Who Killed the Electric Car?

I finally got around to watching this movie. Who else has seen it?

Normally, I would never spend $3.99 on it at Blockbuster, but, unfortunately, I believe it’s actually worth talking about at this point, since a majority of the people I get into discussions/debates with over free markets bring this movie up as evidence of their point that free markets don’t work to solve problems.

If you haven’t seen the movie, the basic premise is that GM came out with this electric car, the EV1, and tried it out amongst a small group of people, all of whom loved it. When GM decided it had to discontinue the car, not pursue further development, the people were outraged, since GM collected their cars and brought them to scrapyards, rather than letting them re-lease it.

The movie presents this event under the guise of, “GM says there wasn’t enough demand for the car, but they hardly even tried to market it; the oil companies were tied to GM (I forget how) and had too much to lose if the electric car became popular; a battery had actually been invented that allowed people to drive 300 miles per charge (a common complaint about the car was that people could only drive 60 miles a day), but GM suppressed it”.

Continually, the movie flashes back to clips of people outside the GM headquarters, picketing and demanding that GM give them back the EV1.

All I could think when I was watching this was of The Fountainhead, when Roark blows up the public housing community he had designed and is put on trial for it.

I mean, these people are DEMANDING, and trying to use California MANDATES to force GM to make this car, even if it is against GM’s interest – all under the guise of the fact that California’s citizens have become endangered by air pollution caused by the cars.

What do you think of this movie, if you’ve seen it? Or the points above – if 1 in 4 Californians REALLY IS suffering lung problems due to the air pollution cause from cars (which is what the movie claims), should California take political action against the car companies, or just let them continue business as usual?

What do you think of this movie, if you’ve seen it? Or the points above – if 1 in 4 Californians REALLY IS suffering lung problems due to the air pollution cause from cars (which is what the movie claims), should California take political action against the car companies, or just let them continue business as usual?

Have you ever been on the L.A. streets during an ueber smoggy day? I have. It is like having a forty pound monkey sitting on one’s chest.

Bob Kolker

No, I’ve never been to LA, but I bet the smog sucks. My question is, what do you propose is done about it, if anything?

Do you think laws should be put into place (this is similar to the issue discussed about global warming political measures (http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.php?showtopic=10832&st=0&p=160804&#entry160804)), or what?

… what do you propose is done about it, if anything?

The best thing would be to move further toward a free economy. If you want to see real pollution, visit a third-world country like India and China, and there are probably worse places. If you want to see total disregard for public safety, check out government owned places (compare Chernobyl to Three Mile Island). As people can afford more, one of the attributes they value more is cleanliness. It’s really that simple.

You may as well go watch a Michael Moore film. That “documentary” is filled with backhanded lies and misleading half-truths.

Here, check out the Edmunds.com editor-in-chief’s review of it.

I think the movie makes very valid points. The real reasons why the electric car was killed was not because GM couldn’t make any money with it, although at some point in the movie the statement was made that the PUBLIC was guilty of not being smart enough to accept it.

But without going into a discussion about who killed the car, let’s say that governmental regulations are a big part of it.

Here in Canada we have an inventor of a great electric vehicle that can’t get it on the market in Canada because the government won’t approve it.

These governmental regulations are a form of control.

The truth is that the electric car is not dead. There’s quite a few companies that are working right now to release new electric vehicles on the road. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_vehicle

Even Toyota is working actively on its own EV, after its success with the Hybrid. See: http://www.hybridcars.com/news2/enerdel-lithium-prius.html

Who cares about GM? If they’re not smart enough to take advantage of a concept that is a true revolution (maybe a small version of the “motor” in Atlas Shrugged), other companies can take over and do it.

The Canadian company that I mentioned is called the Zenn Car (see: http://www.zenncars.com)). Apparently the owner created the car because he was frustrated that this car didn’t exist.

So if it doesn’t exist… build your own. That’s what entrepreneurs do.

The problem is when governmental regulations come in the way and add their own control. Or other companies (such as oil companies) steal, lie and destroy and prevent the use of new technology to delay their own inevitable self-destruction.

You may as well go watch a Michael Moore film. That “documentary” is filled with backhanded lies and misleading half-truths.

Here, check out the Edmunds.com editor-in-chief’s review of it.

Or other companies (such as oil companies) steal, lie and destroy and prevent the use of new technology to delay their own inevitable self-destruction.

What do you mean by this?

My understanding is that oil is a finite resource, electricity is an infinite resource (to a large extent).

