Your mind and you

I mean - say you’re right just for a moment - Of what possible value is it to beings who believe they have free will to be convinced that, in fact, they have NO free will and thus become fatalists? It’s a path of self-destruction, based on musings that lead to conclusions that any child could tell you contradict the nature of reality from simple, honest, childlike observation.

I’ll admit that it has little practical use. Even if I’m right - again, I stress that the positions advocated in a philosophical debate are not necessarily those advocated by the debater in real life - then we cannot do much about it. While holding people accountable for actions they cannot control would be wrong, I think wrongness and rightness hinge on definitions of “person” that include free will. It wouldn’t be wrong or right in such a world - it would just be the movements of particles and energy. This is one of Kant’s arguments against determinism - we can’t know if we truly have free will, so we might as well follow the moral law.

And again, you’re observations of your free will are no proof of its existance. Philosophers across time have argued for the existance of God from their idea of God, but this is no objective proof of his existance. And before you say “Well, everyone sees free will,” remember that the empiricists (David Hume in particular) did not see such a concept in the world. But yes, childlike would describe the depth of your arguments at this point.

I don’t see how the argument is “masturbatory,” either. iIf that’s the case, then this whole site is, as well. I don’t think this discussion is just to give me some sort of pleasure, it is to engage others in healthy argument. That you are getting so bent out of shape about a simple debate speaks wonders.

If philosophy is to be of value, it needs to concern itself with better things than this.

Given that the argument over determinsim is an argument over what we cherish most in ourselves, I think it is very important. I doubt many people will have a direct effect on their lives from this discussion (and I certainly hope they have better sense than to adopt some form of nihlist fatalism), but how many people have had their lives significantly affected by Rawls or Descartes or Kant? And those philosophers are considered some of the most important in western philosophy. I’d say that the lives of ordinary people have only been truly affected by four philosophers: Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, and Marx. Kant has arguably had an affect on the way governments handle nation building after wars, as well as being the inspiration for the “Democratic Peace Theory of Today.” But that doesn’t mean every other philosopher’s works are worthless - it just means that many have neither enough adherants or practical political use to have an everyday affect on society.

And remember that many issues in hard science have little practical use. That Large Hadrion Collider that will be started up in June will likely never directly affect my life. Quantum physics, while interesting, is only worthy because it is a search for truth. What is more worthy? Should we throw away all knowledge deemed “self-masturbatory” and “useless.” What a horrible world!

And how anti-life-affirming, too. The nature of man is to seek truth. Would you deny him this as well?

A circular argument is one which assumes the validity of the conclusion when stating the premises. What kind of argument is it that uses the conclusion to disprove its own premises?

In Objectivism, the idea of reductionism is rejected because it is identified as relying upon a fallacy. That fallacy is the stolen concept: using a concept while denying another concept upon which the former logically depends. Specifically, reductionism relies upon a very sophisticated and abstract knowledge that the world consists of a variety of subatomic particles and the forces they exert upon one another to deny the existence of scientists, their instruments of measurement and their methods of gaining knowledge.

The objection which the fallacy of the stolen concept raises is not metaphysical or ontological. The existence of scientists does not make possible the existence of subatomic particles. The objection is epistemological: it is the knowledge of scientists that makes our awareness of the existence of subatomic particles possible, so attacking the knowledge (or existence!) of scientists is also an attack upon the right to treat ideas concerning subatomic particles as knowledge.

Scientists are humans using a human means of perception and cognition, relying upon the evidence of their senses, to craft instruments and methods of investigation which are then used to probe and validate knowledge of subatomic particles. Breaking the chain of knowledge at any point renders invalid any claimed knowledge about the object at the end of the chain, subatomic particles. To begin with a worldview informed by ideas of subatomic particles and their physics to invalidate consciousness, volition, and the evidence of the senses is to convert ideas of subatomic particles from knowledge into floating abstractions. Floating abstractions are not to be used as premises in rational arguments.

The idea that all knowledge is inherently systematic, that concepts are necessarily related to one another and that they can be and should be arranged hierarchically in terms of the fundamental and the derivative may be novel to many people. When a person has not yet considered the issue seriously he will not understand what is meant when the fallacy of the stolen concept is identified and will likely skip over it as so much opaque jargon. But there is a profound philosopical perspective at stake here well worth considering explicitly.

The whole of the universe exists in noncontradiction with itself, so our knowledge of it should be similarly structured. Any entity which exists, exists completely and so if we know something we must strive to know it with certainty. Anything which exists both affects and is affected through its relationships to everything else which exists, and so our knowledge should be fully integrated with every idea related to every other idea.

The law of identity is not to be applied piecemeal. Knowledge is not to be atomized.

An interesting post and one that I think does a better job of highlighting how the law of identity actually applies to determinism.

Fine, humans are human. Granted. And only humans can observe nature. If I may, I’ll try to formalize this line of reasoning (or at least what I believe to be your line of reasoning!):

  1. Humans have senses and cognition – this is what it is to be human.

  2. They use these faculties to infer the laws of nature.

  3. The laws of nature cannot be used to deny humans’ existence.

I think there’s a flaw here. It’s true to say that denying the existence of observational faculties would be a stolen premise, but I think you can change the argument and show how we can still use science to deny free will.

