My question is: How do you know that you are, in fact, an Objectivist? I am aware that Objectivism is “the philosophy of Ayn Rand” and that an Objectivist must agree with all parts of Objectivism. But how do you know what all the parts of Objectivism are? Is there a single officially approved list of tenets somewhere or did you have to go through everything Ayn Rand ever wrote and agree with every single sentence?
My question is: How do you know that you are, in fact, an Objectivist? I am aware that Objectivism is “the philosophy of Ayn Rand” and that an Objectivist must agree with all parts of Objectivism. But how do you know what all the parts of Objectivism are? Is there a single officially approved list of tenets somewhere or did you have to go through everything Ayn Rand ever wrote and agree with every single sentence?
That’s a good point. I believe that it’s a matter of what’s in OPAR. Have you read that far?
My question is: How do you know that you are, in fact, an Objectivist? I am aware that Objectivism is “the philosophy of Ayn Rand” and that an Objectivist must agree with all parts of Objectivism. But how do you know what all the parts of Objectivism are? Is there a single officially approved list of tenets somewhere or did you have to go through everything Ayn Rand ever wrote and agree with every single sentence?
How do I know I am Objectivist?
It is enough to pursue your goals in life while allowing others to do the same.
What all the parts of Objectivism are?
You just have to know those:
Metaphysics and three aksioms(existence, identity, consciousness);
Ethics(egoism as the moral ideal, not being driven by emotions);
Politics(free economy, Capitalism);
Aestethics(art is the way to show what you see/how you feel about something, etc, not for propaganda)
A list of approved tenets?
Where is one somewhere, Ayn Rand said it at the Interview with the Playboy magazine, if I remember well.
It’s only my opinion, as I am a bit green in Objectivism myself, it can be inaccurate.
Metaphysics and three aksioms(existence, identity, consciousness);
Ethics(egoism as the moral ideal, not being driven by emotions);
Politics(free economy, Capitalism);
Aestethics(art is the way to show what you see/how you feel about something, etc, not for propaganda)
Don’t forget Epistemology: Reason. It derives from metaphysics but is nonetheless important to identify.
Don’t forget Epistemology: Reason. It derives from metaphysics but is nonetheless important to identify.
Thanks for reminding me.
But the name of the forum thread is a bit tricky. Objectivists use reason to accept the Objectivism philosophy, they don’t believe in anything. That’s why Objectivism only works for atheists, because belief saves you from thinking.
How do I know I am Objectivist?
It is enough to pursue your goals in life while allowing others to do the same.
What all the parts of Objectivism are?
You just have to know those:
Metaphysics and three aksioms(existence, identity, consciousness);
Ethics(egoism as the moral ideal, not being driven by emotions);
Politics(free economy, Capitalism);
Aestethics(art is the way to show what you see/how you feel about something, etc, not for propaganda)
A list of approved tenets?
Where is one somewhere, Ayn Rand said it at the Interview with the Playboy magazine, if I remember well.
It’s only my opinion, as I am a bit green in Objectivism myself, it can be inaccurate.
I think this is a better summary:
Metaphysics - objective reality, A is A (based on the three axioms you mentioned)
Epistemology - reason as the means of percieving reality and that reality is knowable(um, is that a proper word?)
Ethics - selfishness, that every man lives for himself with his own hapiness as the moral purpose of his life
Politics - capitalism, only moral system which acknowledges man’s rights
Aestethics - romatic realism; art is recreation of reality that reflects the artists value judgement, romantic realism recreates the world as it could and should be
But how do you know what all the parts of Objectivism are? Is there a single officially approved list of tenets somewhere or did you have to go through everything Ayn Rand ever wrote and agree with every single sentence?
You certainly don’t need to agree with every single sentence that Rand ever wrote. Rand wrote a lot of stuff that isn’t philosophy – e.g. her discussions of sexual psychology, or her talks on how to write non-fiction, or her love of the New York skyline, or her personal artistic preferences. Objectivism is a system of philosophy, and to agree with it you have to understand and agree with the principles that make it up.
That issue of understanding is an important one, and is key to why there isn’t a simple list like “the 27 principles that make up Objectivism”. Context is important. Take a principle like “Selfishness is a virtue.” In isolation, that could mean a wide number of things. To know what it means and how to apply it you need to understand where that idea came from and why it’s true, and you can’t get that from a list.
