What is the nature of philosophy?

The view of what exactly qualifies and constitutes a philosophy – is that conclusion itself (in the case of Objectivism) derived from a previously established consensus among contemporary philosophical thought, or did Ayn Rand establish a new meta-philosophical perspective on the issue here as well? If so, would that perspective be part of Objectivism or more like an optional frame for a painting?

My study of Objectivism advances. I have now read the first two chapters of OPAR! Yeah, I hear your applause over the seas… thank you… it is quite an impressive achievement. :wink: But seriously, I really want to check if my own conclusions on what Objectivism really IS can be regarded as true or false according to more seasoned Objectivists. So here are my conclusions, as they stand right now:

Objectivism is a noun, a name, on Ayn Rand’s philosophical summa as it was made public on a larger scale by herself or associates with her explicit authorization. The works she wrote during her lifetime but did not intend to publish, are not part of Objectivism. Nor is Dr. Peikoff’s book OPAR (since it is based on rewritten material from the original 1976 lectures), or most other material produced by other Objectivists after her death.

Objectivism is Ayn Rand’s philosophical premises AND conclusions during her lifetime – regardless of how consistent with logic or other people’s sense-perceptual data. Any revision of any conclusion manifests itself as a rejection of Objectivism as an integrated whole. Ayn Rand didn’t deduce her philosophy from axioms, rather she extrospected and induced from on her own sense-perceptional data.

My first question: If I am correct in the above, does it mean that Ayn Rand’s philosophy started to form in her head… well, when? Does her philosophy form as a progression from the year 1905 to 1982 and anything she regarded as important and induced from her perceptions of reality, made up that philosophy?

My second question: Is Objectivism merely a selective presentation of Ayn Rand’s progression of abstract thought during the period 191X-1982? I.e., did she say at a point in her lifetime “This is Objectivism, no more and no less”? Would Objectivism be different if Ayn Rand lived 20 years longer and incorporated new insights into her philosophy?

You know, I’ve been thinking “maybe I am doing something wrong by asking these kind of questions before having studied Objectivism at depth”. That is, not in the sense of being morally wrong, but wrong in the sense that I am exposing myself as lazy (which I am not). But this is a very burning question for me right now, and I can’t find an answer to it anywhere in my books. So I am asking again:

Is Objectivism, as a systematization of particular ideas (as they were integrated from the premises and conclusions by Ayn Rand herself, reduced back to her personal sense-data), closed in the sense of not being expanded further by Miss Rand (since she’s not alive), or is it closed in the sense of being a definite statement – a finished product if you like – during some point in her lifetime (an if so, when?).

One reason I am asking this is because I don’t understand how Ayn Rand could write an “Introduction” to Objectivist Epstemology, and yet have the system as a whole without making explicit the rest of that epistemology. Could anyone please comment on this? Thanks.

Would Objectivism be different if Ayn Rand lived 20 years longer and incorporated new insights into her philosophy?

I think this is the real crux of your question. Objectivism is the philosophy devised by Ayn Rand during her lifetime. In that sense it is what is called a closed system; meaning that it is not open to change. It is her property, somebody could come along and “change” it, but then it would no longer be Objectivism, which is the name that Ayn Rand gave to her philosophy.

This is why Dr. Peikoff in the preface to OPAR stated: “…nor can the book be properly described as “official Objectivist doctrine.” “Objectivism” is the name of Ayn Rand’s philosophy as presented in the material she herself wrote or endorsed.” OPAR, Preface, pg xv.

That gives you one extra assignment when reading a work that she neither wrote nor endorsed. In this in accordance with Objectivism, or is this veering off-course? That comes after the affirmation or denial of the truth of a particular statement of course.

As per your quoted question above. I don’t see how it could be any different. But, I could speculate that if she had lived another twenty years she would have taken it further like in epistemology; induction for example. Who knows? Augmented, perhaps; different, no.

One reason I am asking this is because I don’t understand how Ayn Rand could write an “Introduction” to Objectivist Epstemology, and yet have the system as a whole without making explicit the rest of that epistemology. Could anyone please comment on this? Thanks.