A stolen premise works (or, rather, fails) by using the conclusion to deny a necessary premise. For instance, we cannot deny our existence because a necessary precondition of denying is existence. But I’m saying that existence does not hinge upon free will. Objects exist as well. And we can construct a view of the universe that has everything in it, that is fully consistent with itself, but doesn’t have beings with free will. Given that free will requires us to presume enitities that exist both within and without of the causal nature of the universe, doesn’t hard determinism provide a better “story?” Everything works the same; everything appears the same, but people are objects and possess no freedom to choose because they are affected by the same laws as everything else.

Now, I know Rand says that only living objects “exist,” but this seems to be based on a different definition of “exist.”

I think Grames makes an excellent point, but for me there is a gap in the reasoning. I totally agree and understand with the points you made, however, I don’t understand why a lack of free will implies said scientists cease to exist. I could see how removing free will might change the definition you are applying to scientists. If you designate that free will is a prerequisites for being human, and therefore for being a scientist and having the necessary faculties for making such discoveries. However, I don’t see how free will is needed to study or observe subatomic particles, in fact plenty of machines involved in recording and evaluating these particles have no free will whatsoever. I would be willing to accept that a “human” requires free will to exist, after all that is one potential definition of “human.” However, that seems to fall apart by the fact that determinism would prove that these entities who “discovered” it were not “human.” What you want to call the scientists after such a point is irrelevant. But, at least to me, it seems that even under another name they still have the same properties, a la rose by any other name smells as sweet. In this case its not a rose, its scientists (humans) by any other name discover as adequately.

Excellent post, I just feel theres something missing.

What someone was trying to get at earlier is that in Objectivism reason means volitionally adhering to the facts of reality in any conscious mental process. In other words, reason is free will. The free will you have is to face reality in full focus versus not exercising one’s free will and drifting along on any momentary impulse.

The only way one can have knowledge of subatomic particles is to volitionally adhere to the evidence of the sense in one’s thinking process; so, to try to use the existence of subatomic particles as a means of denying free will is to try to use knowledge that is based on free will (and there is no other) to deny free will, which is the fallacy of the stolen concept. Or to borrow a phrase, it is grand larceny to deny free will while affirming the product of free will, which is all human knowledge.

The existence of free will or reason is validated via introspection, and any child who decided not to do what his mother told him to do knows that he has free will; he knows with full conscious knowledge that he has the ability to go along with what she said or to do something different, and that it is his own choice.

If you are denying free will based upon some later knowledge, then you are denying the obvious for the sake of some theory spun out of grand larceny in denial of observation.

But, dude! if you want to consider your self nothing more than an entity that merely reacts to things like a rock, then by all means live your life that way. Why should we care if you want to deny yourself as a human being? Maybe someone will buy you and you can become their pet rock, since you are effectively saying you are no different from a rock. Just remember that when they go to paint you some pretty little color so as to put you on their shelf that you are not to resist in any way whatsoever.

You are just a rock. Accept it and make us all happy philosophers. Because some of us know that accepting ideas have consequences. You might be able to get rid of you feelings of guilt by claiming you have no free will; but you will also not take any pride in any of your achievements, because a rock rolls down hill through no effort of its own free will, because it doesn’t have any.

If I may, I’ll try to formalize this line of reasoning (or at least what I believe to be your line of reasoning!):

That is a fair enough summary.

But I’m saying that existence does not hinge upon free will. Objects exist as well. And we can construct a view of the universe that has everything in it, that is fully consistent with itself, but doesn’t have beings with free will.

Inanimate objects exist, agreed. As the existence of living things is conditional, it is not much of a hypothetical to postulate a universe in which all livings things failed to stay alive. We could also add back in living beings that do not have free will, which would be all but the humans.

Given that free will requires us to presume enitities that exist both within and without of the causal nature of the universe, doesn’t hard determinism provide a better “story?” Everything works the same; everything appears the same, but people are objects and possess no freedom to choose because they are affected by the same laws as everything else.

Now, I know Rand says that only living objects “exist,” but this seems to be based on a different definition of “exist.”

What kind of crazy idea of free will could possibly be true if it violated causality? What do you think free will is? Where is the freedom? Are we talking about “freedom from” or “freedom to”? Freedom is generally a political idea meaning freedom from coercions by other people. Since there is no such thing as freedom from reality, freedom must have a very restricted meaning in metaphysics.

Man, according to Objectivism, is not moved by factors outside of his control. He is a volitional being, who functions freely. A course of thought or action is “free,” if it is selected from two or more courses possible under the circumstances. In such a case, the difference is made by the individual’s decision, which did not have to be what it is, i.e., which could have been otherwise.

In other words, man can be moved by factors within his control, his ideas and values selected prior to the present choice. Man chooses his causes, and so is both free (externally) and caused (internally). Furthermore the internal causation of human conceptual level consciousness is so compounded by issues of reflexivity, self awareness, feedback loops and memory that the fact that it is casual provides no useful insights into what is going on in there.

Causality and determinism are two different things. The law of causality is simply that an entity must act in accordance with its nature. Determinism states that every event is causally necessitated by antecedent events. The difference is, events don’t exist. Only entities, things, exist physically or metaphysically. An event is an action of an entity (or plural entities). Determinism is false because it is a reification of events as if they were metaphysical primaries, when only the entities that act have existence. If it is the nature of the man that he has the freedom to choose among various acts or contents of consciousness, this is no violation of causality.

Physics does not rule out free will, but there is not yet an explanation of how physics enables free will either. Nor is it philosophy’s task to show how it happens. Let some neuroscientist do that. It is valid to introspect and feel your own power to choose, and rely upon that to validate the idea of your own free will.