OPAR is the closest thing in print to what you seem to want – an end-to-end presentation of the essential principles of Objectivism along with their validations. But even that is really Peikoff’s interpretation of Rand’s philosophy. If you’re early in the study of Rand’s philosophy, I wouldn’t worry too much about self-description. Work on getting a first-handed grasp of the ideas, and on using them to improve your own life. Let other people worry about classifying you.
Thanks for reminding me.
But the name of the forum thread is a bit tricky. Objectivists use reason to accept the Objectivism philosophy, they don’t believe in anything. That’s why Objectivism only works for atheists, because belief saves you from thinking.
I think generally this is true, but if we *believe* anything, we believe the three axioms. The entire philosophy starts there, and those three axioms are taken as given, which amounts to about the same thing as belief.
[…] those three axioms are taken as given, which amounts to about the same thing as belief.
That does not sound right… What do you mean by “taken as a given” and what do you mean by “belief”?
I think generally this is true, but if we *believe* anything, we believe the three axioms. The entire philosophy starts there, and those three axioms are taken as given, which amounts to about the same thing as belief.
They are validated ostensibly, that is, by direct sensory perception. They are NOT taken as belief.
That does not sound right… What do you mean by “taken as a given” and what do you mean by “belief”?
Probably the wrong things ![]()
Taken as a given means what it means in any logical proof. “Given that X, Y and z and Q and R”. X is treated as true for the purpose of the argument.
By belief, I mean we don’t doubt or dispute them, because they are self-evident. However, despite their self-evidence, there are those who dispute them.
I’d agree that people dispute them, but they also dispute that there is a god, we still count ourselves as knowing the truth in that regard. I’d also like to add that aesthetically Objectivists think that Romantic realism is beautiful and artful, not all of use deny or dislike other genres of art, as they can also be used to get a literary point across.
By belief, I mean we don’t doubt or dispute them, because they are self-evident. However, despite their self-evidence, there are those who dispute them.
Actually I’m not sure they are self-evident. The only thing that strikes me as self-evident are sensory perceptions.
The three fundamental axioms:
Existence ( it is )
Consciousness ( I know it is)
Identity (I know what it is )
They are self evident. In order to prove any of them, you would have to be accepting them. Sensory perception is also self evident, because–again–you would have to accept it in order to prove (or disprove) it.
I believe, and please correct me if I’m wrong, that the order is important.
Doesn’t putting consciousness before identity carry an implication of primacy? That knowledge that it is precedes its identity?
I have always heard it put as:
-
Existence (it is)
-
Identity (it is WHAT it is and nothing else)
-
Consciousness (I know what it is)
That implicitly would seem to say that our consciousness is not necessary in determining what it is, it is what it is whether we are conscious of it or not, and even if nothing lived to be conscious of it, it will still be what it is, and nothing else.
The three fundamental axioms:
Existence ( it is )
Consciousness ( I know it is)
Identity (I know what it is )
They are self evident. In order to prove any of them, you would have to be accepting them. Sensory perception is also self evident, because–again–you would have to accept it in order to prove (or disprove) it.
“Self-evident” means “evident without proof or reasoning”. These axioms require proof and reason; therefore, they are not self-evident.
“Self-evident” means “evident without proof or reasoning”. These axioms require proof and reason; therefore, they are not self-evident.
Peikoff is quite clear in OPAR that he considers the axioms self-evident. They cannot be demonstrated through proof and reason because proof and reason are processes whose validity presupposes the axioms. The axioms are conceptualizations of direct sensory awarenesses. How do you know that existence exists? Simply through your awareness of existence.
“Nothing is self-evident except the material of sensory perception.” - Rand
This quote is from Philosophy:Who Needs It? by Rand. Maybe I’m wrong here. Not sure…
This quote is from Philosophy:Who Needs It? by Rand. Maybe I’m wrong here. Not sure…
I think that quote is proving khaight’s point.
existence exists - no need for proof
Identity - A rock is a rock a plant is a plant again there is no need to prove that things are what they are.
consciousness - acknowledging either of the first two means accepting the validity of the third without proof.
I agree with you Zip, but I would rather have stated that:
Existense exists, and existense is identity.
That is, when we observe that existense exists we also observe that it is something which exists.
I believe, and please correct me if I’m wrong, that the order is important.
That’s why I prefer saying it this way:
That sentence is from OPAR; the diagram is mine. It may be more useful to express something as “some thing” to emphasize the definite nature of that which exists.