I regard as a possible (and not necessarily negative) consequence of the establishment of an objectivist-certified government is that it would eventually devolve into the sort of anarchist system advocated by Murray Rothbard, albeit one which actually functions to protect human rights. The idea is that if we start with a full compliment of police, military, and courts, with the understanding that individuals are supposed to contribute voluntarily to the government, then at each stage where a businessman needs a specific sort of physical or legal protection he will end up purchasing part of that service on the market from private security or private arbitrartion, and thus redirect some of his protection budget from the government to private enterprise. This private protection will still remain under the official government, but it will come to provide a progressively larger and larger amount of the protection of the country. Eventually, overseer organizations will sprout up, so that you will eventually have the equivalent of state supreme courts for private arbitration organizations, albeit still under the watchful eye of the government. If at any point an organization which provides philosophically improper protection services, it will come into contact with the equivalent level of the proper protection services, and either be outcompeted by the proper services or destroyed by the government. What you will eventually end up with is an atrophied police and court system and a set of private police organizations and courts all operating according to objective standards, since they grew up under the auspices of the government, but doing so much more efficiently than the government would. Naturally, if any organization begins to provide improper protection services and no organization outcompetes them, people will regrow the government and the whole process will start all over again, although I do not think this is likely to happen.
First, do people agree that this is likely to happen? Second, if it does, would it be good?