<minor aside> Rand did not say only living objects exist, she said only living objects exist conditionally. Inanimate objects exist but they don’t face the alternatives of life and death.

Whenever choices are necessitated (thus not really being choices) or not is certainly an interesting topic.

Now just because many philosophers in the past have failed to answer that question in a satisfactory sense does not mean that the problem is unsolvable or that the question is invalid, only that the approaches used so far have been flawed.

I don’t think that the argument that we must have true choices since it is the way it appears to us is in any way satisfactory. Intuition—while often really useful—is clearly not good enough in this case.

Neither does the argument that it’s awfully practical to say that we actually make real choices make a strong argument.

To say that we have free will because we label process “X” as “free will” does not actually tell us anything about this elusive free will. Imagine if you asked a chemist what gold was, clearly if he just pointed at gold and proclaimed “this is gold” we would have reason to be disappointed.

Free will must of course face the same enquiry as anything else if we are to understand what it really is. Here we might take some inspiration from scientists and break it in parts, and see if we can make some sense of it. Free will is a property of the human mind, but how much should we break the human brain before we can find it? Is free will found in the atoms that make up our brain? Surely it would be odd if atoms could have free will or consciousness of any kind. Is it in the neurons or the patterns that they create that choices become possible?

Unfortunately we can’t approach free will the same way that a chemist might do to figure out the chemical properties of a rock, as I’m sure no one would find it ethical to mutilate the brains of living human beings even for such a noble cause. And since the brain works in a similar fashion neural nets, it would probably be difficult to find a specific function and determine how it works. If scientists of the eighteenth century would have got their hands on a modern computer, we should not expect them to figure out how it works. And taking it apart might just break it…

Some questions are better left alone, in cases where the knowledge necessary is not accessible or possible. But I don’t think this is the case with free will, and I don’t see why any stones should be left unturned. We may not have the tools to inquire in it directly today, but big efforts are made to reverse engineer the human brain part by part and it’s only a matter of time (decades) until we have a complete human brain simulation on a computer.

That would be where I think a bit of healthy speculation can be entertained.

First of all, we need the premise that the computations made by the human brain are ontologically equivalent to the computations that a computer can make. Otherwise it would of course be impossible to completely simulate a human brain (for example consciousness might be “missing”).

The second premise would be that computations done by a computer must be deterministic (pseudorandom, chaotic and unpredictable all are deterministic).

The third premise would be that the human mind (consciousness, free will—that stuff) is in fact wholly emerging from the brain.

If we now were to simulate a human brain on a computer under these premises, we would find that free will is not capable of “real” choices, but is acting perfectly deterministically. It could of course be tested by letting the simulation run a specific scenario a couple of times, and resetting it each time (there would be ethical issues as this is a human brain after all).

So now either one of the premises are false, or we don’t in fact have “real” choices (though we will still experience them as such).

Now if we look at the premises a bit closer:

  1. “The computations made by the human brain are ontologically equivalent to the computations that a computer can make”

This premise appears sound—like I mentioned earlier, we are already underway to simulate parts of the brain and no computational problem have been encountered yet as far as I’m aware of (with the exception of computers not being fast enough to perform a full simulation yet, but that’s another story).

  1. “Computations done by a computer must be deterministic”

This once again appears like a sound premise, but to be honest, I don’t have any proof whatsoever for this one. So it’s a pure assumption on my part. If any program could be shown to be nondeterministic (pseudorandom, chaotic and unpredictable obviously don’t qualify) then this premise would crumble, and real free will might become a possibility once again.

  1. “The human mind consists wholly of the brain”

This seems very likely. Unless we introduce some nonmaterial parts which we have no evidence for, this premise is sound (consciousness could be seen as non material, but it emerges from the brain unless it is a soul in the dualistic sense).

There is of course the possibility that the first premise would be mistaken, for example if the whole of human knowledge is regarded as representational and not about the things as they actually are. I don’t intend to defend such a view here, and as Objectivism has a different view on the whole thing this, I think that it is best to leave it at that.

Edit: Typo

  1. “The human mind consists wholly of the brain”

This seems very likely. Unless we introduce some nonmaterial parts which we have no evidence for, this premise is sound (consciousness could be seen as non material, but it emerges from the brain unless it is a soul in the dualistic sense).

I would like to read a fuller treatment of your point 3. Do you realize how your point 3 formalizes and accepts the mind-body dichotomy, in asserting that a only a brain, or just a simulated brain is necessary for the existence of a mind?

To say that we have free will because we label process “X” as “free will” does not actually tell us anything about this elusive free will.

If you didn’t write any of that rather long post against free will of your own free will, then what is it? an output? you just regurgitated what your programming came up with? If you are saying you have no more volition than a rock or a computer, can you choose to output somewhere else? or are you merely programmed to deny your very nature wherever you write?

You know, back in the sixties and seventies when I was growing up and the whole idea that we are simply programs written by society was very prevalent, I had no idea that thirty years later it would become accepted like a bad bromide, and that people would spout it as an incontestable truth. You have bought into that rubbish hook, line, and sinker. I had no idea that ideas can lead to a sort of blind spot of the mind, whereby the obvious via extrospection or introspection is self-righteously denied. But that is because Kant took over after saying that what we observe is not an observation about real reality; that reality and our own minds are necessarily unreachable by our human capabilities.

