Objectivism is the philosophy devised by Ayn Rand during her lifetime. In that sense it is what is called a closed system; meaning that it is not open to change. It is her property, somebody could come along and “change” it, but then it would no longer be Objectivism, which is the name that Ayn Rand gave to her philosophy.
I already grasp the fact that nobody except Ayn Rand can change Ayn Rand’s philosophy. A is A. However, “Objectivism” as a label is not a registered trademark. In the history of ideas, such labels are not protected by anything else except what people (sometimes subjectively and arbitrarily) make the label refer to. Would you suggest that there is a contradiction involved in such a change of the label’s referents? Because that would be a non sequitor, I think. The contradiction would only occur when somebody asserts that A is non-A, i.e. when he asserts that his particular philosophy is Ayn Rand’s philosophy. But if he doesn’t make such a claim, there is no contradiction to deal with.
I am not endorsing any “Let’s change Ayn Rand’s philosophy” project. On the contrary, I think it is very important that the integrity of Ayn Rand’s philosophy is preserved in its original. I am prepared to fight for that cause. Not because I think Objectivism necessarily is true (I haven’t studied it enough to know whether it is, as a whole, at this point), but because I believe in honoring individual achievement, originality, productivity and the importance of giving proper credits (i.e. the law of identity applied in the realm of cognition). That’s why I am taking these issues seriously enough to ask you guys this type of questions.
But, I could speculate that if she had lived another twenty years she would have taken it further like in epistemology; induction for example. Who knows? Augmented, perhaps; different, no. I don’t know if I understand the question. She completed the work that she completed, no less, no more (published at least).
My original question stands in a meta-philosophical context. Of course she completed what she completed, that’s not the question here. The question is whether Ayn Rand said, in effect, at some point of her life either one of these two alternatives:
-
(In the year of X) “My philosophy, Objectivism, is once and for all systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT*. In terms of essentials, that means the case is closed. Objectivism is a finished product, just like Atlas Shrugged is out there on the market. I could rewrite Atlas Shrugged if I wanted, but I couldn’t grab the sold copies out there and change their content. In the same way, even if I decided to change something in Objectivism as it is right now, that new philosophy would not be Objectivism. A is A and I would get a new name for it. All subsequent derivations, applications, elaborations from Objectivism are to be authorized by me if they are to be part of official Objectivist doctrine. If they are not authorized, no matter how consistent with Objectivism, they are not part of official Objectivist doctrine. Objectivism is a closed system, which means that it is whatever I say it is – until the case closes, and that I have done. If I were to say, as an old woman, that now I want Objectivism to endorse anarchism in politics – that is not possible. Objectivism is objectively closed, meaning that the case is closed in terms of essentials. As I said, if I wanted to change any essential, I’d have to change the name for the new philosophy as well.”
-
(In the year of X) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 1*.
(In the year of X+Y, later than X) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 2*.
(In the year of X+Z, later than X+Y) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 3*.
In terms of essentials, there is no once and for all statement. Objectivism is whatever essentials I put into it, when and if I do it during my lifetime. Objectivism is like a mirror of my personal growth in wisdom and knowledge. The case closes only when I die. Until then, Objectivism is still forming. But still, all derivations, applications, elaborations from Objectivism are always to be authorized by me if they are to be part of official Objectivist doctrine. If they are not authorized, no matter how consistent with Objectivism at some point during its development, they are not part of official Objectivist thought. In that sense, Objectivism is a closed system – it is whatever I say it is."
The difference between these two alternatives should be clear.
The former is an application of philosophy, but not an element of the philosophy itself. The latter, correct or not, is an element in her views of a specialized science, psychology – where a specialized science is an effort to gain knowledge about a narrow aspect of reality, using special methods.
I think these distinctions are clear to me. But the spotlight here is on the status of Ayn Rand’s meta-philosophy contra established ditto. Is it derived from Objectivism, being an integrated part of it, or is it separate (like a frame for a painting)? I want to understand these issues because I think it will be very difficult to market Objectivism as a philosophy if the meta-philosophical context of Objectivism clashes too much with established meta-philosophy (i.e. the view of what philosophy is).