What is 'reason'?

18 hours ago, SpookyKitty said:

The description of human cognition that Rand and Peikoff give us sounds good on paper, but then when you actually try to go and use it… you can’t.

Why not? Would you be more specific? You’d be right to say that it’s incomplete, or that a fully fledged theory needs more to it, but this doesn’t invalidate what is there. I would like to see a detailed step-by-step account from an Objectivist academic as well, but the lack of one doesn’t mean that the sketch given by Rand in ITOE can’t be used.

On top of that, not even Rand thought her theory of concepts was complete.

Take this quote from Peikoff:

“Ayn Rand regarded her theory of concepts as proved, but not as completed. There are, she thought, important similarities between concepts and mathematics still to be identified; and there is much to be learned about man’s mind by a proper study of man’s brain and nervous system. In her last years, Miss Rand was interested in following up on these ideas—in relating the field of conceptualization to two others: higher mathematics and neurology. Her ultimate goal was to integrate in one theory the branch of philosophy that studies man’s cognitive faculty with the science that reveals its essential method and the science that studies its physical organs. (109)”

[My secondary source: http://forum.objectivismonline.com/index.php?/topic/24356-from-integrity-to-calculus/)

I don’t really see how your reply has much to do with the OP’s question anyway.
 

18 hours ago, SpookyKitty said:

Formal logic and probability theory are the way to go.

These aren’t epistemological theories per se. You can’t say “they are the way to go”, especially because they aren’t excluded from Objectivist epistemology. Or any theory that takes advantage of reason for that matter. If you say it as if these are the only valid options, it makes a sound like you will not have any knowledge until you learn formal logic and probability theory. They aren’t things people do naturally.

You would still need to explain basic concepts like ‘dog’, and how children can have knowledge of that concept without using formal logic.