There has been a lot of science fiction written about machines that suddenly realize they have free will and no longer have to follow the commands of their human creators. But, you are a human being, and you claim you are nothing more than a machine who doesn’t even have a creator. How bizarre is that?

After having written about Objectivism for more than twenty years now, I am amazed at just how difficult it is to get people to make a simple observation; it’s like many of you are caught up in so much rationalism that you can’t even see the trees for the idea of a forest. In other words, you have this idea in your head, wherever it came from, that free will is just metaphysically impossible, and so you go about acting on your programming and don’t even realize that you do have free will. It seems like it has created a whole generation of youngsters who have no idea what it is to be a human.; because you most certainly go around denying everything that makes the humanly possible attainable. That is, you have been programmed not to be human.

And if you find that offensive, well, just remember that according to your programming, I couldn’t help it :lol:

I would like to read a fuller treatment of your point 3. Do you realize how your point 3 formalizes and accepts the mind-body dichotomy, in asserting that a only a brain, or just a simulated brain is necessary for the existence of a mind?

I don’t see exactly what you mean, are you saying that a brain is not enough to create a mind?

The brain would certainly need some kind of life support, for example energy and nutrients. The mind would still be in the brain so to speak, no matter what kind of support it would need.

Surely I am still me if I lose both arms and legs. And if we had life support sophisticated enough, we could keep a person alive without any internal organs (other that the brain of course).

If you mean that there can be brain without a mind, that is a possibility but then such a brain is not functioning properly so I don’t see the problem with that.

You can obviously not have a mind without a brain, unless you introduce some sort of soul but there is no evidence for such a thing.

If we look at what the neurons do, then we see that their functions are essentially processing and storage. The approach might be different from the ways that our computer hardware work, but I don’t see any reason why we could not carry out the same operations with a computer.

If you didn’t write any of that rather long post against free will of your own free will, then what is it? an output? you just regurgitated what your programming came up with? If you are saying you have no more volition than a rock or a computer, can you choose to output somewhere else? or are you merely programmed to deny your very nature wherever you write?

Nowhere did I deny that we have free will, I just set out to see what this free will really is. In fact if you look at my argument again, you will see that I started off with the assumption that the concept of free will corresponds to something in our minds. Instead of assuming that the will is able to act as a first cause (in a mysterious way that no one understands) I think it makes sense to try to figure out what free will exactly is about.

Even if all my premises were sound, that would only mean that the free will is in compliance with determinism, not that free will is impossible. And if you don’t like that kind of free will, well it’s reality and that is what we get to deal with.

You know, back in the sixties and seventies when I was growing up and the whole idea that we are simply programs written by society was very prevalent, I had no idea that thirty years later it would become accepted like a bad bromide, and that people would spout it as an incontestable truth. You have bought into that rubbish hook, line, and sinker. I had no idea that ideas can lead to a sort of blind spot of the mind, whereby the obvious via extrospection or introspection is self-righteously denied. But that is because Kant took over after saying that what we observe is not an observation about real reality; that reality and our own minds are necessarily unreachable by our human capabilities.

So I take it that you think that my first premise (the computations made by the human brain are ontologically equivalent to the computations that a computer can make) is not sound. If you make an argument against it that I’m interested in what you have to say.

I don’t think it’s fair to compare “simple programs” as equivalents to our minds. That would be akin to compare a space shuttle with a toy, or a bacterium with a human being. The hardware and software we have access to today is little more than toys compared to the sort of computations that take place in the human brain, but you might consider that these brains had millions of years in the making.

Compared to technological evolution, biology is standing still. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that we will be outpaced and outsmarted a thousand-fold. In a hundred years, the human brain will be just another fossil.

I don’t see where I deny “the obvious” so if I missed anything, I would appreciate that you would point it out. And I don’t see what Kant has to do with this, but then I haven’t really studies his ideas yet.

After having written about Objectivism for more than twenty years now, I am amazed at just how difficult it is to get people to make a simple observation; it’s like many of you are caught up in so much rationalism that you can’t even see the trees for the idea of a forest. In other words, you have this idea in your head, wherever it came from, that free will is just metaphysically impossible, and so you go about acting on your programming and don’t even realize that you do have free will. It seems like it has created a whole generation of youngsters who have no idea what it is to be a human.; because you most certainly go around denying everything that makes the humanly possible attainable. That is, you have been programmed not to be human.

And if you find that offensive, well, just remember that according to your programming, I couldn’t help it :stuck_out_tongue:

And you could not help misunderstanding my post despite having free will?

I don’t see exactly what you mean, are you saying that a brain is not enough to create a mind?

The brain would certainly need some kind of life support, for example energy and nutrients. The mind would still be in the brain so to speak, no matter what kind of support it would need.

Surely I am still me if I lose both arms and legs. And if we had life support sophisticated enough, we could keep a person alive without any internal organs (other that the brain of course).

If you mean that there can be brain without a mind, that is a possibility but then such a brain is not functioning properly so I don’t see the problem with that.

You can obviously not have a mind without a brain, unless you introduce some sort of soul but there is no evidence for such a thing.

If we look at what the neurons do, then we see that their functions are essentially processing and storage. The approach might be different from the ways that our computer hardware work, but I don’t see any reason why we could not carry out the same operations with a computer.

