When speaking of measurments, 1" doesn’t exist. it might be 1.000…1,
Then I think you mean that we can’t measure with infinite precision on a truly continuous scale. If space is quantal (there is some smallest possible separation between entities) then space measurement is not continous. But 1 inch still exists.
When speaking of measurments, 1" doesn’t exist. it might be 1.000…1, the glass will never be exactly half.
One of the points that Rand makes in IOE is that measurements are contextual, so there is always an implicit error term involved in any measurment. Accordingly, even if space is not quantized and one could hypothetically measure arbitrarily small lengths, it makes no sense to say that the glass is “exactly” half full. The reason is that would imply that there is zero error in a measurement, something that can’t be done when measuring lengths of physical objects since one’s unit of measure has some length.
However, just because one cannot measure something “exactly” (i.e., acontextually, i.e., intrinsically) doesn’t mean that measurement is not possible (i.e., subjective).
Accordingly, even if space is not quantized and one could hypothetically measure arbitrarily small lengths, it makes no sense to say that the glass is “exactly” half full.
I’m not 100% sure what you mean here. It makes perfect sense to say in ordinary English that a glass is exactly half full, just like it makes sense to say that I arrived for dinner at exactly 9pm. And, it would be correct to say that I arrived at exactly 9pm even if I actually arrived 4 seconds earlier. The word “exact” isnt normally used to mean “idealised mathematical exactness as measured under perfect idealised laboratory conditions” - there is normally a surrounding context which defines what classes as ‘exactness’ in any particular situation. What counts as “exactness” when meeting a friend for dinner might not count as ‘exact’ when you are (eg) timing a 100m sprint in the Olympics, or the time taken for light to travel 1 meter.
The reason is that would imply that there is zero error in a measurement, something that can’t be done when measuring lengths of physical objects since one’s unit of measure has some length.
That’s true when your standard of measurement is a perceptible distance, like the distance between two marks. When the standard of measurement is in terms of a count, then error-free measurement could be possible. Length is now commonly measured in terms of a count (of oscillations), which can be fractional (hence subject to imprecision). But if the universe really is “grainy”, it could be possible to count the grains and derive an error-free length measurement.
It makes perfect sense to say in ordinary English that a glass is exactly half full, just like it makes sense to say that I arrived for dinner at exactly 9pm. And, it would be correct to say that I arrived at exactly 9pm even if I actually arrived 4 seconds earlier. The word “exact” isnt normally used to mean “idealised mathematical exactness as measured under perfect idealised laboratory conditions” - there is normally a surrounding context which defines what classes as ‘exactness’ in any particular situation. What counts as “exactness” when meeting a friend for dinner might not count as ‘exact’ when you are (eg) timing a 100m sprint in the Olympics, or the time taken for light to travel 1 meter.
We don’t disagree. “Exactness” depends upon a standard which is appropriate for one’s purposes. I was just objecting to saying that a measurement is “exact” without reference to any standard. In ordinary language, we (properly) use the term “exact” contextually, as you point out above. My usage of the term here is in the philosphical context used by Rand in “Exact Measurement and Continuity”, c.f. IOE, 2nd. ed., pretty much the “ideal mathematical” definition you give above. orangeiscool’s usage suggested he meant this version of exactness rather than the ordinary language version. Of course, if he didn’t mean that, he can always correct me.
That’s true when your standard of measurement is a perceptible distance, like the distance between two marks. When the standard of measurement is in terms of a count, then error-free measurement could be possible. Length is now commonly measured in terms of a count (of oscillations), which can be fractional (hence subject to imprecision). But if the universe really is “grainy”, it could be possible to count the grains and derive an error-free length measurement.
Right-- I only meant this to apply in a discussion of measuring length (or the height of a liquid in a glass) in a continuous universe.
However, just because one cannot measure something “exactly” (i.e., acontextually, i.e., intrinsically) doesn’t mean that measurement is not possible (i.e., subjective).
EXACT measurments doen’t exist since atoms are always in motion. Talk to me about the smallest possible grains of matter at absolute zero and I will concede.
Of course, unit length my foot, will always =my foot, not that the measument wouldn’t change in quantum size. (did I use quantum correctly?)
Are you sure about that? Because something tells me that if you do the following:
.5 + .25 + .125 + …
or
E [1/(n^2)] , where 1 <= n
you’ll never really reach 1. You can get arbitrarily close, but never equal.
There is a mathmatical answer to Zeno that doesn’t simply parrot out E [1/(n^2)], where 1 <= n. I’m currently looking it up to make sure I don’t mispeak about it.
His whole set up was flawed because the ancient Greeks did not have sufficient understanding of the mathematics.
You all over look the fact that Zeno made the paradox because he wanted the Greeks to re-evaluate there definitions. Zeno knew that his statements were not true, but that was the point. Zeno knew that there was an answer to every paradox he presented, but on the surface each one is right. Thats what makes them a paradox. Zeno wasn’t preaching that motion is impossible, he just wanted to show that by the words we use we can manipulate logic and reality. Thus, no answer to the paradox is necessary, they’re rhetorical.
Luckily philosophers and mathematicians disagreed with your friend when they were (eg) discussing how to formulate the calculus and theory of limits.
Ditto.
Something funny that always comes to mind whenever people bring up Zeno’s paradox is the way Peikoff describes him. I’ve been listening to some of his lecture courses recently and whenever he mentions Zeno, he always say, “You know, that guy who couldn’t walk across the room.”
Luckily philosophers and mathematicians disagreed with your friend when they were (eg) discussing how to formulate the calculus and theory of limits.
I apologize for being murky, but what I was calling pointless was such a long discussion, we could all answer this in one post: state “before moving an inch you move .5inch etc. etc.,” then state about grainy universe; but we CAN move!, so there is something here (teleportation on quantum scale?). This either goes to a different subject such as what could this teleportation be, or a refuting of grainy universe.
She started, but realised that before she could fully answer the question, she had to half-answer it, but before she could half-answer it she would have to quarter-answer it. At that point she realized “This is a total waste of my time”, and so she wrote Atlas Shrugged instead.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!
The standard interpretation of Greek pre-Socratic philosophy is that Zeno was trying to show that motion was an illusion, and hence that change didnt occur. One of the main ‘problems’ for the Greeks was how change was possible. Parmenides held that the reality ‘underneath’ our sensations was eternal and hence couldnt actually change - Zeno’s arguments were intended to illustrate this point. Compare it (for instance) to Democritus’ argument that one thing could change into another because the world was actually made up of indivisible eternal atoms, and change was only a change in the configuration of these atoms rather than anything new coming into being.
Pretty much. He was, in the tradition of Parmenides, trying to show that the very idea of change was nonsense and that everything is one.
Pat Corvini of the Ayn Rand Institute recently released a lecture series that resolves Zeno’s paradoxes (especially the Achilles/tortoise one) and uses Ayn Rand’s theory of concepts as a general principle to deal with all paradoxes.
I just skimmed this thread, so pardon me if someone has already made this point.
As we all know, to ‘be’ is to be something. The law of identity. No matter now minutely you break up your measurements of reality, for something to exist it has to be as large as at least one of the increments you’re using.
Say that the distance between Point A and Point B is 10 "yadayada"s (the smallest unit of measurment in use), the object traveling between A and B has to be at least 1 yadayada in size. Once the object gets fully past yadayada number 9, no matter how Zeno wishes to record that motion, it necessarily is touching Point B - the 10 yadayada mark. It has arrived.
You’re not thinking infinitely. If something runs off into infinity, just because we haven’t defined a number for X yet doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. Existence is independent of consciousness; if I don’t think of a measurement of something, that doesn’t mean it’s immeasurable. The “foot” didn’t exist in 200BC. Does that mean nothing was a foot long? NO. So why, then, must something ONLY be a “yadayada” short? Because we haven’t defined anything further? If we accept that the shortest measurement possible is “yadayada” then we cannot define anything shorter. If we can (we can), then your statement is moot anyway. My new measurement is equal to 1/4*yadayada. I’ll call it the metricyada.
Quite the contrary, every time I enter in to a discussion on this board, I expect to have to think infinitely.
By “yadayada” I was thinking about things like atoms. I didn’t use that term because I’m not sure exactly how people measure things at that level, or if atoms really are the smallest units known. I realize that subatomic particles do exist and can be measured, but they cannot exist independently of the arrangement know as the atom. I hoped to bypass such objections by using a variable.
Also, you cannot quantify infinity because it does not have a quantity. It is a purely conceptual phenomenon representing NO THING in reality. If you decided to call some point that infinity passed though X, and determined it’s value, infinity would still have to keep going in order to be infinity. Infinity is by defnition indeterminite and non-existent. Does that mean that there is an infinite number of things in existence. I don’t know. It’s an interesting topic for another thread.
The only other thing I can say to your comment is yes, just because some smaller unit of measurment hasn’t been thought of doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist and can’t be used. However, conversely just because it can be thought of doesn’t mean that it actually does exist. The units of measurement at the atomic level - what I ignorantly call yadayadas - were identified and used for good reason. They weren’t just arbitrarily ordained as “the smallest units of measurment possible”. Scientists, and the Japanese, have direct experience with what happens when they attempt to create something that is smaller.
So, as I said, in order to be something, it has to be as big as, and be composed of, at least one yadayadya. If you attempt to cut it in half, or in to quarters, all you get is a violent rearrangment of yadayadas - not metriyadas.
So then your answer is that zeno is wrong because the smallest unit of measurement is the length of an atom. Which isn’t true, because I can concieve of 1/2 of the length of an atom. Are you trying to tell me that 1 atom-length exists, but 1/2 an atom length doesn’t exist? That’s a fallacy. 1/4 an atom length also exists, as does 1/8, 1/16, 1/32, 1/64, 1/128, 1/256, 1/512, 1/1024, etc. Whether or not we are able to measure it is completely irrelevent to its existing. 1=.5+.5=(.25+.25)+(.25+.25)=((.125+.125)+(.125+.125))+((.125+.125)+(.125+.125)), etc… If we can see its whole, how can you claim that any part of it doesn’t exist? Because it’s really small?
You can’t quantify infinity going away from 0. You CAN quanify it approaching 0 or well… 1, which is what Zeno is doing. It’s called a limit! If we were to put it in a geometric sequence, it would be E n^2(1/(n^2)). Zeno’s paradox isn’t a contradiction, it’s just not mentioning all the relevant information. If I’m an arrow, the distance between me and my target can be divided up infinitely. Except, I’m traveling at 200m/s. No matter how you divide up 200m/s, you’re still traveling that far. 200m/s=100m/s+100m/s=50m/s+50m/s+50m/s+50m/s, etc. It’s got the sum, and you can add up to that sum an infinite number of ways.
So then your answer is that zeno is wrong because the smallest unit of measurement is the length of an atom. Which isn’t true, because I can concieve of 1/2 of the length of an atom.
Sure, you can conceive of it all you want. That doesn’t mean that it exists. There is no such thing as 1/2 of an atom. An atom is the smallest unit of existence. Nothing can be broken down any smaller. Like I said, when it is tried, all that results is a violent reorganization of atoms. To talk about something being “1/2 an atom’s length” away from Point B is absurd. What’s in between? Something is in between, and to be something, means to possess at least one atom. When that something and the original object switch spots, the object has literally reached Point B.
And as for this:
Zeno’s paradox isn’t a contradiction, it’s just not mentioning all the relevant information.
There is such thing as half an atom. Are you telling me that you can have a whole atom without its left side?
That’s irrelevent. I answered the paradox correctly, so any objections you have to it are irrelevent.
EDIT: If the atom is the smallest existing particle (which it isn’t, but that doesn’t matter), then nothing smaller than it exists. There is still space 1/2 its length and 1/2 of the atom still exists.