What is the nature of "time"?

Everything exists; Existence cannot be added to, or subtracted from. The axiom does require the rejection of a changing world (as first recognized by Parmenides), but the fact of our experience of a world in motion can be reconciled with logic, by embracing four-dimensionalism. In such a view, to observe change is to observe the differences between different parts of the same four-dimensional whole, but the parts (ultimately) do not change and the whole does not change. Such a view of change agrees with the axiom: all A is A, and it does not deny the perceptual evidence of motion. It is, rather, a reinterpretation that leads to a very difference world view with profound implications. It is a view that holds that the passage of time is psychological (i.e., pertaining to the way one perceives the dimension of time, not an actual component of the physical universe) and existence is an unchanging four-dimensional totality.

But even Peikoff said “Time is a measurement of motion…” isn’t this wrong?  Time, to be a parent concept, must omit measurement.  Duration is a measurement of time - time is not a measurement of itself.  Can a concept be a measurement of it’s own conceptual common denominator?

First, you misunderstand the role of measurement-omission in concept formation. It is not the word “measurement” itself which is omitted, but rather all instances of measurement, all specific measurements. Second, time is a relational concept, but it is defined ostensively. Any subsequent definition or characterization will, implicitly or explicitly, be abstracted from the notion of time itself.

Saying, time is a change of relationship.  What I don’t like about it is that, time is a change of relationship.  Wouldn’t it be more appropriate saying time is change in relationship?

No. A change in relationship would imply a different kind of relationship, which is not relevant to the sort of change that involves time.

Anyways I sympathize with that Michael’s wording because of how time and existence are related.  If nothing existed there would be no time.

If nothing existed there would be no anything. I fail to see what you sympathize with, since the statement itself is not at all informative.

Everything exists; Existence cannot be added to, or subtracted from. The axiom does require the rejection of a changing world (as first recognized by Parmenides), but the fact of our experience of a world in motion can be reconciled with logic, by embracing four-dimensionalism. In such a view, to observe change is to observe the differences between different parts of the same four-dimensional whole, but the parts (ultimately) do not change and the whole does not change. Such a view of change agrees with the axiom: all A is A, and it does not deny the perceptual evidence of motion. It is, rather, a reinterpretation that leads to a very difference world view with profound implications. It is a view that holds that the passage of time is psychological (i.e., pertaining to the way one perceives the dimension of time, not an actual component of the physical universe) and existence is an unchanging four-dimensional totality.

Thank you! You just gave me a new concept. Rationalist word salad!

I recommend referring to reality once in a while.

Mr. Speicher ,

Some technical questions that everyone else can ignore.

What do “coupled” and “uncoupled” mean, in general and as applied to the contexts of the GRT field equations and the field equations of electromagnetism? Why is (D’Alembertian A = 4 pi J ) uncoupled and ( G = 8 pi T ) coupled?

What do “linear” and “nonlinear” mean? I’m going to guess that, as in electromagnetism, linear fields are fields that, when superimposed (when two or more sources are close to each other), add linearly. Ie, do you mean that the gravitational effect on the metric of two or more sources is different from the sum of the effect of each of the sources individually? Or is it something different?

Can you give me any more examples of finding the solutions (ie a metric) for some given kind of stress tensor? I think the Shwartzchild metric is the solution for the surface and exterior of a star; I’ve heard mention of a Kerr metric, which I think is the solution which (somehow) illustrates at the same time the observations of an observer far from and one on the horizon of a (collapsing?) black hole, which the Shwartzchild metric couldn’t do. Also, if you could clarify exactly what these two metrics are, that would be great.

Also, though you didn’t bring it up, how are point charges and singularities (point masses?, eg within a black hole’s horizon) different?

I have an interest in but no formal training in theoretical physics. If you could answer these questions, or direct me to any articles (preferably free & online & perhaps not too technical), I would appreciate it. Thanks.

Thank you! You just gave me a new concept. Rationalist word salad!

I recommend referring to reality once in a while.

One simple straightforward question from the rational salad:

Does the past and future exist?

When referring to reality, is it not appropriate to consistently affirm it. The three-dimensional view can’t decide on the ontological state of past and future. It implies that only “now” exists, but yet, also speaks of a non-existent past and future. And the future is somehow less real than the past.

Four-dimensionalism does not fail to reference reality, it interprets the information we have about reality in a way that is not contradictory.

W A Dunkley,

Here and there do not exist, just as past and future do not exist. But they are all often reified.

Also, rational != rationalist. Reason includes identification of fact. Rationalism includes making things up as you go along.

W A Dunkley,

Here and there do not exist, just as past and future do not exist. But they are all often reified.

