribution was adequate.
This could be true. If so, then full disclosure of contributions would not work as an individual’s income is his own private matter. I think the real solution to the free rider problem under laissez-faire capitalism is a wide acceptance of the Objectivist ethics. Individuals should not want a free ride in such a society.
The principle is that in a laissez-faire society, government funding should be voluntary. The issue is if voluntary funding that takes place in the form of a charity lottery is a moral mechanism for collecting such funding.
Oh, I see. I’ve just started studying these terms, so sorry for the wrongful use. The latter would be considered a derivative then, right?
These are not principles and they were not implied by me. Besides, you are dropping the context that this is intended to be a charitable lottery, not any arbitrary business venture.
My point was that if the gov’t can run a lottery on those terms, then that would be grounds for other gov’t businesses to be created. Do you agree?
There’s no business of “seizing and selling goods”.
True, but if you break that down into its primitives, “seizing” and “selling,” you see that the seizing part is not competitive; the selling part is.
Not that I disagree with the concept, or see any downside to having the government compete *on an equal footing* with private businesses. (Or am I missing something?)
How do you all feel about the idea that a monetary system is crucial for the effective exchange of value. Would it be in keeping with objectivist tenets to see the availability of standard, trustworthy money as providing value to the exchangers, and that it is proper to pay for that value, in the form of exchange taxes?
Since any exchange on the market involves a mutual benefit, due in large part to the free method of exchange, is it morally defensible to tax a portion of that benefit in exchange for the proper government roles that make that stable money possible (including enforcement of individual rights and defense against foreign aggressors)?
Of course this opens up further questions, like is it reasonable for a government to be given the sole authority for providing stable money (in addition to using force)?
Not that I (…) see any downside to having the government compete *on an equal footing* with private businesses. (Or am I missing something?)
What you are missing is that to compete on an equal footing, a government would have to cease acting like a government (i.e. not wield force). At that point it becomes only a business with incredibly high fixed costs - since you are trying to finance the actual government out of the same profits your competitors pocket and reinvest.
What you are missing is that to compete on an equal footing, a government would have to cease acting like a government (i.e. not wield force). At that point it becomes only a business with incredibly high fixed costs - since you are trying to finance the actual government out of the same profits your competitors pocket and reinvest.
That’s what I was implying by “equal footing”: no force against private competitors. Government could probably make a go at competing in this case, because their fixed costs would in fact be very low - staff to seize, staff to sell, no production costs - so most of the price would go to gov’t “profit.”
Well what exactly is the best definition for ‘business?’
Buying, selling, or trading goods or services on a continuous basis as a means for gain/profit. Does anyone see anything wrong with this definition?
How about the dictionary definition: A commercial, industrial or professional enterprise or establishment.
My point was that if the gov’t can run a lottery on those terms, then that would be grounds for other gov’t businesses to be created. Do you agree?
If your question is:
“If the state is permitted to run a lottery at a sure profit for the sole purpose of raising funds and that it did not compete with any private enterprises, would that make any state-run, not-for-profit venture morally permissible so long as profitability was almost certain?”
Then my answer is absolutely not. Even if a state-run lottery is acceptable (I am still ruminating over it myself), that does not give the government a blank check to do whatever it can to maximize its revenue. A state-run lottery would presumably (in a quasi laissez-faire society) be to fund a proper function of government. Government should not be expanded just because it can.
If your question is:
“If the state is permitted to run a lottery at a sure profit for the sole purpose of raising funds and that it did not compete with any private enterprises, would that make any state-run, not-for-profit venture morally permissible so long as profitability was almost certain?”
Then my answer is absolutely not. Even if a state-run lottery is acceptable (I am still ruminating over it myself), that does not give the government a blank check to do whatever it can to maximize its revenue. A state-run lottery would presumably (in a quasi laissez-faire society) be to fund a proper function of government. Government should not be expanded just because it can.
I’m glad you agree with that, but my question, to be more exact, is, “What grounds could a gov’t lottery be created on that wouldn’t have some loopholes which would allow other gov’t businesses to be created on?” Hypothetically(and based on what you have said), the gov’t lottery would be created on the grounds that it is a sure profit and a means to generate revenue for the gov’t. Given that, why couldn’t a multitude of gov’t businesses be created on those grounds? You know how politicians are.
Also, if you think the gov’t lottery wouldn’t need to compete with other companies because the majority of buyers of their lottery tickets main intention is to fund the gov’t, why is the lottery needed at all? Why not just have donations?
