Objectivism holds that words need precision to serve their purpose.
vs.
But words need some precision to serve their purpose.
So enough said on that.
While family does have different contexts to it, the thread on Objectivism and Procreation was dealing with the issues surrounding Objectivism and children, the choice to have and rear them or not, which would subsume how to structure the interpersonal relationship under that given choice.
Right, and given that this thread is a tangent from that, I’m a little confused as to why Eiuol keeps wanting to discuss non-procreative “families”.
Also noted in the alternatives you provided - do you not consider a husband and wife a family? If they have chosen not to have children - do they not still face the challenge of how to structure their inter-personal relationships as well?
I’ll leave the general question aside but it’s certainly not part of my claim about the optimality of the nuclear family.
You might keep in mind that Objectivism is a general guide, sort of a one-size fits all, rather than an attempt to micro-manage the myriad of interdependent choices that arise in various concrete situations. It identifies what a value is in the broadest context possible. It does not try to identify what all the specific concrete values could/should/ought be.
Insofar as Objectivism is objective it is (or ought to be) concerned with objective reality. So the question becomes whether or not the nuclear family is objectively superior to the alternatives in the sense that I have elaborated.
It would help the discussion immensely if someone would propose an alternative against which we can compare the nuclear family. Everyone seems to want to argue abstractly against the nuclear family without being able to offer a competitive alternative.