Also, rational != rationalist. Reason includes identification of fact. Rationalism includes making things up as you go along.

“Here” and “there” are relative terms and so to are “past” and “future.” but they have reference to reality. If I am sitting in Atlanta, not doing the boot-scoot in Ft. Worth, then I refer to Atlanta as “here” and Ft Worth as “there,” but Atlanta and Ft. Worth both exist. Four-dimensionalism maintains that “past,” “present” and “future.” are also relative. (what does this “make up)” The part of me sitting here calls the part of me boot-scooting in Texas last summer “past”, but both exist. Three-demensionalism makes “present” absolute and existence relative.

With all due respect, it seem that reason becomes rationalism when it fails to support ones position.

Another powerful argument for four-dimensionalism might be referred to as a “cosmological argument.”

Stating it briefly:

Three-dimensionalism leaves one with the unattractive choice between the absurdity of a universe that pop out of nothing and returns to nothing or the contradictions of infinity. Four-dimensionalism liberates us from such conundrums by providing us with a view of the universe that is finite, but yet eternal.

Dunkley:

It is a view that holds that the passage of time is psychological (i.e., pertaining to the way one perceives the dimension of time, not an actual component of the physical universe) and existence is an unchanging four-dimensional totality.[emphasis added]

Does this mean “we’re all in this together” because “we’re all parts of a whole?”

Three-dimensionalism leaves one with the unattractive choice between the absurdity of a universe that pop out of nothing and returns to nothing

Why?

What do “coupled” and “uncoupled” mean, in general and as applied to the contexts of the GRT field equations and the field equations of electromagnetism? Why is (D’Alembertian A = 4 pi J) uncoupled and (G = 8 pi T) coupled? What do “linear” and “nonlinear” mean?

Let me sketch out a few basics and establish the context while answering your questions.

A differential equation involves one or more unknown functions along with one or more of their derivatives. This unknown function is called the dependent variable, since it depends on one or more independent variables. When there exists only a single independent variable then only ordinary derivatives are required and we refer to the equation as an ordinary differential equation. When there exists two or more independent variables then partial derivatives are required and we refer to the equation as a partial differential equation. The Maxwell electromagnetic and Einstein gravitational field equations both involve partial differential equations.

When the unknown functions and their derivatives appear in the equation only to the first degree, and when there are no mixed products of these functions, then we refer to this as a linear differential equation. If there exist mixed products of the unknown functions, or higher than first degree derivatives, then we refer to this as a nonlinear differential equation. So, for instance, if the differential equation contains x + y, or derivates such as x’ or x’‘’, it is linear. If the derivates are of the form like (x’)^2 or (x’‘’)^3, or a product such as xy, then the differential equation is nonlinear. Finding exact solutions to nonlinear differential equations is, in general, much more difficult than for linear differential equations. Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations are linear, whereas the Einstein field equations are nonlinear.

Physical problems often have multiple unknown functions which lead to a system of differential equations. When each of these differential equations in the set can be solved independently, then the system is known as uncoupled. When the unknown functions appear together in each of the differential equations in the set, each equation cannot be solved independently and the system of equations is said to be coupled. Special techniques are required to solve these coupled system of differential equations. Both Maxwell’s electormagnetic and Einstein’s gravitational equations are a set of coupled partial differential equations, but the gravitational field equations are much more complex and much, much more difficult to solve.

The electromagnetic equation you wrote for the vector potential A is one portion of the result of introducing the potential to reduce the number of, and uncouple, Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations. It represents half of two equations that are equivalent to the full set of Maxwell’s equations.

Can you give me any more examples of finding the solutions (ie a metric) for some given kind of stress tensor?

If you send me your email address I’ll email you a couple of papers.

Also, if you could clarify exactly what these two metrics are, that would be great.

I am not sure how this will be helpful to you, but the Schwarzschild metric is

ds^2 = (1-2m/r)dt^2 - (1-2m/r)^-1 dr^2 - r^2(d{theta}^2 + sin^2{theta} d{phi}^2)

There are several Kerr forms that are generally used, but the original metric that Kerr discovered was in Cartesian-type coordinates, and it took this form,

ds^2 = dt^2 - dx^2 - dy^2 - dz^2 - (2mr^3/{r^4 + a^2 z^2})[dt + (r/{a^2 + r^2}) (x dx + y dy) + (a/{a^2 + r^2}) (y dx - x dy) + z/r dz]^2,

where,

t = v - r

x = r sin{theta} cos{phi} + a sin{theta} sin{phi}

y = r sin{theta} sin{phi} - a sin{theta} cos{phi}

z = r cos{theta}

Also, though you didn’t bring it up, how are point charges and singularities (point masses?, eg within a black hole’s horizon) different?