“What grounds could a gov’t lottery be created on that wouldn’t have some loopholes which would allow other gov’t businesses to be created on?” Hypothetically(and based on what you have said), the gov’t lottery would be created on the grounds that it is a sure profit and a means to generate revenue for the gov’t. Given that, why couldn’t a multitude of gov’t businesses be created on those grounds? You know how politicians are.
This sounds like a question for legal experts. At the very least, legislation could explicitly codify a specific, well-delineated lottery as opposed to making broader statements that are easily contorted to allow runaway government expansion.
Please keep in mind that designing mechanisms to permit the voluntarily financing a government would most likely be step 99 in a 100 step process of transitioning to laissez-faire Capitalism. If Objectivist ethics are not generally accepted, which would be the case if there was great risk of elected politicians attempting to champion unnecessary government expansion, then discussing how to voluntarily fund government should not be at the top of the agenda.
Also, if you think the gov’t lottery wouldn’t need to compete with other companies because the majority of buyers of their lottery tickets main intention is to fund the gov’t, why is the lottery needed at all? Why not just have donations?
I think straight donations would be better. However, a lottery, if properly done, could be a possible alternative if the level of donations is truly inadequate to run a just government. A similar rhetorical question would be, why have a city police force if everyone is going to be rational and not violate anyone else’s rights?
This sounds like a question for legal experts. At the very least, legislation could explicitly codify a specific, well-delineated lottery as opposed to making broader statements that are easily contorted to allow runaway government expansion.
Please keep in mind that designing mechanisms to permit the voluntarily financing a government would most likely be step 99 in a 100 step process of transitioning to laissez-faire Capitalism. If Objectivist ethics are not generally accepted, which would be the case if there was great risk of elected politicians attempting to champion unnecessary government expansion, then discussing how to voluntarily fund government should not be at the top of the agenda.
I think straight donations would be better. However, a lottery, if properly done, could be a possible alternative if the level of donations is truly inadequate to run a just government. A similar rhetorical question would be, why have a city police force if everyone is going to be rational and not violate anyone else’s rights?
A gov’t lottery, to be profitable, would require laws to prevent private businesses from competing in the lottery business. What would be the justification for this use of force to limit ostensibly legitimate business?
Voluntary donations are problematic. From game theory you quickly find that most people will try to give less than the average, if anything at all.
An exchange tax could work, but then you would find that all black-market products (prosties, drugs, etc.) would be purchased with pre-tax dollars.
The only answer I can think of is to make public, and easily discoverable, the amount of donations each person/business makes. Then you can support your gov’t with your purchases, hiring decision, friendships, job searches, etc. Anyone not paying a fair share would be shunned, but only if the majority found that donated dollars were well spent.
Voluntary donations are problematic. From game theory you quickly find that most people will try to give less than the average, if anything at all.
The only answer I can think of is to make public, and easily discoverable, the amount of donations each person/business makes. Then you can support your gov’t with your purchases, hiring decision, friendships, job searches, etc. Anyone not paying a fair share would be shunned, but only if the majority found that donated dollars were well spent.
If the people in the society recognize the necessity for a proper gov’t then I don’t see how there would be under-funding from voluntary donations and seizures. I’m not sure if the records would be public or not, but I don’t think making them public for the reason to try to humiliate people is a very good idea.
I’m wondering, given those two ways to fund the gov’t(voluntary contributions and seizure), if this somehow didn’t raise enough money to fund a complete gov’t, does that society even deserve a proper gov’t? The majority isn’t showing interest in the gov’t necessity, so why should the gov’t go out of its way to exist? The gov’t doesn’t exist for the sake of itself, it exists for the people.
A gov’t lottery, to be profitable, would require laws to prevent private businesses from competing in the lottery business. What would be the justification for this use of force to limit ostensibly legitimate business?
Voluntary donations are problematic. From game theory you quickly find that most people will try to give less than the average, if anything at all.
An exchange tax could work, but then you would find that all black-market products (prosties, drugs, etc.) would be purchased with pre-tax dollars.
The only answer I can think of is to make public, and easily discoverable, the amount of donations each person/business makes. Then you can support your gov’t with your purchases, hiring decision, friendships, job searches, etc. Anyone not paying a fair share would be shunned, but only if the majority found that donated dollars were well spent.