The wars of the world seem to be in part about control of this resource, and monopoly over this resource.

Therefore a product like electric cars or other technology pose a threat to companies and government who control the oil resource.

My understanding is that oil is a finite resource, electricity is an infinite resource (to a large extent).

I don’t understand what you mean by “finite” and “infinite” such that both of these claims could be true. Either both are finite, or both are infinite. Perhaps the problem is a misunderstanding about the nature of the infinite?

The wars of the world seem to be in part about control of this resource, and monopoly over this resource.

There is no instance in history that I am aware of where that has been true. You can get a list of wars broken down into various historical periods, if that will help you to make your case. It’s certainly not the case for any of the wars that started since 2000. The best case that you could make would be Saddam’s aggression against Kuwait in 1991 though Hussein’s ostensive excuse was that Kuwait was a “provice” of Iraq (which, in fact, was equally a “province” of Turkey). Anyway, concretely, what is your accusation and evidence regarding war and oil?

I will say first that I’m rather new to Objectivism and I’m here to learn more. I just read Atlas Shrugged and was deeply impressed and moved by it.

I come with the ideas compiled from reading books like “Confessions of an Economic Hitman” and other titles as well as personal reflections, that military interventions in Irak are about control over the oil resource rather than the alleged “war on terrorism”.

As for finite and infinite it is my understanding that electricity can be produced in numerous ways: sun, hydroelectrical power, nuclear, etc., whereas the earth eventually will run out of oil if we keep on using it at the rate we are.

I’d be willing to hear your point of view on the current state of the world/Irak war, etc., and American intervention in these countries (and others).

I get the feeling from reading this forum that most users are of a more pro-American point of view (excuse the term but I want to mean the idea that American military interventions around the world are for the “Freedom of American People” and not for the purpose of controlling the world by force, which is what I believe is the case).

That’s a diversion of topic, but I wonder, why do some many users feel that America is the greatest country in the world (at the moment)?

I’m Canadian and I don’t approve the form of governmental control in our pro-socialist country (welfare system, health system, burden of taxes, making the rich pay, etc.)

But the direction the US is taking seems to be more like a Fascist state, certainly not the capitalist ideal depicted in Atlas Shrugged. To me the US seems to head in a direction that is best described as a mixture of 1984 and Atlas Shrugged.

The use of propaganda and fear tactics is widespread, the “patriot acts” and other forms of control, the invasive government that can throw you in jail without a trial, the IRS gun-equipped agents that can bust your house without a notice, and so on.

That’s my perception and I think it’s an accurate perception of what’s going on in the US right now: a once-great country that is now moving to a fascist state of fear-based control.

I know this is off topic but this is really what I was hoping to get from this forum: an objectivist perspective on the current direction of the US government, and of course, of the Canadian and other world economies.

As for the electric car, I think it’s a great idea if given a chance to live.

I don’t understand what you mean by “finite” and “infinite” such that both of these claims could be true. Either both are finite, or both are infinite. Perhaps the problem is a misunderstanding about the nature of the infinite?There is no instance in history that I am aware of where that has been true. You can get a list of wars broken down into various historical periods, if that will help you to make your case. It’s certainly not the case for any of the wars that started since 2000. The best case that you could make would be Saddam’s aggression against Kuwait in 1991 though Hussein’s ostensive excuse was that Kuwait was a “provice” of Iraq (which, in fact, was equally a “province” of Turkey). Anyway, concretely, what is your accusation and evidence regarding war and oil?

I come with the ideas compiled from reading books like “Confessions of an Economic Hitman” and other titles as well as personal reflections, that military interventions in Irak are about control over the oil resource rather than the alleged “war on terrorism”.

None of the above, really. The real reason to have a war in Iraq was to depose the dictator Saddam Hussein, who posed some element of threat to peace and freedom outside Iraq and certainly deserved what he got for his actions inside Iraq. Of course the current continuation of the war is based on the altruistic nation-building premise that Bush has accepted as his credo. In the course of that war, of course, Iraq has become a center for terrorism. Oil is simply not relevant, despite the leftist’s insisting.

As for finite and infinite it is my understanding that electricity can be produced in numerous ways: sun, hydroelectrical power, nuclear, etc., whereas the earth eventually will run out of oil if we keep on using it at the rate we are.