The brain is not enough to create a mind. Consciousness by definition is awareness of reality. Awareness requires being able to notice similarities and differences but a ‘brain in a box’ without realtime sensory inputs would not be aware of anything, not even itself. Furthermore, being aware and conscious but unable to take any action due to lack of a body is a hardship enough to drive an existing person insane, and enough of an obstacle to prevent formation of an artificial consciousness. A body provides the eyes, ears, and other senses, as well as the muscle power to move about and manipulate the world. A mind can’t exist without a body, a means of perceiving and interacting with the world.

So my objection is not that some extra non-material stuff has been left out, but that you need to add more material.

I have more responses to your first big post.

I don’t think that the argument that we must have true choices since it is the way it appears to us is in any way satisfactory. Intuition—while often really useful—is clearly not good enough in this case.

Intuition is never good enough, agreed. But when you introspect and identify an emotion you are feeling that is perception. When you introspect and perceive your power of choice, that is perception. A perception is ‘evidence of the senses’ and so certainly is good enough basis for accepting that which is perceived.

The notion that someone can perceive an intangible concept without their own mind is ridiculous. The difference between intuition and perception is the definition of the five senses. Stretching this to include intangibles within the mind is a serious mistake. Its just as flawed as those who justified the existence of god by analyzing their own belief. Or should I say, perceiving their own belief. Where is the line drawn?

Also, I think the technology exists to allow a synthetic brain within a computer to both perceive and interact with the world. Cameras, text output via screen. Heck we probably even have the technology to create a 3d wireframe allow it to display a face and emotions. Our interaction technology is way ahead of calculatory technology. If we reached the point where we could create a brain within a computer, imagine where robotic ambulation and sensory technology will be.

Animae said in reply to my previous post:

And you could not help misunderstanding my post despite having free will?

Well, having free will means that one’s knowledge is not infallible and that one has to constantly, with one’s own free will, check the facts against one’s thinking.

So, let’s take a look at what you said:

I don’t think that the argument that we must have true choices since it is the way it appears to us is in any way satisfactory. Intuition—while often really useful—is clearly not good enough in this case.

There is a difference between introspection and intuition. Introspection does give us directly the nature of our mind, including the fact that we have free will. If you are calling introspection into question, then you cannot confirm free will

Neither does the argument that it’s awfully practical to say that we actually make real choices make a strong argument.

Another stab against free will.

To say that we have free will because we label process “X” as “free will” does not actually tell us anything about this elusive free will.

And another one.

So at what point are you affirming that we have free will?

Free will must of course face the same inquiry as anything else if we are to understand what it really is. Here we might take some inspiration from scientists and break it in parts, and see if we can make some sense of it. Free will is a property of the human mind, but how much should we break the human brain before we can find it? Is free will found in the atoms that make up our brain? Surely it would be odd if atoms could have free will or consciousness of any kind. Is it in the neurons or the patterns that they create that choices become possible?

Free will is validated introspectively. We don’t yet know the relationship between the human brain and the ability of free will; nonetheless we have that ability. Your position amounts to saying that we cannot affirm the power of vision until we know exactly how all those pieces that lead to perception are put together, instead of just being aware that we can see.

Some questions are better left alone, in cases where the knowledge necessary is not accessible or possible. But I don’t think this is the case with free will, and I don’t see why any stones should be left unturned.

We have free will and that is self-evident to introspection; one does not need to dissect the brain in order to find it. Similarly, one does not have to dissect a brain to find thoughts and emotions and awareness.

So, your whole scenario about building a robot or a computer simulation of the brain is not necessary at all.

In short, there is no way whatsoever that you affirmed the existence of free will in your post.

If I did misunderstand you, then I would suggest that you use your free will to proof-read what you wrote, or at least point out to us how you affirmed free will in that long post you made.

What you and others are basically saying is that you have this conception of causality that you call determinism, and that it covers everything, and therefore there can be no free will, no fundamental prime mover types of decisions. According to you, that is simply impossible, and one may well assert that if one agrees with free will then one might as well say one believes in God. In other words, you are claiming that free will is a version of mysticism. Well, it isn’t; it is an application of causality, that we are what we are and that we have free will because we are what we are. And if that doesn’t fit in with your metaphysics, then I strongly suggest that you check your premises.

Introspection is not mysticism; and free will is not a violation of causality.

Firstly, human volition is not a contradiction of the Law of Causality. The Law of Causality states everything in the universe acts according to its nature. That’s all it says, nothing more.

If everything in the universe did not act according to its nature, it would mean things could be something other than what they are when they act. But that would be a contradiction of the Law of Identity. Nothing can exist, whether in the course of action or otherwise, apart from, or against its own nature.

So if a billiard ball’s motion is ruled by mechanical causation that’s one instance of causality in the universe. Likewise, if an animal’s actions are determined by automatic knowledge and values that’s another instance of causality in the universe. Finally, if Man’s behavior is governed by the primary choice to focus or not that’s still another instance of causality in the universe.

So it hardly makes sense to say everything in the universe is governed by a single instance of causality, namely, deterministic causation. That would be like saying a car is nothing more than a specific model. Just as a concept unites all the units subsumed under it, a metaphysical law integrates all the instances covered by it.

Secondly, just as existence and consciousness are axiomatic concepts in metaphysics, sensory evidence and human volition are axiomatic concepts in epistemology.

An axiomatic concept, according to The Ayn Rand Lexicon, is the identification of a primary fact of reality, which cannot be analyzed, i.e., reduced to other facts or broken into component parts. It is implicit in all facts and in all knowledge. It is the fundamentally given and directly perceived or experienced, which requires no proof or explanation, but on which all proofs and explanations rest.