I don’t know if I understand the question. She completed the work that she completed, no less, no more (published at least). Maybe she never got farther enough along for anything substantantial to be published. Except for induction (which, I think I read somewhere, she was working on) what was the rest? To my knowledge (and someone can correct me if I am wrong) it is a complete epistemology. All the essentials are there for any and all subsequent derivations, applications, elaborations, even the groundwork for induction is in there.

I hope this helps. But I think you are fretting too much! :lol:

You have asked a lot of challenging questions. Following is my answer – which is another question, one that I believe you should ask yourself at some point. It is implicit in the questions you have asked:

What is philosophy?

My answer, for me, at this point in history is: A philosophy is a coherent, systematized set of fundamental ideas that condition all of a man’s other ideas and therefore his actions. These ideas apply to ever individual, everywhere, at all times. These ideas answer the key questions of:

  1. What is the basic nature of the world in which I live? (Metaphysics, ontology)

  2. How do I know what I know about the world? (Epistemology)

  3. What should I do about what I know about the world (including myself)? (Ethics)

  4. How should I interact with other individuals in society, especially in regard to settling disputes? (Politics, an application of ethics to the universal situation of living in society.)

  5. How can I capture all these insights in one package? (Esthetics, the study of the principles of art, a need for all individuals; it, like politics, is also an application of ethics, but including metaphysics and epistemology in an emotional, stylized form.)

The above are the objects of philosophical study. The last defining characteristic of philosophy is its method, which is also universal: using logic and observation. These are common to all pursuit of knowledge. (Specialized sciences use additional methods – such as clinical experimentation – and focus on particular aspects of reality not the broad characteristics that affect everyone, everywhere, at all times.)

With this definition of philosophy, I can see that Ayn Rand’s views on the presidential election of 1980 (in which she chose to not vote) and her views on homosexuality are not part of Objectivism, the philosophy which she created. The reason is that neither applies to all individuals everywhere at all times.The former is an application of philosophy, but not an element of the philosophy itself. The latter, correct or not, is an element in her views of a specialized science, psychology – where a specialized science is an effort to gain knowledge about a narrow aspect of reality, using special methods.

I would define philosophy in terms of essentials:

Philosophy is the discipline which studies the fundamental nature of existence, man, and man’s relationship to existence.

Science studies certain aspects of existence—philosophy studies existence in virtue of being existence.

To give an example, chemistry or engineering are the studies of delimited and specific aspects of reality, whereas philosophy asks the question: what is reality? What is the nature of reality as such?

Here is the exact quote from Ayn Rand:

“Philosophy studies the fundamental nature of existence, of man, and of man’s relationship to existence. In the realm of cognition, the special sciences are the trees, but philosophy is the soil which makes the forest possible.” - Ayn Rand

I do think Ayn Rand did establish a new perspective on this. Her epistemological method, when applied to the concept of “philosophy,” defines it in terms of essentials. Rather than just saying “philosophy is what the philosophers do,” she identified the essential characteristics of the discipline. She cut through the conceptual confusion and presented a clear definition.

Contrast some of these non-essential definitions of philosophy with her definition:

“Science is what we know and philosophy is what we don’t know."

  • Bertrand Russell

“Philosophy is the peculiarly stubborn attempt to think clearly.”

  • William James

“Philosophy, n. A route of many roads leading from nowhere to nothing.”

  • Ambrose Bierce

Objectivism is the philosophy devised by Ayn Rand during her lifetime. In that sense it is what is called a closed system; meaning that it is not open to change. It is her property, somebody could come along and “change” it, but then it would no longer be Objectivism, which is the name that Ayn Rand gave to her philosophy.

I already grasp the fact that nobody except Ayn Rand can change Ayn Rand’s philosophy. A is A. However, “Objectivism” as a label is not a registered trademark. In the history of ideas, such labels are not protected by anything else except what people (sometimes subjectively and arbitrarily) make the label refer to. Would you suggest that there is a contradiction involved in such a change of the label’s referents? Because that would be a non sequitor, I think. The contradiction would only occur when somebody asserts that A is non-A, i.e. when he asserts that his particular philosophy is Ayn Rand’s philosophy. But if he doesn’t make such a claim, there is no contradiction to deal with.

