In a discussion on “4AynRandFans”, someone asked why some things – like food from a street vendor – are so cheap in poor countries (e.g. in Thailand). I posted this example there, and decided to post it here too.
This example is in response to the original question of the topic.
Situation 1: Suppose a Thai person who has two employment options:
- Either, he tills the soil, producing 20MT (20,000kg) of rice each year; or,
- is a street-hawker selling 20,000 servings of food per year
Clearly, as a street-hawker, he must price his wares so that each serving contains a labor cost equivalent to 1 kg of rice.
Situation 2: Instead, suppose he was able work on a farm that was more capital-intensive. Suppose the capital enabled better irrigation, fertilizer, pesticides, harvesting equipment, and storage facilities. Suppose, by doing this, he could double his output to 40 MT of grain.
We should also assume that the provider of capital requires a return. Assume that the provider of capital takes the equivalent of 15MT of grain, and pays his labor the equivalent of 25MT of grain (to coax the street hawkers to come work for him). Over time, street-hawking becomes less attractive, unless the hawker can price in the equivalent of (25MT/20,000=) 1.25kg. of grain per food-serving.
Summary: Raising the productiveness of a unit of labor in one industry will draw labor to that industry until the wage rates for similar labor are similar across industries. The higher productiveness in one industry does not raise the wages in that industry alone, but in other industries as well.
The effect of money: Using money, instead of “kgs. of rice” shows the same effect. Suppose Thai rice is about $300/MT. So, 20 MT is $6,000. To get $6,000 from selling food, one has to price in a labor cost of ($6000/20000=) $0.30 per serving. The capitalist-farmer in the second example pays his labor ($300/MT x 25MT=) $7,500. Soon enough, street-hawkers need ($7,500/20,000=) $0.38 per serving, to make it worth their while.