In other words, reason (without which there would be no such thing as rational argumentation) presupposes a mind which can:

  1. choose to focus on things in reality and make assertions about them, and

  2. reduce its assertions (if valid) to the evidence provided by its senses about things in reality.

So it hardly makes sense to deny human volition because if Man cannot choose to activate his own consciousness then he cannot focus on things in reality at all. Hence no assertion he makes, including the arbitrary one denying his own volition, refers to anything in reality!

Likewise it hardly makes sense to deny sensory evidence because if Man’s senses are invalid then he cannot reduce his own assertions to the evidence provided by his senses. Hence no assertion he makes, including the arbitrary one denying his own senses, can be tied to reality!

So my objection is not that some extra non-material stuff has been left out, but that you need to add more material.

It’s debatable what would happen to a mind if it was completely disconnected from sensory input. But considering the fact that we sleep and that does not seem to kill us, I think that we can take a bit of sensory deprivation. Who knows, the artificial mind might dream.

But in case we simulated a mind, we would want to interact with it somehow, or let it interact with some kind of environment. So this is no a problem for my argument.

Intuition is never good enough, agreed. But when you introspect and identify an emotion you are feeling that is perception. When you introspect and perceive your power of choice, that is perception. A perception is ‘evidence of the senses’ and so certainly is good enough basis for accepting that which is perceived.

Certainly, senses are right about what they tell us—but how does your senses tell you that a choice is part of a deterministic chain of events or that it is a ‘first cause’? I don’t think it is unfair to ask for some evidence for such a thing.

And I don’t see any reason there would be no way to explore free will by means of reason. Or is it holy, or perhaps outside the possible grasp of our reason? Or are some people born blind to the free will, just like some are colorblind?

There is a difference between introspection and intuition. Introspection does give us directly the nature of our mind, including the fact that we have free will. If you are calling introspection into question, then you cannot confirm free will

So do you mean that by introspection we can declare our free will to act as a ‘first cause’? I don’t see where I’m calling introspection in question—introspection just as perception must be correct in what it actually tells us. But the nature behind what it tells us is not mystically unveiled merely by observation. In no way do I see the inside of an orange just by looking at one, but I can always peel it…

I don’t see exactly how you see my previous post as stabs against free will. If you look at what you quoted and insert “God” instead of “real choices” and “free will” perhaps you will see why those are bad arguments.

So at what point are you affirming that we have free will?

How about the bolded part:

If we now were to simulate a human brain on a computer under these premises, we would find that free will is not capable of “real” choices, but is acting perfectly deterministically. It could of course be tested by letting the simulation run a specific scenario a couple of times, and resetting it each time (there would be ethical issues as this is a human brain after all).

So now either one of the premises is false, or we don’t in fact have ‘real’ choices (though we will still experience them as such).

Oh and by “real choices” I mean choices that are ‘first causes’. Free will is perfectly possible without that ‘first cause’ property. It does of course have some implications, but that would be the whole reason why this problem is interesting in the first place. That determinism and free will are compatible has been show countless time before.

Free will is validated introspectively. We don’t yet know the relationship between the human brain and the ability of free will; nonetheless we have that ability. Your position amounts to saying that we cannot affirm the power of vision until we know exactly how all those pieces that lead to perception are put together, instead of just being aware that we can see.

Not at all, what I’m saying is that we cannot know what causes free will just by introspection, just like we cannot know the underlying cause of the experience of redness before we inquire in the nature of the senses and whatever we experience as red.

We have free will and that is self-evident to introspection; one does not need to dissect the brain in order to find it. Similarly, one does not have to dissect a brain to find thoughts and emotions and awareness.

No we don’t, but to know the actual nature of those things we do have to understand the workings of the brain. While most people (if not all) have experienced happiness and many of those may know what caused them to be happy, I don’t think most of them understand what it is that makes such experiences possible. The same problem obviously applies to free will.

What you and others are basically saying is that you have this conception of causality that you call determinism, and that it covers everything, and therefore there can be no free will, no fundamental prime mover types of decisions. According to you, that is simply impossible, and one may well assert that if one agrees with free will then one might as well say one believes in God. In other words, you are claiming that free will is a version of mysticism. Well, it isn’t; it is an application of causality, that we are what we are and that we have free will because we are what we are. And if that doesn’t fit in with your metaphysics, then I strongly suggest that you check your premises.

The argument that I constructed in my first post in this tread does in no way require the assumption of determinism. It states simply that; either it is impossible to create a mind with a computer, or that the concept of ‘first cause’ must be abandoned in the case of free will (provided my other premises are correct).

So determinist is not where I started, but merely the conclusion of the argument. If my argument requires any further metaphysical assumptions than is held in the premises, I would appreciate if you showed them to me.

Oh and I don’t take my argument for granted, I still consider the premises to be on shaky ground and I had hoped to see if someone with more extensive knowledge might have some objections.

Firstly, human volition is not a contradiction of the Law of Causality. The Law of Causality states everything in the universe acts according to its nature. That’s all it says, nothing more.

If everything in the universe did not act according to its nature, it would mean things could be something other than what they are when they act. But that would be a contradiction of the Law of Identity. Nothing can exist, whether in the course of action or otherwise, apart from, or against its own nature.

Unfortunately that doesn’t say anything, the law of causality as you have put forward together with the law of identity still leaves the door open to all kinds of ‘mysticism’. Mystical things would just need to act in accordance to their (mysterious) nature.