I am not endorsing any “Let’s change Ayn Rand’s philosophy” project. On the contrary, I think it is very important that the integrity of Ayn Rand’s philosophy is preserved in its original. I am prepared to fight for that cause. Not because I think Objectivism necessarily is true (I haven’t studied it enough to know whether it is, as a whole, at this point), but because I believe in honoring individual achievement, originality, productivity and the importance of giving proper credits (i.e. the law of identity applied in the realm of cognition). That’s why I am taking these issues seriously enough to ask you guys this type of questions.

But, I could speculate that if she had lived another twenty years she would have taken it further like in epistemology; induction for example. Who knows? Augmented, perhaps; different, no. I don’t know if I understand the question. She completed the work that she completed, no less, no more (published at least).

My original question stands in a meta-philosophical context. Of course she completed what she completed, that’s not the question here. The question is whether Ayn Rand said, in effect, at some point of her life either one of these two alternatives:

  1. (In the year of X) “My philosophy, Objectivism, is once and for all systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT*. In terms of essentials, that means the case is closed. Objectivism is a finished product, just like Atlas Shrugged is out there on the market. I could rewrite Atlas Shrugged if I wanted, but I couldn’t grab the sold copies out there and change their content. In the same way, even if I decided to change something in Objectivism as it is right now, that new philosophy would not be Objectivism. A is A and I would get a new name for it. All subsequent derivations, applications, elaborations from Objectivism are to be authorized by me if they are to be part of official Objectivist doctrine. If they are not authorized, no matter how consistent with Objectivism, they are not part of official Objectivist doctrine. Objectivism is a closed system, which means that it is whatever I say it is – until the case closes, and that I have done. If I were to say, as an old woman, that now I want Objectivism to endorse anarchism in politics – that is not possible. Objectivism is objectively closed, meaning that the case is closed in terms of essentials. As I said, if I wanted to change any essential, I’d have to change the name for the new philosophy as well.”

  2. (In the year of X) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 1*.

(In the year of X+Y, later than X) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 2*.

(In the year of X+Z, later than X+Y) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 3*.

In terms of essentials, there is no once and for all statement. Objectivism is whatever essentials I put into it, when and if I do it during my lifetime. Objectivism is like a mirror of my personal growth in wisdom and knowledge. The case closes only when I die. Until then, Objectivism is still forming. But still, all derivations, applications, elaborations from Objectivism are always to be authorized by me if they are to be part of official Objectivist doctrine. If they are not authorized, no matter how consistent with Objectivism at some point during its development, they are not part of official Objectivist thought. In that sense, Objectivism is a closed system – it is whatever I say it is."

The difference between these two alternatives should be clear.

The former is an application of philosophy, but not an element of the philosophy itself. The latter, correct or not, is an element in her views of a specialized science, psychology – where a specialized science is an effort to gain knowledge about a narrow aspect of reality, using special methods.

I think these distinctions are clear to me. But the spotlight here is on the status of Ayn Rand’s meta-philosophy contra established ditto. Is it derived from Objectivism, being an integrated part of it, or is it separate (like a frame for a painting)? I want to understand these issues because I think it will be very difficult to market Objectivism as a philosophy if the meta-philosophical context of Objectivism clashes too much with established meta-philosophy (i.e. the view of what philosophy is).

I don’t think Ayn Rand’s metaphilosophy differs that much from the traditional definitions and subsections of philosophy. That said, there are many modern philosophers who do not consider Ayn Rand a philosopher at all. I think that says more about them than her, though.

I already grasp the fact that nobody except Ayn Rand can change Ayn Rand’s philosophy. A is A. However, “Objectivism” as a label is not a registered trademark. In the history of ideas, such labels are not protected by anything else except what people (sometimes subjectively and arbitrarily) make the label refer to. Would you suggest that there is a contradiction involved in such a change of the label’s referents? Because that would be a non sequitor, I think. The contradiction would only occur when somebody asserts that A is non-A, i.e. when he asserts that his particular philosophy is Ayn Rand’s philosophy. But if he doesn’t make such a claim, there is no contradiction to deal with.

I’m not sure I see your point. As a matter of intellectual honesty, the term “Objectivism” should only be used for the philosophy developed by Ayn Rand. No, it is not trademarked so no legal action cn be taken if someone misuses the label. It’s purely a moral and intellectual issue.

  1. (In the year of X) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 1*.

(In the year of X+Y, later than X) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 2*.

(In the year of X+Z, later than X+Y) "My philosophy, Objectivism, is currently systematized by me this way *SNAPSHOT no 3*.

