On the off-chance that you do find an agreement with such a standard in it, the agreement will almost always control. There is a doctrine that might help employee under certain circumstances: waiver. Employee must show that employer’s past failure to enforce the requirement constituted a waiver of employer’s right under the provision. It’s usually hard to do, but in an ongoing employment relationship it can be a bit easier.
That’s kinda what I had in mind: in writing, employer A prohibits contractual employees from doing X, but in fact the prohibition is never enforced. At some point employee B does X and for some reason (personal hatred for example) manager M fires B for doing X.
If Wal-Mart does not exercise the contractual right, it may lose it in the future.
That’s the related other side of the coin that I had in mind – it is not totally harmless to say “We’ll make an exception”. That exception can be the thin end of the wedge.
I think her attorney did her a disservice by not figuring the cost of repayment to Wal-Mart in the amount that she sued for. Any reasonable attorney who is familiar with insurance laws and practices would have requested to inspect all relevant documents pertaining to her insurance through Wal-Mart in order to ascertain whether it would be likely that the company would seek reimbursement.
Being a law student, I have what is probably an abnormally high opinion of lawyers - an opinion I believe to be quite accurate. I doubt that the lawyer failed to take account. Remember that the subsequent lawsuit against the other driver was settled. Clients will often take settlements their lawyers advise may be too low. The client may need money quickly and not be willing to wait through the lengthy process of trial and appeal. Or might not want to endure the emotional toll of trial. Or any number of other reasons. Clients are often more willing to settle than their attorneys advise. And the decision is ultimately the client’s to make.
I find it much more likely that Shank accepted a settlement that didn’t cover her subrogation liability to Wal-Mart. Come to think of it, she may not have even had a lawyer for that settlement. I’ll have to look it up again.
~Q
EDIT: Sorry, she did have an attorney for the earlier action. “Ms. Shank sued the parties responsible for causing her injuries and settled her claims for $700,000 on August 8, 2002. After payment of attorney fees and costs, Ms. Shank received $417,477.00, which was placed in a special needs trust (“Trust”) created for the benefit of Ms. Shank, with Ms. Shank’s husband, James A. Shank to serve as Trustee.” Admin. Comm. of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Shank, 2006 WL 2546797 (E.D. Mo. 2006). Looks like she had a standard 1/3 contingency agreement. I still strongly suspect that she (or rather, her husband) accepted the settlement against the advice of counsel. Or at least after counsel had told her (him) about the liability to Wal-Mart.
Obviously Walmart has the right to sue for the money. I don’t question that. I’m wondering what they gained from it. After the legal fees, I bet they only ended up getting back a very tiny amount of money. And bad press along with it.
Indeed. Given what companies like Walmart pay in advertising to generate good will among the public, you’d think they’d just skip this one and chalk up the money lost as “advertising”, or rather as “avoiding negative advertising”.
Indeed. Given what companies like Walmart pay in advertising to generate good will among the public, you’d think they’d just skip this one and chalk up the money lost as “advertising”, or rather as “avoiding negative advertising”.
Think about that though. This is the first you’ve heard about it even though this has been standard practice for one time. Now imagine yourself the lawyer looking at the next of htese cases. If 99 of 100 of them prosecute successfully, how are you going to decide which one to forgoe. Remember, all this publicity didnt’ come about until after the case was completed.
The minute you start trying to skip cases on the premise that you can predict which ones are and aren’t going to give you publicity trouble, the minute you put at risk all the other cases because you’re now starting to show inconsistent use of the contractual clause. Better to think of this as a cost of doing business to be able to assure successful winning of funds in the other 99% of cases.
The article is an example of using the heart wrenching tragedy of the story to make an argument, that Wal-Mart is “heartless.” Without reporting this particular fact I mentioned it makes me suspicious that it is just one of the many hatchet jobs on Wal-Mart.
Indeed. Argumentum ad misericordiam. I am never moved by the argument to pity. The hachet job(s) on Walmart are from union thugs (socialists barely in disguise) and other corporations like their competitor, K-Mart. And the neverending class warfare between those who are hard-working, industrious benefactors of society and the slugs who want a handout from the State, viz, you and me.
I applaud Sam and his family for the success that they are. I shop there as often as I can.