I’m an anti-taxation minarchist and a big fan of Ayn Rand. I convinced of Rand’s metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical views, but I’m not sure of some of her political views. One of them is her belief that all property should be privately owned. I don’t think the idea is outrageous, but I’m just not convinced of it.
Why should all property be privately owned? I honestly haven’t (to the best of my recollection) come across an argument by Rand for why this should be the case.
I listened to a podcast
by Peikoff about this subject. He says “Collective ownership doesn’t mean anything.” I suppose he means “collective ownership” is a contradiction in terms. Why is this the case?
Here’s the rub for me:
Suppose someone owns the roads and sidewalks of a neighborhood. This means that if people who live in the houses want to get around, they either (1) must have permission by the road-owner to walk/drive on their property or (2) use alternate means of getting around (using a jetpack, a helicopter, flubber-boots, or tunneling, although I suppose most Objectivists would say tunneling under someone’s property violates their property rights, while flying above it doesn’t). If the road owner decides that you can’t use their roads/sidewalks, how are you going to get around? Do you really have to try as best you can to live off of your own (small) bit of land? Or are you just supposed to go with the jetpack option?
I surmise some Objectivists at this point might say, “Other people could bring you food.” Let’s suppose the road/sidewalk owner doesn’t allow anyone to travel on the roads and that the road-owner is wealthy enough to keep this up indefinitely (I’m guessing maintenance costs won’t be very high if no one’s using the roads).
When I say wealthy, I don’t just mean “has a lot of money.” If a person with a lot of money owned these roads, they would quickly become hated and no one (or almost no one) would trade with them. Perhaps they would quickly starve. However, let’s say this person controls enough productive property that they’re getting all their short-term needs met without trade (they own a good deal of arable land, for example). Therefore, even if no one decides to work for them, they can still survive.
Is the inconvenience you’re being subjected to because you can’t use the roads really moral? Do you have to jetpack around now? Why not have the roads which are public now remain public and be maintained by voluntary donations by people (the same way the military, police, and courts would be financed)?
Since rights are contextual, I’m thinking having public roads might be compatible with Rand’s ethics. For example, someone has the right to their life, but not if they carry a virus which will quickly wipe out the human race unless they’re killed. Or, you have the right to operate a bar on your property (without having to deal with zoning), but you don’t have the right to disturb the peace. Couldn’t it be reasonable to say the opportunity to keep people from moving around on foot/with a car is bad?
Some Objectivists might at this point say “So why not make all roads public?” I think this is like saying there shouldn’t be any zoning whatsoever, because if you allow some zoning, then there’s no good answer to why you shouldn’t have more zoning than X amount of it. Yet, I believe Rand herself said (I think this is in the Ayn Rand Q&A book) something to the effect of “An industrialist shouldn’t be allowed to manufacture explosives near a crowded residential area with schools.”
I surmise some Objectivists might also say “This sounds incredibly unlikely. Why would a road-owner not want to profit from their property by letting people use it?” To me, that’s just a utilitarian argument, and not substantively different from an anarchist saying “But why would a private defense firm/court behave badly if they need a good reputation to stay in business?” Or, they might say “This sounds like a fantasy.” But it’s certainly within the realm of possibility, which I think is all that counts.
All the people in this neighborhood can’t get around (easily). They could then sell their property, but who would buy it if they couldn’t use the roads?
I suppose if the roads get privatized, we could have a homestead-ish system where the people living nearby get shares in a roads corporation. But what about when they move? And wouldn’t a requirement that only people living nearby get shares in the road corporation be anti-capitalistic (at least, according to Rand). And where do you draw the line between one zone and another? Would we have to allocate shares to everyone in the country for all the roads?