All of the means of producing electricity on earth are finite. You should be comparing comparables – fuels. There are a finite number of ways to create electricity and a finite amount of those fuels. The proper concern should be whether this or that is practical in the long term. The repeatedly failed predictions of oil shortages are so famous that we really ought to consider petroleum to be an infinite resource.

The use of propaganda and fear tactics is widespread, the “patriot acts” and other forms of control, the invasive government that can throw you in jail without a trial, the IRS gun-equipped agents that can bust your house without a notice, and so on.

You won’t find many people around here supporting an American dictatorship. Just because we don’t hate America because America is automatically wrong (it has been said), doesn’t mean that we support the Patriot Act, suspensions of habeas corpus, taxation and armed tax-agents stealing property from individuals, or any of the other acts of wrongful force carried out by the government.

As for the electric car, I think it’s a great idea if given a chance to live.

It’s not a matter of it being “given a chance to live”, it’s simply not a viable idea at present. I have no objection to electric cars per se: I object to cars that go only 40 miles a day at a top speed of 25 mph, and require 8 hours to fill the tank. Build me an electric car that’s as good as my Xterra, and I’ll consider buying it (when I’m in the market for new wheels). Nobody is denying electric cars a “chance”.

As for finite and infinite it is my understanding that electricity can be produced in numerous ways: sun, hydro electrical power, nuclear, etc., whereas the earth eventually will run out of oil if we keep on using it at the rate we are.

Since the earth is finite, oil must be so too. However, suppose we assume that there is enough oil in the earth to last 50 centuries with the current projected population increases; then, the question of finiteness becomes unimportant. Most people who argue that oil will run out are using a simple calculation: they take the current known reserves and they take the assumed annual usage, and using these they come up with a statistic like: we have 30 years of oil left, or something similar.

It is important to understand that “known reserves” can be a deceptive term. Suppose we know, for instance, that some oil can be extracted from an area, but only at a huge cost – say $300 a barrel. Is that oil part of the “known reserve”? As usually computed, it is not. A deposit is only counted as a known reserve if it can be exploited economically. This brings up two ways in which known reserves increase, even without new exploration. Firstly, people figure out new ways to tap oil. In the ocean, for example, people have been able to get to oil at greater depths. Just last month, Brazil’s oil-company tried a new technique at depths never tried before, and overnight their estimates of reserves have been raised from 14 bbl to 21bbl! Secondly, as the price of oil rises, deposits that were previously uneconomical become economical. For instance, oil is present in shale and in “oil-sands”. There are many such deposits in the U.S. itself. Many of these were explored but given up as being not worth pursuing. However, at some price, they become worth pursuing. The recent oil-price rise has made Alberta’s oil-sands viable, and Canada suddenly shot up to having one of the worlds largest known reserves!

Now, let’s suppose we calculate that there are 30 years of oil left to go. When we do the same calculation next year, how many years of oil will we have? The answer will be 29 if the initial assumptions were right. However, what keeps happening is that the known reserves keep increasing. These do not increase smoothly every year. When the price of oil is low (relative to its historical norm) exploration slows down considerably. When the price rises, it gives exploration an incentive. Even here, oil-companies do not go out and spend millions until they conclude that the higher price is durable: that it reflects some real increase in demand.

The last couple of decades have seen India and China boom in a way that would not have been predictable in the 1970’s and even the 1980’s. This has caused an increase in demand (not just consumption demand, but also industrial demand, as those countries make goods for export). This demand pushed prices up and became an incentive to explore. Not just oil; almost all commodities have seen large price increases in the last few years.

Price rises also cause substitution and economization. For instance, if oil and natural gas rise past a certain point, more people will consider using electricity to heat their homes. Higher prices will make gas-guzzlers more expensive to run, and will thus curb demand there. Right now, the price of oil is still low in real terms, so there is no good reason for people to conserve. If there was a true shortage, prices would rise high enough so that people would shift their purchases. Of course, this does not imply that the government should force prices higher via higher gas-taxes.

As for electricity, if one went nuclear, I cannot imagine how there could be any practical shortage. The finiteness would be irrelevant.

Much has been written on the subject. The late Dr. Julian Simon spent a lifetime arguing that there was one key unlimited resource: human ingenuity and inventiveness. His books are online. You can check them out here.

Since the earth is finite, oil must be so too. However, suppose we assume that there is enough oil in the earth to last 50 centuries with the current projected population increases; then, the question of finiteness becomes unimportant. Most people who argue that oil will run out are using a simple calculation: they take the current known reserves and they take the assumed annual usage, and using these they come up with a statistic like: we have 30 years of oil left, or something similar.