A point-charge is just the classical model of an electron, whereas the central singularity of a black hole derives from several solutions to the field equations. (And, as I have mentioned several times, not all solutions of mathematical equations reflect what exists in physical reality.)

Dunkley,

Ah, you see I stopped keeping up with philosophy (historically at least) after Sarte. So I had to look it up.

This Four-Dimensionalism is as old as Plato in essential form. First it attempts to describe human consciousness, and from this basis to define what reality must be like. This is the primacy of consciousness in its original formula, and the most common form of rationalist metaphysics. It also violates, I believe, Occam’s razor, by giving existence to time as if it is something rather than a relation. And, this violation is the result of the primary fallacy of the primacy of consciousness.

That is all that I’ve gleemed from it thus far, and am not going to argue it any further since it violates one of the cardinal rules of a rational metaphysics. Besides, I’d have to update my philosophy texts!

PS. Try to be a little more intelligible to the audience you are writing for. Objectivists are the last people to think a river is deep because the water is murky, whether by intention or not.

Dunkley:

Does this mean “we’re all in this together” because “we’re all parts of a whole?”

Why?

I am not sure exactly what this first question is asking in context to the quote. My philosophy maintains that everything that exists shares the same primary part and the same first cause, which is self-sameness. This affirms that the universe is in fact a universe (i.e., an integrated totality.)

In response to the second question, I will address the problem of assuming that there is no beginning in time. Objectivism acknowledges that an actual infinity is incompatible with the axiom. (Why this does not constitute “rationalism,” but what I do with the axiom does, has not been explained to my satisfaction.) The Aristotelean approach to the problem is to maintain that an infinite past does not constitute an actual infinity. But, surely, when Ayn Rand was born, this was an actual event, an actual moment. When the last Neanderthal died this was actual. If there is no beginning, then you are stuck with an infinite regression of actual moments. The other three-dimensional alternative seems to leave us with an actual nothing!

I am reminded of the saying. “Once you have eliminated the impossible, what remains, however unlikely, most be true.” What remains is four-dimensionalism!

Thoyd Loki

You seem ready to discuss everybody’s philosophy but mine. The primacy of identity and four-dimensionalism do not affirm the primacy of consciouseness.

“A river is not deep because the water is murky.” This sounds like a wise aphorism, but it should also be remembered that when we learn new ideas they often seem murky in the beginning. Four-dimensionalism is a simple idea, but hard to get a handle on, because it is so divergent.

I address this “audience” because, while some of my metaphysical views diverge from Objectivism, I have great respect for Ayn Rand and her philosophy. My philosophy and objectivism maintain the same conviction that A is A and that this truth is profoundly important. Like myself, objectivism also maintains that it is wrong to evade and to misrepresent. Here and elsewhere, I see much of this when confronting my ideas.

Thoyd Loki

You seem ready to discuss everybody’s philosophy but mine.

Have you considered the possibility that the problem lies, not with Thoyd Loki, but rather with the “philosophy” that you think you have presented? Frankly, I find your view of “four-dimensionalism” to be lacking clarity and intelligibility, a jumble of floating abstractions with no tie to reality. I suppose that was what Thoyd Loki had in mind when he referred to your posting as a “word salad.” One cannot really discuss a “philosophy” when there is nothing meaningful there to discuss.

Now, I have come across the philosophical views of “four-dimensionalism” before, in several different guises. People like Theodore Sider have written about this in The Philosophical Review. Others have tried to tie it directly to special relativity. But what you have written here is so nebulous – such a faint reflection of meaningful ideas – that you really should not be surprised that no one has taken a serious interest in what you have said.

p.s. If you do not mind me asking … I am curious. Are you perchance a university philosophy student?

Thoyd Loki

You seem ready to discuss everybody’s philosophy but mine. The primacy of identity and four-dimensionalism do not affirm the primacy of consciouseness.

“A river is not deep because the water is murky.” This sounds like a wise aphorism, but it should also be remembered that when we learn new ideas they often seem murky in the beginning. Four-dimensionalism is a simple idea, but hard to get a handle on, because it is so divergent.

I address this “audience” because, while some of my metaphysical views diverge from Objectivism, I have great respect for Ayn Rand and her philosophy. My philosophy and objectivism maintain the same conviction that A is A and that this truth is profoundly important. Like myself, objectivism  also  maintains that it is wrong to evade and to misrepresent. Here and elsewhere, I see much of this when confronting my ideas.