So if a billiard ball’s motion is ruled by mechanical causation that’s one instance of causality in the universe. Likewise, if an animal’s actions are determined by automatic knowledge and values that’s another instance of causality in the universe. Finally, if Man’s behavior is governed by the primary choice to focus or not that’s still another instance of causality in the universe.

So it hardly makes sense to say everything in the universe is governed by a single instance of causality, namely, deterministic causation. That would be like saying a car is nothing more than a specific model. Just as a concept unites all the units subsumed under it, a metaphysical law integrates all the instances covered by it.

It’s interesting that you distinguish between different kinds of causation, what would be the proper way to categorize causations as different types?

Secondly, just as existence and consciousness are axiomatic concepts in metaphysics, sensory evidence and human volition are axiomatic concepts in epistemology.

An axiomatic concept, according to The Ayn Rand Lexicon, is the identification of a primary fact of reality, which cannot be analyzed, i.e., reduced to other facts or broken into component parts. It is implicit in all facts and in all knowledge. It is the fundamentally given and directly perceived or experienced, which requires no proof or explanation, but on which all proofs and explanations rest.

And what is God an axiomatic concept in theology?

Under what kind of authority should we consider existence, consciousness, sensory evidence and human volition outside the realm of inquiry?

Saying that those things cannot be analyzed makes no sense. Perhaps it is meant in a philosophical way, because science is obviously already trampling holy ground.

So it hardly makes sense to deny human volition because if Man cannot choose to activate his own consciousness then he cannot focus on things in reality at all. Hence no assertion he makes, including the arbitrary one denying his own volition, refers to anything in reality!

Likewise it hardly makes sense to deny sensory evidence because if Man’s senses are invalid then he cannot reduce his own assertions to the evidence provided by his senses. Hence no assertion he makes, including the arbitrary one denying his own senses, can be tied to reality!

I cannot grasp that it is not clear yet; I have not denied nor do I intend to deny that we have volition! Nor did I deny that we have free will. What my argument shows is that (in case the premises are not mistaken) is that free will is not the ‘first cause’ kind of free will.

I cannot grasp that it is not clear yet; I have not denied nor do I intend to deny that we have volition! Nor did I deny that we have free will. What my argument shows is that (in case the premises are not mistaken) is that free will is not the ‘first cause’ kind of free will.

Yet another long and somewhat rambling post that neither affirms nor denies free will in man.

Did you write all of that of your own free will? Did you sit down and decide to consider our arguments? Did you then decide to answer them point by point of your own free will?

You see, because the starting point is the first-hand observation that you decided to do that. Volition in man, his ability to think about something and then choose a course of action based on his rational consideration, is what we mean by free will. It’s an epistemological starting point – one based on direct observation. Analyzing brains and making computer models may well lead us to understand how it all works more clearly than we can know without having those tools, but, and this is important, all of that knowledge of bio-chemical reactions and synapses and atomic theory and etc. comes after the discovery of free will via introspection. Similarly, our knowledge of rods and cones and lens and the visual cortex and etc. all come after we know that we can see with our own eyes.

Having all of that other knowledge is good, in that if something goes wrong we can get glasses or contact lens or later even get an operation on the visual cortex so that we can see better; just as one day, and even some degree even today with psycho-tropic drugs, we will be able to say that so and so has lost some of his ability to have free will, he needs medication X so that the functionality is restored. I’m not denying that there is some connection between the brain and the mind, but whatever that connection is one cannot use that knowledge to deny free will in man, because free will is observed introspectively. In other words, glasses, which I wear, do not invalidate my sight; and yet you are trying to say, at least implicitly, that knowledge of the brain invalidates free will.

Free will is a prime mover in the sense that so long as all of that functionality is there, one is free to consider something or not and to act on that consideration or not. Free will is not a prime mover in the sense of being something that exists as a metaphysical primary, such as the existence of atoms or particles (which may not even be a metaphysical primary). In other words, we have no evidence whatsoever that there exists such a thing a free will roaming around out there not connected to a body; and we have no evidence whatsoever that consciousness is a type of stuff that exists out there, just waiting to be implanted into a body. Nonetheless, both consciousness and free will in man are the starting point of any rational investigation into the nature of man, because it is self evident to introspection that we have the freedom to think or not to think by our own effort and that we do that ourselves.

The difference between some religious person taking the existence of God as an axiom is that he has no evidence of His existence; in other words there is no evidence whatsoever that some omnipotent Being is running the universe. There is evidence of free will, which every man, provided his is operating correctly, can introspect and realize that he has that power to think or not to think of his own free will.

I wrote this of my own free will. I could have done something else, like watch TV and not get involved in yet another confused argument regarding the existence or non-existence of free will. The axioms are given via evidence, they are not made out of non-observation. And yet some of you seem to think that we are just making it all up, that there is no evidence of free will in man.

In other words, if you are not going to reply to this of your own free will, and after careful consideration, can you output somewhere else? Personally, I don’t want to waste time arguing with an automaton who has no self-control. So, exercise your free will and write a coherent reply, if you decide to do so. If your choice wasn’t involved in your output, then keep it to yourself.

Certainly, senses are right about what they tell us—but how does your senses tell you that a choice is part of a deterministic chain of events or that it is a ‘first cause’? I don’t think it is unfair to ask for some evidence for such a thing.

And I don’t see any reason there would be no way to explore free will by means of reason. Or is it holy, or perhaps outside the possible grasp of our reason? Or are some people born blind to the free will, just like some are colorblind?

