I was debating with myself, as you do, over breakfast, the problem of immigration. Now, let’s leave the economics side alone - I was more concerned with the social side. Now, it’s not because it’s more pertinent to the issue, but because it comes up so much. The old “Poles coming to Britain and stealing all our jobs” argument doesn’t come up much, especially since the public has come to realise that, actually, the jobs that Eastern European immigrant get hired in, are ones the indigenous population don’t want (and they do a much better job too).
What comes up far, far more, especially with the social stigma attached to Muslim immigrants, is the idea of ‘integration’. That is, it’s not enough for people to come here, to live and to work, but they should also have to integrate with their new home’s customs and way of life.
But that got me thinking, in a country like Britain, do we really want that?
If immigrants integrated with the ‘British way of life’:
-
They would demand more benefits from the government
-
Their children would roam around city streets in gangs
-
They would go on strike often claiming they have a democratic right to run their employer’s company
Well, I can’t think of many right now (I’m always bad at this analogy stuff), but my point is, that the ‘British way of life’ is ill-defined, and from what I have got in my 18 years of living here, simply means being melancholical and complaining about things.
I think, yes, immigrants should integrate to a certain degree, but only on the principled stuff. Immigrants shouldn’t have to take ‘citizenship tests’ (ones that most of the public would fail, if tested), but if their new home thrives on free-trade and a government that protects rights, then those are principles of that country, and the immigrants should integrate with them, or choose a different country (he can’t have the priveleges of wealth from a rich, Western country, but demand that all that nasty capitalist stuff be taken out).
But then I think, well hold on, does Britain, if you were going to take a measure of its philosophical attitude, does it really hold good, moral principles that I could ask someone to integrate with? We have a crippled (in the economic sense) and crippling (in the literal, medical sense) National Health Service, to which the solution is more money, not less regulation; we have a police force that spends more time doing paper work and checking it is being ‘fair’ in the demographic nature of its policing (as well as spending most of its time catching drug dealers); we have an over-crowded prison system, to which the only solution seems to be given as, “Well, let’s just let the least offending go free”; we have an education system which, whilst not as bad in terms of structure as the US, is definitely worse in terms of philsophy.
We have a myriad of other problems, but I just want to get to my question: looking at Britain, what is, what it’s ‘founded’ on, what it preaches and practices - how can one really defend a country such as this? Would it:
a) ever be moral to go to war for such a country?
B) ever moral to ask someone to integrate with its principles, when it seems to lack any to begin with?
To explain B) further, I mean that, I hold Objectivist principles at government and morality, and I would ask an immigrant to integrate with those principles, because those are the ones, whether the country wants to recognise it or not, which keep the economy healthy and the people in warm houses, with computers and good food.