Sorry but what concept am I holding on to that is out of context?
“Perhaps our position converges on the point that without uncoerced consentual economic exchanges, laissez-faire cannot exist.”
Do you agree with me here or not? A yes or no will do.
No.
Short version:
“Protection of individual rights” is the only purpose and the positive duty on the government, to enact its delegated power from sovereign individuals to use retaliatory force in response to the initiation of force against those individuals. “Laissez-faire”, although it follows logically from said only purpose of government, is a negative duty on the government NOT to commit *initiation* of force on individuals i.e. not to violate the individual rights of the individuals. To the extent a government fails at the second duty to NOT violate the rights of individuals it fails at its primary purpose, but a government CAN fulfill its negative second duty perfectly while failing (although attempting) to fulfill its main purpose. Laissez-faire CAN exist even if crime exists. Crime in fact would always exist as there always will be criminals, but this will be completely independent of governments chosen policy NOT to engage in the initiation of force on its citizens.
Extended Version:
Laissez-faire CAN exist whether or not every economic exchange is coerced by one party to the exchange, i.e. a theft (which I hold such as impossible), whether only some economic exchanges are coerced (some theft/crime) and some not, or whether every economic exchange is unforced, i.e. all exchanges are trades (probably not possible either, as crime will always exist) because the nature and kind of exchanges which actually occur is a separate concept from the government’s policy not to interfere, i.e. the policy not to initiate force in the economic sphere which IS laissez-faire.
Trade, sex, music, art, science, philosophy, sports, are all spheres of activity by sovereign individuals in which no proper government has any role to play whatever.
Crime, initiation of force, will always exist amid conduct in every sphere of activity because there will always be criminals. Be careful though, the conduct constituting crime, although amid other activity, is not to be confused with the non-criminal activity. Theft is not trade. Rape is not “consensual sexual activity”.
The concept laissez-faire is restricted to the policy of government towards its citizens, in particular, by common and Objectivist usage, in the economic sphere, the non-initiation of force. This is a negative duty which in logic follows from its mandate to protect individual rights. Laissez-faire DOES NOT mean a mandate for the government to literally NEVER DO ANYTHING. This would be an abdication of the proper role of government which is to exercise the delegated authority to use retaliatory force in answer to initiation of force in any sphere. Laissez-faire means “leave alone” ALL activity (economic) which does not involve the initiation of force which means EXACTLY the same thing as “DO NOT initiate physical force i.e. do not VIOLATE rights of individuals”. For laissez-faire to “exist” the government simply needs to leave alone, i.e. completely ignore all non-criminal activity in EVERY sphere of activity. Economic activity comes along for free. This is a moral duty of the government, a “negative” duty, to refrain from perpetrating crimes on its citizens.
As a separate matter the role in protecting individual rights is a positive mandate on the government to protect individuals from each other and from foreign aggressors, its delegated authority to use retaliatory force in answer to the initiation of force. An effective government will be one which is laissez-faire (NOT violate individual rights, this logically follows from governments primary purpose) as well as one which has good justice, crime prevention, and military systems (PROTECT individual rights, government’s primary purpose).
Let us concretize this a little.
Consider two men trading. This is not laissez-faire. This is trade. This is voluntary action by two sovereign individuals. That is all it is and it has nothing to do whatever with proper government action/jurisdiction. As far as the government is concerned (remember a proper government is not involved in social engineering, or fostering, or funding, or causing things, only protection of individual rights), this activity never happened, because it is literally NONE of its business.
Consider a cop with a gun, telling the men how to trade. This is not laissez-faire; this is a crime being committed on the two men.
Consider a cop observing one man engaging in the initiation of force on another. The cop intervenes with retaliatory force. THIS is the protection of individual rights. This is not an example of laissez-faire, but the exercise of proper government power to use retaliatory force.
Now, consider a cop seated nearby two men trading (recall the definition of trade… it does not include crime, i.e. the initiation of force). The cop peacefully continues to look for something for which his mandate from government would require his intervention. He is blind to ANY non-criminal activity. He abstains from violating individual rights, in particular abstains from violating economic freedom.
THIS is laissez-faire. Laissez-faire is NOTHING ELSE.