Actually, there are several philosophies that I do not discuss. Leibniz’s, Comte, Existentialism, and others. The reasons for not doing so are two: 1) they are boring and not too important (Kant bores me, but he is important) 2) they are very recent and rehash well worn fallacies.

I didn’t have a problem grasping four-dimensionalism which I looked up from various sources. I got the gist of the idea in about 5 minutes, while an eternity of staring at your obscure sentences would have yielded zilch.

Am I missing something by throwing four-dimensionalism away with such a quick look?. No. It is simply another passing bundle of jargon that will pass away. It is only of interest to PhD canidates and tired old professors who have given up on the real business of philosophy.

Nobody here has evaded, nor misrepresented your ideas because nobody here knows what the hell you are talking about. Sorry, not trying to offend for the sake of offending, but your posts are reading more like comedy for Objectivists than philosophy. I am merely suggesting that you take the time to make your ideas clearer to a mind other than your own. It may make perfect sense in your own mind, and is just not making it out of you coherently.

Come to think of it, I probably will look deeper into four-dimensionalism. As a science-fiction writer I am always looking for weird ideas to serve as vehicles for my stories! Where would the whole gerne be without the screw-ups of the philosophers! B)

This is what I have learned about time:

Time is just a form of measurment–motion of entities in relation to each other. It does not exist in and of itself. Without entities in motion, there is no time. The universe or existence itself is eternal. But I need help with this one. Why is the universe or existence eternal? Is existence itself featureless–timeless, motionless, etc. Confused.

Why is the universe or existence eternal? Is existence itself featureless–timeless, motionless, etc. Confused.

Things IN the universe change and time is one of the ways we measure that change, but the universe AS A WHOLE always was and always will be. The concept of time is not applicable to the universe as a whole.

Have you considered the possibility that the problem lies, not with Thoyd Loki, but rather with the “philosophy” that you think you have presented? Frankly, I find your view of “four-dimensionalism” to be lacking clarity and intelligibility, a jumble of floating abstractions with no tie to reality. I suppose that was what Thoyd Loki had in mind when he referred to your posting as a “word salad.” One cannot really discuss a “philosophy” when there is nothing meaningful there to discuss.

Now, I have come across the philosophical views of “four-dimensionalism” before, in several different guises. People like Theodore Sider have written about this in The Philosophical Review. Others have tried to tie it directly to special relativity. But what you have written here is so nebulous – such a faint reflection of meaningful ideas – that you really should not be surprised that no one has taken a serious interest in what you have said.

p.s. If you do not mind me asking … I am curious. Are you perchance a university philosophy student?

Well no, I majored in Football and wild Texas women. It was a long tome ago. But, perhaps it can be argued that I received to may helmet to helmet hits, I am substantial convinced, nonetheless, that I have expressed meaningful issues. These issues cannot be seeped away with lazy reason.

When Objectivism states that there can be nothing outside of existence, or as I put it, everything exists, it is not a “floating abstraction.” This logical truth does not conveniently become meaningless when it is weighted against the notion of a changing world, where things come in to and go out of existence.

I am also supremely confident that the three-dimensional eternity embraced by Objectivism would indeed constitute an actual infinity, which Objectivism and my philosophy, both reject.

P.S. If this message is incomprehensible to you, I’ll try to bring in a young philosophy major to explain it.

I am also supremely confident that the three-dimensional eternity embraced by Objectivism would indeed constitute an actual infinity, which Objectivism and my philosophy, both reject.

Objectivism does hold that the universe is eternal (and there is not contradiction in that), but three-dimensionality is simply the form in which we perceive metaphysical reality. Evidently, not only do you need to strive harder, intellectually, to make your “four-dimensionalism” sensible, but you also have to learn to distinguish the form from the object.

P.S. If this message is incomprehensible to you …

I can read the message just fine. It is a good deal of the content of your postings that is consistently incomprehensible.

Objectivism does hold that the universe is eternal (and there is not contradiction in that), but three-dimensionality is simply the form in which we perceive metaphysical reality. Evidently, not only do you need to strive harder, intellectually, to make your “four-dimensionalism” sensible, but you also have to learn to distinguish the form from the object.

I may be just an old punch-drunk quarterback, but I cannot comprehend how this answers to the statement you quoted. Defining “form” into oblivion (which is all I can make of what you said) does not resolve the conundrum to my satisfaction.

You may argue that space/time (i.e., relative position) is something less basic than objects. (And I would disagree.) Asserting that it is not something that exists, however, is fundamentally absurd. And since it does exist, I’m afraid it brings us back to the dilemmas that I so poorly describe.