In terms of essentials, there is no once and for all statement. Objectivism is whatever essentials I put into it, when and if I do it during my lifetime. Objectivism is like a mirror of my personal growth in wisdom and knowledge. The case closes only when I die. Until then, Objectivism is still forming. But still, all derivations, applications, elaborations from Objectivism are always to be authorized by me if they are to be part of official Objectivist doctrine. If they are not authorized, no matter how consistent with Objectivism at some point during its development, they are not part of official Objectivist thought. In that sense, Objectivism is a closed system – it is whatever I say it is."

I think it is more like this. Ayn Rand was continuously developing Objectivist ideas during her life, so there was no one point when the philosophy was “finished.” And clearly there is much more work that can be done and is being done in the Objectivist tradition. So Objectivism is “closed” only in the sense that the term applies only to Ayn Rand’s work, not in the sense that that it is impossible to further expand on her ideas.

With this definition of philosophy, I can see that Ayn Rand’s views on the presidential election of 1980 (in which she chose to not vote) and her views on homosexuality are not part of Objectivism, the philosophy which she created. The reason is that neither applies to all individuals everywhere at all times.The former is an application of philosophy, but not an element of the philosophy itself. The latter, correct or not, is an element in her views of a specialized science, psychology – where a specialized science is an effort to gain knowledge about a narrow aspect of reality, using special methods.

This is an excellent point. I often see people seeming to argue that every opinion Ayn Rand ever expressed is part of Objectivism, and that anyone who disagrees with her about anything is not an Objectivist.

On the election, this seems quite clear. We can see it in this election with the different positions taken by Drs. Peikoff and Binswanger.

Homosexuality is a bit more debatable, since it is an aspect of the nature of man, which should be applicable to “to all individuals everywhere at all times.” I think there is a wider issue here: a lot of Objectivism seems to rest on a view of the nature of man as fully volitional, which in turn rests on psychology, not philosophy. I think this is a potential weak point in the philosophy that could use some work to solidify.

Soulsurfer’s Hypothetical quote from Ayn Rand:

In that sense, Objectivism is a closed system – it is whatever I say it is.

I don’t think it is correct to say that Objectivism is whatever Ayn Rand says it is. It is whatever Ayn Rand said about PHILOSOPHICAL issues only. In contrast to SCIENTIFIC issues, such as psychology. I think you already understand this distinction, I just want to make sure that you further incorporate it into your understanding.

I too was interested in this topic for the same reason that you seem to be interested. I asked some related questions here. Most of this content has already been reiterated in here on this thread, but it may prove informative nonetheless.

I want to present a few other questions to test the validity of the distinction between Philosophy and Science.

If Science is specialized study of an aspect of existence, and Philosophy is a study of existence as a whole, based on material that is available to all of man at any point of time in his history, then doesn’t the STANDARD OF ‘SPECIALIZED’ change as man’s knowledge expands?

Put another way: Would Objectivism be understandable to a caveman, assuming his intellegence was equal to our own?

Doesn’t our exposure to the discoveries made in science, enable us to grasp Objectivism or does it simply aid us in our understanding via the ‘spiral theory of epistemology’?

PS: If these questions are deemed too far removed from the present thread topic, then these questions can be given their own thread. In which case, this PS can be removed.

I don’t think it is correct to say that Objectivism is whatever Ayn Rand says it is.  It is whatever Ayn Rand said about PHILOSOPHICAL issues only.  In contrast to SCIENTIFIC issues, such as psychology.  I think you already understand this distinction, I just want to make sure that you further incorporate it into your understanding. 

Yes, I understand this distinction. But what IS a PHILOSOPHICAL issue? According to what criteria does something qualify as a “philosophical issue”? Is that criteria itself derived from inside Objectivism or outside Objectivism? Since the view of what philosophy is echoes a metaphilosophical perspective, I think it is fully legitimate to ask if that criteria or qualification (i.e. the metaphilosophy) is derived from Objectivist conclusions or may be separated from Objectivism as a philosophy.

I’ll read the suggested thread to see if that helps my understanding further.