We have had thirty years of oil left for the last seventy years.

Bob Kolker

Basically, what SoftwareNerd said. I might also refer you to Chapter 12 of Thomas Sowell’s, “Basic Economics,” under the heading of “Natural Resources” – which I believe has even been quoted to some extent somewhere on this forum.

I get the feeling from reading this forum that most users are of a more pro-American point of view (excuse the term but I want to mean the idea that American military interventions around the world are for the “Freedom of American People” and not for the purpose of controlling the world by force, which is what I believe is the case).

I’m not going to speak for other people on the forum, but I will say that I am of a “more pro-American point of view” such to the extent that America is a country that embraces freedom and does not sacrifice its citizens.

I’ll agree with you that the United States is not ideal – far from it. But before we go around making accusations of the United States becoming a fascist state based upon things like the USA PATRIOT ACT – I have to ask you, what is your perception of the evils of the Patriot Act? … I’m not denying here (nor am I sanctioning) any of the supposed injustices incurred by the Patriot Act, but it is something that has generated a lot of hype, most of which, if my understanding is correct, is simply false.

Thanks for all the responses and the great insights.

My perspective on the US may be flawed but whenever I spent a day in a US airport I cringe at what I see broadcast on national television. To me it’s nothing short of blatant fear-based propaganda.

(Example: broadcast that the “alert level” of any particular day is red, yellow orange or whatever, without any proof whatsoever)

By the way, I lived for 3 years in the US from 1997 until 2000 and completely enjoyed my experience there. Lots has changed since.

What do you think of this movie, if you’ve seen it?

I found the external pressuring of GM to drop the EV1 to be deplorable, but I still had a lot of questions at the end of the film. I can’t remember them now as it’s been several months since I’ve seen it, but I do remember thinking that the whole story wasn’t told.

Or the points above – if 1 in 4 Californians REALLY IS suffering lung problems due to the air pollution cause from cars (which is what the movie claims), should California take political action against the car companies, or just let them continue business as usual?

If GM doesn’t want to make an electric car, they shouldn’t be forced into it by the state, even if there is a “public health” issue. It might be arguable if [A] the smog were created solely by GM automobiles and there was an irrefutable link between that smog and mass numbers of sick people, but that’s not the case at all.

The first thing I thought to myself after watching this doc, though, was this: Given obvious demand for more fuel-efficient automobiles, wouldn’t it be great if someone - like Gates or Buffet - instead of flushing their billions away into altruistic charity, used their money to create viable electric cars as competition for internal combustion cars? The engineering exists, the engineers exist, and the demand is palpable. Think of the money that could be made if some company, independent of the infused state-corporate realm of automobiles, came out with something like the EV1?

There is one that I can think of - Tesla Motors - but the base price for their Roadster is $98,000. Not that it’s a bad thing, but something more like the EV1 would really be great.

(Not that I care about ‘environmental concerns’, of course, but more that it’s about saving money in the long run not having to buy gasoline all the time.)

I will say first that I’m rather new to Objectivism and I’m here to learn more. I just read Atlas Shrugged and was deeply impressed and moved by it.

Then I will excuse your rudeness, since it is likely inadvertent.

Let me explain: it’s not good form to just come here, brand new, and start simply asserting your ultra-leftist views as the uncontested and obvious truth - especially when you know (as you said) that you will be disagreed with.

Next time, instead of hijacking someone else’s thread and making a series of unsupported assertions based on your obviously controversial ideas about war and oil, what would be much more polite would be to actually do a search and find out the numerous threads on this board about “peak oil” and the wars of the 21st century.

If you have questions to ask or opinions to present, it would be polite to present them in the context of places where they are actually open for discussion.

A lot of people put a lot of effort into explaining those issues in those other threads, specifically so that people would not continue to spout them off randomly all across the board.

Now, that said, all of the above is presented as a matter of etiquette. The trouble I’m highlighting here is not your disagreement as such, but the way that you chose to express it.

As for your views themselves, as Softwarenerd and David Odden have explained they are badly mistaken. I’ve already posted extensively on the subject, however, so if you want my opinion do please avail yourself of the search button. If you have any questions or remain unconvinced I’m generally glad to respond to direct replies to my posts - provided that the poster has done me the courtesy of having read the whole discussion so I don’t have to repeat ad nauseam what has already been said.

Professor Plumb, in the garage, with the wrench.