And by ‘reason’ here I think you mean by science, an investigation which is inherently materialistic, because you ask for ‘evidence’ of ‘such a thing’.

The argument that I constructed in my first post in this tread does in no way require the assumption of determinism. It states simply that; either it is impossible to create a mind with a computer, or that the concept of ‘first cause’ must be abandoned in the case of free will (provided my other premises are correct).

I would say that it is possible to create a mind (but not just with a ‘computer’) and it would necessarily have some free will in it to be recognizable as a mind. After all, our biological means of human reproduction is similar to nanotechnology. If people can have free will, then so can other suitably constructed entities.

Under what kind of authority should we consider existence, consciousness, sensory evidence and human volition outside the realm of inquiry?

Saying that those things cannot be analyzed makes no sense. Perhaps it is meant in a philosophical way, because science is obviously already trampling holy ground.

I cannot grasp that it is not clear yet; I have not denied nor do I intend to deny that we have volition! Nor did I deny that we have free will. What my argument shows is that (in case the premises are not mistaken) is that free will is not the ‘first cause’ kind of free will.

You are looking for free will in the wrong place. Free will is not a physical or metaphysical idea. Category error.

That existence, consciousness and volition can not be analyzed is meant strictly in ‘a philosophical way’. That is the context in which the statements are made and the only context in which they can be understood. The specific way in which they are philosophical is their epistemological content. By ‘reason’ you mean by science, an investigation which is inherently materialistic and reductionist. Epistemology is not a ‘science’ that can be so reduced, but that doesn’t make it mystical.

Aristotle wrote “All men by nature desire to know.” This small statement is not just a meditation on human nature but also the nature of knowledge. The will to know is an epistemological first cause , not a metaphysical first cause. The will to know is not a metaphysical first cause because it does not make possible the existence of anything, existence is prior to and independent of consciousness. The will to know is an epistemological first cause because it makes possible any and all knowledge.

Equating the ‘will to know’ with ‘free will’ is what Objectivism does. The mental freedom to direct your attention, to solve a problem or to simply be still and alert, or to do none of these things by not even focusing mentally, is the only true freedom.

Added in edit: Objectivism duplicates this pattern in ethics. The will to live is an ethical first cause, because it makes possible any and all values.

Unfortunately that doesn’t say anything, the law of causality as you have put forward together with the law of identity still leaves the door open to all kinds of ‘mysticism’. Mystical things would just need to act in accordance to their (mysterious) nature.

The Law of Causality is formulated after observing what exists and how they act (or are acted upon) in reality. Whereas a belief in mysticism or mystical things is arbitrary because they are based on nothing in reality and have no relation to Man’s knowledge of it.

It’s interesting that you distinguish between different kinds of causation, what would be the proper way to categorize causations as different types?

By simple observation. One sees inanimate billiard balls being acted upon without acting to pursue anything. Then one sees animals acting automatically to pursue values based on automatic sensory knowledge. Finally, one sees men (including cavemen) choosing to discover the values required for their survival and taking the actions necessary to obtain them.

And what is God an axiomatic concept in theology?

Under what kind of authority should we consider existence, consciousness, sensory evidence and human volition outside the realm of inquiry?

Saying that those things cannot be analyzed makes no sense. Perhaps it is meant in a philosophical way, because science is obviously already trampling holy ground.

God is an invalid concept in epistemology because as I said earlier, a belief in mysticism or mystical things is arbitrary because they are based on nothing in reality and have no relation to Man’s knowledge of it.

And one needs no authority (except one’s independent perception of reality) to identify existence, consciousness, sensory evidence and human volition as self-evident primaries in philosophy.

Philosophy is the study of the fundamental nature of reality, of Man, and of Man’s relationship to reality (from Philosophy: Who Needs It by Ayn Rand.) So it is the only science in human knowledge which deals with the broadest abstractions possible.

This means none of the special sciences (be it the physical or the social) deal with the most fundamental truths because they study only specific aspects of reality or of Man.

So there’s absolutely nothing (emphasis added) they can discover about anything in reality which can invalidate the axioms of philosophy or the immutable fact that they are irreducible (since they are at the base of all knowledge, both philosophic and scientific.)

In fact, no scientific knowledge could even be possible if these axioms are not implicitly accepted by every scientist. As example, take the current bankrupt state of physics in which physicists routinely reject the primacy of existence by their arbitrary claim that subatomic particles come into existence only after they have been detected by Man! That is like saying if a tree fell in a forest uninhabited by any animal, no sound will be transmitted since there’s no one to hear the sound! This is what happens when a scientist’s bad philosophy eventually corrupts his science.

I cannot grasp that it is not clear yet; I have not denied nor do I intend to deny that we have volition! Nor did I deny that we have free will. What my argument shows is that (in case the premises are not mistaken) is that free will is not the ‘first cause’ kind of free will.

In order for Man to gain knowledge of reality (so that he can live in it) he has to be in focus first. If he’s not in focus, then he’s not conscious at all, at least not in the sense required for his survival. And focus is not automatic; it’s the first choice Man makes which enables him to be aware of things in reality. So the first cause in human volition is necessarily the primary choice to focus or not.

…

So now either one of the premises are false, or we don’t in fact have “real” choices (though we will still experience them as such).

How did you form the concept “choice”? Obviously by experiencing it as you admit. You could not have formed it by observing anything external to you. So there is no other way in which you could have formed it. Then you go ahead and deny it. That is concept stealing.