By the way,
I often get “Tackled” by certain issues… I find it hard to explain why goverment should be limited and why unregulated capitalism is the most moral way when im debating people. I’m usually saying that it’s not moral to take my money via taxes with coercion in order to pay somebody else’s lifestyle, but then, even though they are not anarchists, they put me in the corner saying “So you are willing to take from people in order to pay police and courts but not other things?”, and I answer than, and I explain the laizes-faire point, but I always end up trying to defend that position and explain why anarchy is immoral… it’s rather tiring. maybe you have a rebuttal for that.
I get this frequently when talking politics. The user jumps from a point on Federal taxation this tosses in something about police of firemen. At the point I first ask the person if I should finish the point on federal policy or switch to talking local community politics. Then from there I point out that a community that wants police can easily work with each other, as adults, learn to communicate, and then through voluntary association come up with means of paying for police or any other service. The point is, if you start with the principle that you are not going to force participation then you can open up the discussion. The users point is that forced participation is the only way. Simply ask them that if they were a community leader and had to talk to locals to generate revenue what they might do. If they insist on force being the only “practical” means then you are pulling the conversation towards them justifying a statist approach to dealing with their neighbor.
A good leader should be able to motivate a community and influence others through voluntary appeal to their values with reason. One of the greatest indications of the vacuum existing in politics today is that there are few leaders that do this. The common answer is to write a bill to force people to participate. In business, such people who force others through position are regarded as poor managers. They need their position to influence people. In politics they are regarded as strong leaders that “get things done”. It’s sad really.
The idea is forced association versus voluntary association – If anything they should be the ones to explain why force is a legitimate method of human interaction.
And another thing:
Someone asked me if I support limiting the speed of drivers on the road (can you go 200miles an hour if you want to?) or if I support laws about crossing the street or driving through a red light. I tried to think about it, but came to a blank. I tried to compare that to legalizing weapon carrying, which I agree for the most part with the Objectivist party view (that it should not be granted to ex criminals), so why would I object a limitless speed on the roads?
I was certain that if I go down that road of “Voluntary communites can excersize certain norms/laws” he would “extrapolate” that to a state level, and I dont really know what to answer to that.
This falsely assumes that people will just mindlessly turn into animals and do whatever they want, as if the Government was the only thing between us and the fall of Western Civilization. Bureaucrats wouldn’t even have a paycheck without someone earning it for them, let alone having some power to hold back a Pictish wilderness of anarchy.
It also confuses Government policy with any terms inherent in using something. If that road belonged to me I would still set terms on its use and they would include safety. A speed limit since such a limit is good for the road, the car, as well as the safety of the customers using that road, or if it was an interstate I could take the limit off but impose other rules Autobahn style to control high speed safety. There are many ways to set terms of use. The gross assumption is that the Government is the arbitrator of standards when some of us would be even harder on motorists.
For example, as a driver safety instructor I know the bad habits and common cause of accidents so I would expect those that used my road to follow additional rules too. A good one is that the government ignores rules regarding those that speed up to a construction zone then merge into traffic at the last second to avoid the back-up in the open lane – I would revokes these people’s passes for a period. Same for those that like to read a paper, shave, or do other ridiculously bone headed things while driving… They would also get the boot.
Now the good thing for others is that if I impose too many safety restrictions they can simply choose to ignore my road and use someone else’s. That is the good thing about private property – Unlike a bureaucracy you can choose to ignore it and the owner.
And this brings us back to the point of free association versus forced association.