How are mind and body related?
:lol:
How are mind and body related?
:lol:
How are mind and body related?
:lol:
That they are inseperable.
Do you have something in particular that you want to know?
Is the mind free and the body free? Or is just the mind free and the body determined? Or? I just want a good general explanation of what it means to be a mind-body.
That they are inseperable.
Do you have something in particular that you want to know?
Is the mind free and the body free? Or is just the mind free and the body determined? Or? I just want a good general explanation of what it means to be a mind-body.
Actually they seem to be reciprically determining. The mind can command the body to perform actions and the body through the diet it is fed, illness it experiences, fluctuations in hormone levels, etc can impact the mind. Although this is more psychology then objectivism(Philosophy).
The mind body dichotomy that objectivism usually is referring to is best understood by examining the rationalism vs empiricism debate. Is that what you are looking for?
How can mind be determined by body, and body determined by mind? Isn’t that a contridiction?
Actually they seem to be reciprically determining. The mind can command the body to perform actions and the body through the diet it is fed, illness it experiences, fluctuations in hormone levels, etc can impact the mind. Although this is more psychology then objectivism(Philosophy).
The mind body dichotomy that objectivism usually is referring to is best understood by examining the rationalism vs empiricism debate. Is that what you are looking for?
How can mind be determined by body, and body determined by mind? Isn’t that a contridiction?
No…different things entirely. If I tell my body to bang my head with a hammer, my mind is commanding my body to act. The resulting damage to my brain could very well affect how my mind then operates.
Where in there is free will? It could have been that you’re just doing what you’re doing because you have brain damage then right?
No…different things entirely. If I tell my body to bang my head with a hammer, my mind is commanding my body to act. The resulting damage to my brain could very well affect how my mind then operates.
Where in there is free will? It could have been that you’re just doing what you’re doing because you have brain damage then right?
To clarify, this is not objectivism that I am presenting.
That being said I do not find it to be incompatible with freewill. If you eat a lot of sugar, serotonin will be relaesed in your blood stream and your mind will feel tired. The fact that physical factors have an impact on your mental experience does not mean that it is determined. You still choose to eat sugar or not. It’s impact may or may not reinforce the behavior by being pleasurable or painful(the psychological theory of reciprocol determinsim should not be confused with philosophic determinsim)
The mind is the experienced aspect of what the brain is doing. The process of thinking and choosing affects the chemistry of it just as external(to the brain) factors can affect what it experiences. Drugs, brain surgery, experiences, etc can alter what the mind percieves.
Where in there is free will? It could have been that you’re just doing what you’re doing because you have brain damage then right?
That is possible in particular circumstances. Here is a very well known case where that occured:
How are mind and body related?
The correct answer, bearing in mind the topic title that you chose (you’re asking a question about Objectivism), comes from the writings of Ayn Rand. See Censorship: Local And Express–Part III:
and
Also see John Galt’s speech in Atlas Shrugged for a very nice treatment of this subject.