Why is the U.S. military successful?

If statist institutions by their very fact that they are statist, tend to be inefficient and difficult to adapt to change, what then, are the reasons why the US Army (which does get some income for selling equipment but the majority of its funds come from taxes) has remained the force with the greatest reach in the world, the greatest strength, and the greatest flexibility?

If statist institutions by their very fact that they are statist, tend to be inefficient and difficult to adapt to change, what then, are the reasons why the US Army (which does get some income for selling equipment but the majority of its funds come from taxes) has remained the force with the greatest reach in the world, the greatest strength, and the greatest flexibility?

Because it gets more tax loot than any other military force in the world. With enough money, there is no inefficiency you can’t pave over.

Successful compared to what? There are some people who say that the US military could be far more efficient than it already is, in terms of both cost and lives lost in the course of carrying out its mission. (Yaron Brook, executive director of ARI, for one.) Also, look at the enemies they fight: if anything they’re even more “statist” than our military.

Not that Eric’s explanation has nothing to do with it either. The US military gets a lot of money. That counts for quite a bit.

If statist institutions by their very fact that they are statist, tend to be inefficient and difficult to adapt to change, what then, are the reasons why the US Army (which does get some income for selling equipment but the majority of its funds come from taxes) has remained the force with the greatest reach in the world, the greatest strength, and the greatest flexibility?

I dont think the “funded by taxation == inefficient” argument is valid in the context of the military, since the military is outside the realm of competition as long as we dont have anarchy. Even if it were funded entirely be voluntary donations, its not like you could choose to donate to a ‘different military’ if you disliked the inefficient one.

Having said that, I agree with the above 2 posts.

Succesful it what aspects? As far as special forces go, Britian is still out there, and the US army is by no means the best peacekeeping force. Technologically sure.

I dont think the “funded by taxation == inefficient” argument is valid in the context of the military, since the military is outside the realm of competition as long as we dont have anarchy. Even if it were funded entirely be voluntary donations, its not like you could choose to donate to a ‘different military’ if you disliked the inefficient one.

Here is a question that illustrates why there may be certain inefficiencies, specifically misallocation of resources, in government-allocated military expenditures: how much defense is enough? In fiscal year 2004, the U.S. spent $466.0 billion on defense. That’s about $1.58 per man, woman or child. Now how do we know that $1.58 is sufficient? Or not enough? Or too much? Since the decisions about levels of expenditures are made independently of those who contribute those dollars, it is impossible to know whether or not the buyer is getting the correct amount of defense. For ranch owners along the U.S./Mexico border who regularly suffer property damage from illegal immigrants, $1.58 may not be enough. For U.S. retirees living year-round in Cozumel, $1.58 may be too much.

Here is a question that illustrates why there may be certain inefficiencies, specifically misallocation of resources, in government-allocated military expenditures: how much defense is enough?  In fiscal year 2004, the U.S. spent $466.0 billion on defense.  That’s about $1.58 per man, woman or child.  Now how do we know that $1.58 is sufficient?  Or not enough?  Or too much?  Since the decisions about levels of expenditures are made independently of those who contribute those dollars, it is impossible to know whether or not the buyer is getting the correct amount of defense.  For ranch owners along the U.S./Mexico border who regularly suffer property damage from illegal immigrants, $1.58 may not be enough.  For U.S. retirees living year-round in Cozumel, $1.58 may be too much.

Good point, but there would be a similar problem if funding was voluntary. Suppose I think that ‘enough’ funding amounts to $400 billion, or $1.39 per person. I therefore donate $20, reasoning that since a lot of people wont bother donating anything hence I should try to compensate for the expected deficit. But then when the budget is published, I find that a lot of people thought along the same lines as I did, and many donated $100 or more, bringing the total funding to $900 billion. So next year I am more conservative and only donate $5. But again, everyone else thinks along the same lines and also donates less, so the total funding only comes up to $150 billion.

It would be like a ‘sealed bid’ auction, and I fail to believe it could result in significantly more efficiency than the current system.

Good point, but there would be a similar problem if funding was voluntary. Suppose I think that ‘enough’ funding amounts to $400 billion, or $1.39 per person. I therefore donate $20, reasoning that since a lot of people wont bother donating anything hence I should try to compensate for the expected deficit. But then when the budget is published, I find that a lot of people thought along the same lines as I did, and many donated $100 or more, bringing the total funding to $900 billion. So next year I am more conservative and only donate $5. But again, everyone else thinks along the same lines and also donates less, so the total funding only comes up to $150 billion.

It would be like a ‘sealed bid’ auction, and I fail to believe it could result in significantly more efficiency than the current system.