Yes, I understand this distinction. My concern here is about the criteria of what qualifies as an “philosophical issue.” Is that criteria derived from inside Objectivism or outside Objectivism? Since the view itself echoes a metaphilosophical perspective, I think it is fully legitimate to ask if the criteria or qualification (i.e. the metaphilosophy) is derived from Objectivist conclusions or a separate issue.

I’ll read the suggested thread to see if that helps my understanding further.

If I understand your question correctly, then I don’t know the answer, but I am interested in getting one. Your question seems related to the question I just asked about the standard of specialized study.

Just to take the reasoning a little step further in light of the two alternative views on the status of Objectivism I posted above:

Would you say that at least Ayn Rand’s meta-philosophy reflects the first alternative here? (I.e. that it is once and for all established, not subject to change at a certain point in time.) Or would you say that it follows the second alternative? (I.e. that the meta-philosophy itself was part of Objectivism, and that Objectivism was a continuous development by Miss Rand which was only stopped by her death.)

Soulsurfer, I need clarification.

What does “meta-philosophy” mean? By genus and differentia.

If it is a valid concept, what are some examples, that is, units?

Where in the hierarchy of knowledge does the concept meta-philosophy appear?

What does “meta-philosophy” mean?

“Meta-philosophy” is the view of what constitutes or qualifies as philosophical or what is properly defining a full philosophic system. Thus, by its nature, it cannot escape the fact that the view itself echoes some kind of philosophy (implicit or explicit). However, many philosophers don’t derive their meta-philosophical perspective from their own (explicit) philosophy, but rather implicitly from an established consensus.

I don’t know if it is a proper concept to use here, though. Maybe I would have expressed my thoughts better by dropping the word. I’ll have to think about it.

…

However, many philosophers don’t derive their meta-philosophical perspective from their own (explicit) philosophy, but rather implicitly from an established consensus.

…

Validation by consensus is a philosophical position itself, that is, it is an element of a philosophy, explicit or implicit. In particular, it is the position of a Kantian-Rawlsian philosophy of egalitarianism: The world is what we all agree it is (metaphysics); we know it is what it is through consensus (epistemology); and we should act only on that consensus (ethics).

I also have an inkling that the supposed concept of meta-philosophy, as something outside any particular philosophy, is a stolen concept.

(Thank you, Soulsurfer, for initiating this thread. It has been stimulating to me. The etiquette has been superb, partly because the participants are mainly discussing rather than only debating. I look forward to more comments.)

Yes, I understand this distinction. But what IS a PHILOSOPHICAL issue? According to what criteria does something qualify as a “philosophical issue”?

If I understand correctly, you are asking for a definition of philosophy. Here is Ayn Rand’s, as quoted earlier:

“Philosophy studies the fundamental nature of existence, of man, and of man’s relationship to existence. In the realm of cognition, the special sciences are the trees, but philosophy is the soil which makes the forest possible.” - Ayn Rand

This definition is of course consistent with Objectivism, but also with a lot of other philosophical writings. Thus most of what is generally considered to be philosophy would fall under this definition. So I don’t think Objectivism and “mainstream” philosopy have radically different ideas about what philosophy is.

Here, for example, is a “mainstream” definition: “rationally critical thinking, of a more or less systematic kind about the general nature of the world (metaphysics or theory of existence), the justification of belief (epistemology or theory of knowledge), and the conduct of life (ethics or theory of value).” (Oxford Companian to Philosophy, p. 666)

I don’t see a big conflict; why are you so concerned about this issue?

Would you say that at least Ayn Rand’s meta-philosophy reflects the first alternative here? (I.e. that it is once and for all established, not subject to change at a certain point in time.)

I would say so, yes. The fundamentals of Objectivism are “once and for all established” and that would include what types of issues the philosophy does and does not address.

If Science is specialized study of an aspect of existence, and Philosophy is a study of existence as a whole, based on material that is available to all of man at any point of time in his history, then doesn’t the STANDARD OF ‘SPECIALIZED’ change as man’s knowledge expands?

Put another way: Would Objectivism be understandable to a caveman, assuming his intellegence was equal to our own?

Doesn’t our exposure to the discoveries made in science, enable us to grasp Objectivism or does it simply aid us in our understanding via the ‘spiral theory of epistemology’?

I would say no, yes, and neither.

In theory Aristotle could have developed all of Objectivism. He would not have had to know any science whatsoever; he would have only needed his intellect and everyday observations.