All of these points (i.e., would a state-run lottery need to compete with a private lottery, dealing with “free riders” and disclosing contributions to the government) have already been addressed earlier in this thread. If you have questions on the previous discussion, I am sure someone will be happy to further explore the issues with you. However, please do not expect the same responses to be reiterated here.
I’m wondering, given those two ways to fund the gov’t(voluntary contributions and seizure), if this somehow didn’t raise enough money to fund a complete gov’t, does that society even deserve a proper gov’t? The majority isn’t showing interest in the gov’t necessity, so why should the gov’t go out of its way to exist? The gov’t doesn’t exist for the sake of itself, it exists for the people.
I would say no, meaning that even if a population of individuals will not voluntarily contribute enough money to support a just government, they still might be deserving of a rights-protecting institution that has a monopoly on the retaliatory use of force. Most likely strictly voluntary government financing would not work until there is another philosophical revolution where Objectivism becomes widespread amongst the general populace. But even today in the United States, property rights are still generally respected, there is freedom of speech, most people are still decent to eachother; this country is still deserving of a rights-respecting government.
Even in a near laissez-faire capitalist society, I am sure there will be individuals (e.g., Market Anarchists, Conspiracy theorists, etc.) who would still refuse the fund the government for a wide variety of reasons.
All of these points (i.e., would a state-run lottery need to compete with a private lottery, dealing with “free riders” and disclosing contributions to the government) have already been addressed earlier in this thread. If you have questions on the previous discussion, I am sure someone will be happy to further explore the issues with you. However, please do not expect the same responses to be reiterated here.
Thanks. (newbie)
So, this is an intractable problem so far. Rand’s solutions don’t seem workable; even Greenspan gave this particular issue as his one reason for disagreeing with Objectivism.
It sounds like we haven’t yet discovered the principles under which gov’t should properly be funded. Voluntary donations seem at odds with Objectivism’s enlightened self-interest. It seems that any solution would base payment on the value on receives from proper government, and the cost one incurs on others through your violation of their individual rights. Not paying at all could be construed as taking value from others (by accepting the value of government resources that they paid for), which could be grounds for retaliatory force.
An analogy would be an honor-system store, where you pay whatever you think is a fair price for your purchases. If you walk out without paying, you’re not technically breaking the rules, but you are stealing. The punishment would be banishment from the store. Would a proper objectivist government consider banishment from a country as the means of enforcing “voluntary” contributions? It certainly would put pressure on other governments to establish similar principles.
Voluntary donations seem at odds with Objectivism’s enlightened self-interest.
That’s a claim you need to support with some sort of argument.
Are you saying that there no instances in history where people have volunteered to do things for their country, or give money to support their country, or buy war bonds that they were not sure would be repaid, or build ships and give them to their country’s navy, and such things?
So, this is an intractable problem so far.
Not really. I think it’s solved already.
Not paying at all could be construed as taking value from others (by accepting the value of government resources that they paid for), which could be grounds for retaliatory force.
If someone can afford to contribute money to the gov’t and they want their rights protected, then they probably should give some. However, there wouldn’t be valid grounds for retaliatory force against the people who don’t contribute. Those people aren’t stealing(legally speaking). They aren’t violating anyone’s rights.
I can hardly drive a mile without seeing a church. I often wonder how much money goes into building all these (in my view, redundant) churchs for all sorts of denominations. Yet, people give willingly. There is much evidence to suggest that people will support causes that they support, not just with words, but also with deeds and cash.
Similarly, look at the universities with their huge endowments. Why, even look at the money that people like Gates spend on far off Africa. Surely it’s obvious that people would give their own security (via government) a higher priority in their lives.
If someone can afford to contribute money to the gov’t and they want their rights protected, then they probably should give some. However, there wouldn’t be valid grounds for retaliatory force against the people who don’t contribute. Those people aren’t stealing(legally speaking). They aren’t violating anyone’s rights.
I once heard Craig Biddle in a speech recommend “vouchers” for people or companies that donated money to the government. A restaurant could hang it on the wall to show that they were supporting the protection of rights and so forth. The hope(and I believe it is justified) is that the resultant social and economic sanctions of customers would pressure profitable companies to realize how tied their profits were to the protection of liberty-economic and otherwise. So a successful restaurant would be expected(not required) to donate while a starving college student would not be held irresponsible for not contributing. Customers who liked freedom could vote with their dollars to pressure continuance. This of course is all dependent on having a mostly rational populace, which is what would be required to get anywhere near laissez faire in the first place.