The important point is that some people, for example the border ranchers I mentioned, may need more defense than they are currently getting. Why shouldn’t they be able to increase their contributions not just to raise the overall defense budget but rather their own particular level of defense?

The U.S. Military is successful because we worship Minerva and would-be aggressors worship Ares.

I think that one of the major reasons why the United States has the best armed forces is that it is a volunteer army.

People choose to become soldiers in the U.S. armed forces for a variety of selfish reasons: the Montgomery G.I. Bill, the opportunities to travel, a yearning for adventure, etc.

Good point, but there would be a similar problem if funding was voluntary. Suppose I think that ‘enough’ funding amounts to $400 billion, or $1.39 per person. I therefore donate $20, reasoning that since a lot of people wont bother donating anything hence I should try to compensate for the expected deficit. But then when the budget is published, I find that a lot of people thought along the same lines as I did, and many donated $100 or more, bringing the total funding to $900 billion. So next year I am more conservative and only donate $5. But again, everyone else thinks along the same lines and also donates less, so the total funding only comes up to $150 billion.

They would simply bring over the surplus from the last year, as it is unlikely they would spend more then 400 billion in a year.

On the money issue, I did hear that our military budget is larger than that of the military budgets of the entire rest of the world combined. It was on television and in passing, so I’m not sure of the accuracy, but we sure do spend more than everyone else.

I am surprised no one has called the error on this one yet:

With enough money, there is no inefficiency you can’t pave over.

Without REASON, you can have all the money in the world and still get nowhere. If you are don’t know how to use your money to “pave over” your inefficiencies (whatever that means), you will remain inefficient.

JMegan said it best:

The U.S. Military is successful because we worship Minerva and would-be aggressors worship Ares.

Without REASON, you can have all the money in the world and still get nowhere. If you are don’t know how to use your money to “pave over” your inefficiencies (whatever that means), you will remain inefficient.

A related example is the Soviet sport teams. A lot of people use a similar “preponderance of resources” to explain why the Soviet teams did so well at the Olympics.

JMegan said it best:

Yes. When I read Jennifer’s post I did a search for “Miverva” and for “Ares”, and realized that she’s said it all :slight_smile:

I am surprised no one has called the error on this one yet:

Without REASON, you can have all the money in the world and still get nowhere. If you are don’t know how to use your money to “pave over” your inefficiencies (whatever that means), you will remain inefficient.

Since you are not clear on what my phrase “pave over inefficiencies” means, I’ll give you another example. Our city-owned water department for decades has been a textbook case of inertia, mismanagement, political cronyism and kickbacks. No company could operate like this in the market for a month, much less a half century. Nonetheless, despite having to shut down water services in some neighborhoods almost regularly and fighting off lawsuits from other municipalities downstream, the department actually continues to grow, add new employees and grant its managers pay raises. How? Because any financial shortfall is covered by a tax increase.

No, reason has not been banned entirely from the water department, but then even the USSR somehow got satellites into orbit.

the department actually continues to grow

But is it successful ? Are its services superior to other water services?

This thread, after all, is not about the size of the U.S. military but its superiority.

But is it successful ? Are its services superior to other water services?

The only objective measure of the success of an enterprise is its ability to make profits. Since my water department has been a net consumer of tax loot since its inception, it is not successful in any sense. As for comparing it to other water services, its legal monopoly status insures zero competitors and thus direct comparisons are impossible.

This thread, after all, is not about the size of the U.S. military but its superiority.

In military planning, size and superiority go hand in hand. In any case, since the U.S. defense budget is more than seven times larger than the world’s second biggest defense spender, it is hardly surprising that the U.S. military is superior to all others. At one time the Soviet Union outspent the U.S. in rocket development and as a result had a superior space program.

In any case, since the U.S. defense budget is more than seven times larger than the world’s second biggest defense spender, it is hardly surprising that the U.S. military is superior to all others.

My contention, though, is that even if Al-Qaeda had double the U.S. defense budget, the U.S. could still beat them. Rational people can make more out of a little money than death-worshipping savages out of a lot of money.

My contention, though, is that even if Al-Qaeda had double the U.S. defense budget, the U.S. could still beat them. Rational people can make more out of a little money than death-worshipping savages out of a lot of money.

This is exciting news. The CIA has estimated Al-Qaeda’s finances at $30 million per annum. That means the U.S. can reduce what it is spending to fight Al-Qaeda to less than $30 million.

Another point: I do not know the exact proportions, but I venture to say that the per capita ratio of military spending to GDP is actually lower for the U.S. than, say, it was for Afghanistan uder the Taleban. Americans spent a smaller proportion of their earnings on defense and yet could easily defeat Afghanistan. Why? Again, for the reason Jennifer stated.

(Don’t you love the word “reason” ?) :wink: