Zeno's Paradox

There is such thing as half an atom. Are you telling me that you can have a whole atom without its left side?

That’s irrelevent. I answered the paradox correctly, so any objections you have to it are irrelevent.

EDIT: If the atom is the smallest existing particle (which it isn’t, but that doesn’t matter), then nothing smaller than it exists. There is still space 1/2 its length and 1/2 of the atom still exists.

Right, but not in any meaningful sense. That’s like saying an 8 man baseball team is a baseball team, or a 1 man baseball team is a baseball team. A baseball team is, by definition, 9 (or more) men - one for each of the 9 defensive positions. An atom cannot exist with out BOTH it’s left side and right side intact. Yes, you can measure 1/2 of the distance of an atom, but you will never find 1/2 of an atom floating around in reality. There is not “space [equal to] 1/2 of the lenght of an atom” in which nothing exists. That space is occupied by something, which is composed of it’s own atoms which play by the same rules.

Space, in it’s common usage, does not exist. It is merely a means of describing the lack of some specific element or object, while implicitly relying on the premise that that “space” is composed of something else. Even if space literally did exist, it would be something. If I moved an object from one place to another empty space, it’s original location would immediately be filled with space. Furthermore, even if I were wrong about this and space actually was some sort of gap in reality, what makes it forever beyond my ability to traverse? Certainly you’re not going to propose that there is something that exists that is 1/2 the length of nothing.

I’m sorry, but I disagree with that. I find billions of “half an atom” in existence.

The problem with Zeno’s Achilles and the tortoise paradox is the conflation of the abstract with the concrete. In the abstract sense, Achilles must run an infinite number of half distances, but he can; “infinite” just means “some number but any number.” In the concrete sense, you would have to choose an actual (as opposed to infinite) number of finite lenghts to run; and Achilles can run any number of finite lengths more quickly than the tortoise can.

Edited to correct a typo.

According to the quantum physics I have heard most recently, they actually say that there is a smallest unit of distance and, while it is sensible to speak of half of it, subatomic particles never travel through it. They simply are at one point and the next moment in time are one quanti removed. [Edit: So this actually means that Zeno was more or less right.]

Has Ayn Rand given a solution to Zeno’s Paradox? and if she has not, how might she gone about solving it? Thank to all in advance.

Occum’s Razor takes care of this. “You shouldn’t multiply entities needlessly”.

Yes, but given the time he made this remark, it’s been quite brilliant. He practically proved that if space and time could be broken down infinitely, we wouldn’t live in the universe we apparently do. I think it’s brilliant.

When Henry Ford developed the Model T, for it’s time, it was an exceptional achievement. However, I don’t see the point in pursuing the process of rebuilding an obsolete model of car in order to pay hommage to a past innovator. I don’t see much difference between the analogy and it’s subject, though I am sure you will differ.

I’m sorry, but I disagree with that. I find billions of “half an atom” in existence.

What does that mean? I understand how you can juxtapose the concept “half” and “atom”, but are you saying that there is a fact out there of a “half an atom”? What are its properties? How come I haven’t heard about one before? Or are you redefining “half” in a special way?

What does that mean? I understand how you can juxtapose the concept “half” and “atom”, but are you saying that there is a fact out there of a “half an atom”? What are its properties? How come I haven’t heard about one before? Or are you redefining “half” in a special way?

I assume we are using “atom” to mean the smallest unit of existence, or some such thing. As such, picture and atom, now picture and atom in front of the original, partially obscuring it from your view. It could be said that you see one half of the original atom, as long as an atom isn’t a point…which wouldn’t really make sense being 0-dimensional and all.

Assuming that we can detect an atom, we should be able to, one day at least, measure it’s size by comparison or displacement or something really really sexy and scientific. Even if nothing smaller than an atom exists, you could then refer to a length that is equal to one half of that of an atom.

In fact, such a designation would also be metaphysically relevent or at least, or at least make a hell of a lot of sense. Since the atom must take up space (correct me if we are talking 0-dimensional point atoms) there must be a specific distance from it’s left side to it’s right. We can designate this distance to be 1 SUAT (Smallest Unit of ALL-TIME), but SUATs in integer amounts won’t be capable of mathmatically describing everything. Take two spherical atoms and place them side by side, now place an atom on top of each of the original two in a gridlike pattern(

00

00). How far is it from the top right to bottom left corners of the atom stack?

I assume we are using “atom” to mean the smallest unit of existence, or some such thing. As such, picture and atom, now picture and atom in front of the original, partially obscuring it from your view. It could be said that you see one half of the original atom, as long as an atom isn’t a point…which wouldn’t really make sense being 0-dimensional and all.

I think this way of speaking only really makes sense if you have a picture in your head of fundamental particles being something like extremely small little balls, rather than (eg) localised wave packets or fluctuations in a field (which is how they are actually treated in current theory). I dont think theres any good reason to assume in advance that the fundamental constituents of the universe ‘must’ have a size, and if you think that anything else would necessarily be incoherent then its possible that youre still thinking of them as being like tiny solid balls.

I believe that within our most current models of particle physics, the most fundamental constituents of the universe do not have size. There are other models though (for example, the strings of string-theory are not pointlike). Having said that, I’m not 100% clear about the precise meaning of ‘point-like’ in the context of theoretical physics and I wouldnt be surprised if it meant something slightly more subtle than ‘being a geometric point’. As far as I know (and I freely admit to not knowing much about physics, so take this post with a large grain of salt), the actual story is that although fundamental particles are pointlike, their associated wavefunctions are smeared across space.

Also even if fundamental particles did have a size, its not obvious that we would ever be able to measure this accurately, due to the uncertainty principle.

According to the quantum physics I have heard most recently, they actually say that there is a smallest unit of distance and, while it is sensible to speak of half of it, subatomic particles never travel through it. They simply are at one point and the next moment in time are one quanti removed. [Edit: So this actually means that Zeno was more or less right.]

I believe the Planck length is something more subtle than that, and doesnt imply that space is actually discrete. One theory of quantum gravity, Loop Quantum Gravity, does predict that space is discrete on the planck scale, but this is not widely accepted among physicists.

But even if this trned out to be true, I dont think it would mean Zeno was right. “Being right” should imply more than just making a lucky guess. There was no good reason for anyone 2500 years to believe that space was either discrete or continuous, given that cutting edge physics today is still undecided on the question (and anyway, he wasnt arguing that space was discrete, he was arguing that movement was illusory). If you need to refer to highly technical details of science in order to settle a philosophical argument, I think this is a good sign that something has went wrong somewhere along the line.

I assume we are using “atom” to mean the smallest unit of existence, or some such thing.

Okay, but that only makes the distinction, whatever it is, even more obscure. Since, after all, we know that actual atoms do have stuff in them.

As such, picture and atom, now picture and atom in front of the original, partially obscuring it from your view.

In reality, I’m skeptical about doing this but let’s procede. So this is the “fruit of (imaginary) method” sense of existence, namely juxtaposing these two concepts. The distractor was BN’s claim ‘I find billions of “half an atom” in existence’. You don’t really find them, you have to create them (they do not physically exist at all), and it’s pretty much guaranteed that nobody has actually so created billions of “half-atoms” just as nobody have created billions of integers by actually mentally forming specific integers. Also, with numbers we can say with justified confidence that “124,383,765” is the same number as “124,383,765” so if you think of “124,383,765” today and “124,383,765” tomorrow, you would say that you thought of the same number twice, and not that you thought of two numbers which happened to be the same. That is, enumerating the integers between one and a billion is thinking of a billion numbers, but thinking “one, one, one…” a billion times isn’t thinking of a billion numbers. With imaginary atom juxtapositions, I just wonder how you would invent a billion such pictures, rather than invent a mental picture once and then replay it in your mind a billion times.

I think this all borders if not mirrors the discussion of either an infinite regress of substances or an essentially formless primary substance, addressed by Aristotle. Perhaps should it be moved to another topic, as it seems related to but distinct from the question of Zeno’s Paradox?

I think the essential error in Zeno’s Paradox is mixing up the abstract and the concrete and therby treating an infinite as an actuality.

For instance, in an abstract race, Achilles can run any length divided into any number of finite smaller parts, but in an actual race, he must run some finite length divided into some finite smaller parts.

It’s an attack on the concept of infinitely small things. And it’s a good one.

I think that if time is fluid and capable of passing in finite quantity, and space is fluid and capable of being passed through over finite time, then it follows that a runner can cross the finish line without a need for dividing by two ad infinitum. Personally, I don’t think Zeno’s paradox is a big problem for Rand, because it doesn’t say as much about how the real world works as it says about how the real world doesn’t work.

I agree with the assessment that Zeno’s paradox is a brilliant proof of discrete time and space. This is not what Zeno intended with the paradox, but its construction is still brilliant when interpreted correctly. The paradox can be presented as a set of premises and a conclusion:

Premise: time and space is continuous

Therefore (due to the Achilles/tortoise example): motion is impossible

HOWEVER, we know from observation that motion indeed is possible. HENCE, the premise is false. Time and space must be discrete. There must exist an indivisible smallest spacetime unit.

Where Zeno got it wrong is by taking a rationalistic turn when the conclusion conflicted with reality. Instead of concluding that the premise was wrong (which he should have) he concluded that sensed reality was wrong instead.

But when interpreted rationally Zeno’s paradox is not only consistent with objectivism, but *exactly* what you would expect. Objectivism holds at its core that the basic stuff of existence is *objects*. But what is an object if not a *discrete* existent?

Objectivism holds at its core that the basic stuff of existence is *objects*. But what is an object if not a *discrete* existent?

I assume you mean “entity” rather than “object”. I don’t know what it would mean for an entity to not be discrete. For example, a cup of water doesn’t look like it’s made up of bits, but it is, and a cup of water is different from the rest of the universe. Even if an electron isn’t divisible, it’s still distinct from the rest of the universe. As far as I can tell, the idea of a “non-discrete existent” is a contradiction, so I don’t see how to grant the “what it” assumption. Are you suggesting that time and space are entities?

I agree with the assessment that Zeno’s paradox is a brilliant proof of discrete time and space. This is not what Zeno intended with the paradox, but its construction is still brilliant when interpreted correctly. The paradox can be presented as a set of premises and a conclusion:

Premise: time and space is continuous

Therefore (due to the Achilles/tortoise example): motion is impossible

HOWEVER, we know from observation that motion indeed is possible. HENCE, the premise is false. Time and space must be discrete. There must exist an indivisible smallest spacetime unit.

I completely disagree. Zeno’s paradox shows an error inherent in Platonism: the mixing up of the abstract with the concrete. No matter how many times you divide the race-track up, in a concrete sense, you willl have some finite number of finite individual lenghts, each of which Achilles can traverse more quickly than the tortoise can. On the other hand, in an abstract race, Zeno must run an infinite number of lenghths, but he CAN, because using the concept of infinite correctly, there can be ANY number of finite lengths, but there must be SOME number of finite lenghts.

By the way, a good lecture on Zeno’s paradox is this one:

http://www.aynrandbookstore.com/prodinfo.asp?number=CC22D

I assume you mean “entity” rather than “object”. I don’t know what it would mean for an entity to not be discrete. For example, a cup of water doesn’t look like it’s made up of bits, but it is, and a cup of water is different from the rest of the universe. Even if an electron isn’t divisible, it’s still distinct from the rest of the universe. As far as I can tell, the idea of a “non-discrete existent” is a contradiction, so I don’t see how to grant the “what it” assumption. Are you suggesting that time and space are entities?

“Discrete object” is a statement of the same kind as “existence exists.” It is not a redundency but an elaboration of the underlying axiomatic nature of the concept. Just like you cannot deny existence without undermining your denial you cannot speak of non-discrete existents. The very fact that existents have identity implies that they are objects and hence discrete. Although not made explicit in her axioms of metaphysics the very name of Ayn Rand’s philosophy – objectivism – is derived from the concept of the “object.” In fact, if her metaphysics should ever be elaborated/expanded it would in my opinion be to include the axiom that existents are objects and objects are discrete.

And to answer your question: yes, time and space are built from objects. Time and space *exists*, hence it must be *something* that exists. This something must have an identity and hence be an object and hence be discrete. This follows from the axiomatic nature of existence.

I completely disagree. Zeno’s paradox shows an error inherent in Platonism: the mixing up of the abstract with the concrete. No matter how many times you divide the race-track up, in a concrete sense, you willl have some finite number of finite individual lenghts, each of which Achilles can traverse more quickly than the tortoise can. On the other hand, in an abstract race, Zeno must run an infinite number of lenghths, but he CAN, because using the concept of infinite correctly, there can be ANY number of finite lengths, but there must be SOME number of finite lenghts.

By the way, a good lecture on Zeno’s paradox is this one:

http://www.aynrandbookstore.com/prodinfo.asp?number=CC22D

Well, I agree that Zeno’s original *conclusion* is both rationalistic and platonic. It is platonic in the sense of confusing the abstraction of infinity with the concrete existents which are not infinite, and it is rationalistic in the sense of choosing a logical conclusion over what is observed by the senses (“motion is impossible”), which is a primacy of mind-error. But that is my point exactly: if you DON’T make the platonic and rationalistic errors you end up with a radically different conclusion from Zeno which completely eliminates the paradox. And the conclusion is that even though you in your _mind_ can hypothesize the infinite subdivision of time and space this leads to the obvious contradiction of the senses. Due to the primacy of existence your mental play with infinites must be thrown out. What remains then is the notion of a finite, discrete spacetime.

Let me also add that Zeno’s experiment can be applied to consciousness and here we can empirically observe the effect of discreteness. Yes, the stream of consciousness too has a discrete existence, and it is easy to prove. It is in fact an everyday phenomenon. Consider the following experiment: a subject is shown a short flash of an image, say for a tenth of a second. (then it shown the negative image for a similar amount of time in order to eliminate retinal after-images) The image is, say, two parallel lines, one longer than the other. The subject is then asked to identify which of the two lines are shortest. Each time the subject succeeds the flash is shortened slightly. At some point the subject is unable to tell the difference between the two lines. In fact, at some point the flash is too short for awareness to register it altogether. This phenomenon corresponds to the Nyquist sampling theorem, which states that a discrete sampling of an analog signal at a sampling rate of frequency f will successfully sample all information in the signal with frequencies lower than f/2. In short, there is a threshold where the sampler no longer detects any signal. This is what happens in the mind too. If a sound is too short, we can hear it, if a detail is too small we can’t see it etc. In short: CONSCIOUSNESS IS DISCRETE. This is an observable fact, but by Zeno’s reasoning we could know it even before we have evidence for it because that is the way that it *must* be.

The very fact that existents have identity implies that they are objects and hence discrete.

You didn’t say anything about the question of what you mean by “object”, so I’ll be more direct: do you mean “entity” or “existent”? Attributes and relations are not objects, but they are existents.

And to answer your question: yes, time and space are built from objects. Time and space *exists*, hence it must be *something* that exists. This something must have an identity and hence be an object and hence be discrete. This follows from the axiomatic nature of existence.

The one thing that time and space aren’t is entities: they are either attributes or relations (or entities), depending on how you are expressing them. They exist, they presuppose some entities (that is, they are aspects of the identity of the entity), but they aren’t entities. Hence, I would conclude, they are not objects. What I’m objecting to is treating “existent” and “entity” as interchangeable.

According to the quantum physics I have heard most recently, they actually say that there is a smallest unit of distance and, while it is sensible to speak of half of it, subatomic particles never travel through it. They simply are at one point and the next moment in time are one quanti removed. [Edit: So this actually means that Zeno was more or less right.]

If he was right, it seems coincidental. I don’t see any way to infer discrete units of time and space from Zeno’s paradox.

By all means, if you have some kind of substantive logical or mathematical argument for the leap from one to the other, I would be happy to argue about it or even accept that you are right if it is very good. I do see that there is some kind of argument that you are trying to make about the nature of infinitely small units, but until there is more elaboration about that, all I can do is look stupid. :slight_smile:

“Zeno’s Dichotomy paradox: Before a moving object can travel a certain distance, it must travel half that distance. Before it can travel half the distance it must travel 1/4 the distance, etc. This sequence goes on forever. Therefore, it seems that the original distance cannot be traveled, and motion is impossible.”

This is the paradox of Achilles and a tortoise. It’s already been answered by mathematics.

1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + … = Sum[i = 0 to infinity] (1/2^i) - 1 = 1/(1 - 1/2) - 1 = 1/(1/2) - 1 = 2 - 1 = 1

Ayn Rand said she was never a great mathematician.