I have seen many threads on this board that discuss artificial intelligence (AI) or computers with consciousness, etc. I haven’t seen any that define the term.
(edit: If anyone knows of a thread that defines AI, could you post a link here? thanks!)
I think that defining a term that has no referents in reality is philosophically interesting. (at least, I personally need to chew on / practice the process of making a definition.) The interesting philosophical question for me in defining AI relates to whether the concept is arbitrary. Nobody is suggesting that there are any actual entities to which it applies today. The question of whether it is even possible hinges on what you mean by possible. If “possible” means “having some evidence that such exists in reality”, then I don’t think anyone is even arguing that AI is possible.
However, it seems obvious to me that many concepts in science are valid, even though they fall into a similar category. For example: alien life. (Life existing on planets other than the Earth.) Now we obviously know that life does exist somewhere in the galaxy – because we know that life exists on Earth. This establishes that it is metaphysically possible for planets to support life, when the conditions are right. This seems like enough of a basis to justify some peeking around at neighboring planets to see what the conditions on them are like. And thus it also seems to me that the concept of alien life is not arbitrary – at least to the scientists who know the relevant facts.
Now on to AI:
DEFINITION:
Artificial Intelligence(n): an entity of volitional consciousness designed by human scientists and built out of non-conscious parts.[/code]
If you find that this is not the definition you are thinking of then please reply to this post and begin your response with your own definition (genus & differentia).
ELABORATION:
\* genus is "entity of volitional consciousness".
\* differentia is "designed by human scientists and built out of non-conscious parts."
Note that if human scientists merely take (for example) human stem cells, grow a brain from them, and then find a way to connect it to sensors/motors and find that the result is conscious (and not completely insane) then they will have created a CYBORG not an AI.
But if the scientists design the entity from the level of some non-conscious building blocks up, it is an AI even if the designers use chemicals & carbon instead of silicon and magnetic oxides.
DISCUSSION
First of all, note the status of this definition: The existence any entities that would be covered by it is purely a hypothetical. It is not formed by looking at a set of AI's then inducing what they have in common that differentiates them from non-AIs in the larger genus.
Rather it is formed by taking a valid concept (being of volitional consciousness), and using a differentiating characteristic that [i]does[/i] exist in reality, but never in conjunction with this genus.
It can be arbitrary to combine genus & differentia this way: 'unicorn' is not valid as a concept describing an animal. So you couldn't define it as a "horse" "with a horn". But it does seem that the word 'unicorn' has valid definition under the genus "a mythical beast".
I think the concept AI falls into a special category of "subjects of scientific research".
But have I identified the correct genus & differentia? i.e. is [u]this[/u] combination valid?
-- Josh