A recent Walmart lawsuit

Link to news story.

Obviously Walmart has the right to sue for the money. I don’t question that. I’m wondering what they gained from it. After the legal fees, I bet they only ended up getting back a very tiny amount of money. And bad press along with it.

Link to news story.

Obviously Walmart has the right to sue for the money. I don’t question that. I’m wondering what they gained from it. After the legal fees, I bet they only ended up getting back a very tiny amount of money. And bad press along with it.

This is why we need to not only boycott Wal-Mart but anyone who does business with it.

This is why we need to not only boycott Wal-Mart but anyone who does business with it.

I assume you’re joking.

While I have no idea about the merits of this particular court-case, many health-care plans have clauses like the one mentioned in the story. Suppose I am in an bad accident and the auto-insurance of the car that hit me pays me $400,000 for health expenses and $600,000 for other pain and suffering. My own health insurance company can ask me to use that $400,000 for health expenses related to the accident before they start to pay. If they have already paid out toward the accident, then they are to be repaid from the $400,000.

The other aspect is that you need to differentiate between direct medical expenses and long term disability. They are two different classes of expense and many times insurance plans differentiate between the two and separate insurance is required for each. I dont’ know about Wal-Mart’s plan and if they even offer LTD. My company has two separate pools for this. You select each (Medical and LTD) separately.

The article is an example of using the heart wrenching tragedy of the story to make an argument, that Wal-Mart is “heartless.” Without reporting this particular fact I mentioned it makes me suspicious that it is just one of the many hatchet jobs on Wal-Mart.

This article sucks. The premise is that WalMart has an obligation to pay. Notice that in the middle of the article it randomly states “In 2007, the retail giant reported net sales in the third quarter of $90 billion.” The situation is tragic, but the fact is she signed the papers for the health agreement and ultimately all responsibility lies on her. To even think that WalMart must pay for her misfortune is an absurdity. Likewise to think that WalMart included that line in her health agreement without an intention to act upon it is even more absurd.

Sounds like this woman had a bad attorney to me. When I broke my leg on my friend’s property last year, my insurance company immediately sent me a letter, and continued to send several more over the course of a year, informing me that if there was any settlement on my behalf, I owed them first. If this woman’s attorney had been doing his job, he should have taken all that into consideration when deciding the amount of the suit. This is not the fault of “evil” Walmart.

Note that the Wal-Mart plan at issue here is not a health insurance plan, but an ERISA health benefits plan.

Some facts from the original district court magistrate’s ruling on Wal-Mart’s motion for summary judgment:

Defendant (Shank) signed the Plan’s 1997 Wrap Document, which expressly included summary plan descriptions as may from time to time be amended. The 2000 summary plan description for the particular welfare plan that paid out included the reimbursement and subrogation clause. Defendant argued first that the reimbursement and subrogation clause was not part of the plan. It relied on two cases, also interpreting Wal-Mart’s Wrap Document, that held that summary plan descriptions were not part of the plan. But those cases interpreted the 2001 Wrap Document, which expressly stated that summary plan documents were not part of the plan. The 1997 Wrap Document, which controls this case, expressly states that they are part of the plan. Therefore, the reimbursement and subrogation clause is part of the plan.

ERISA allows plan to seek only “appropriate equitable relief.” Defendant argued that the relief sought (a constructive trust) was not equitable; precedent established that a constructive trust is absolutely equitable. Wal-Mart had also requested damages (because it couldn’t get all its money back using only the constructive trust), which were not equitable and were not granted. Wal-Mart also wanted attorney’s fees, interest, and costs, but the magistrate declined to award them.

On appeal, the only issues raised were whether the relief was equitable and appropriate. Interpreting ERISA, a panel of the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals held that the constructive trust was both equitable and appropriate. On the appropriateness prong, the court declined to apply the “make-whole” doctrine, a federal common law doctrine arising out of insurance, to ERISA plans, which do not share the overriding purpose of insurance plans to make the insured whole. Furthermore, because ERISA’s goal was to ensure the integrity of plan documents, the courts should not apply federal common law theories of recovery that contradict the plan’s express and unambiguous terms.

The magistrate’s ruling and the 8th Circuit’s opinion are all spot-on with the law and with any rational theory of contracts. I think the outcome would be the same even if the ERISA statute weren’t involved. In fact, ERISA involvement limited what Wal-Mart would have been able to recover under a straight contract claim, assuming no federal regulation.

The article suggests that Wal-Mart ought to have made a sacrifice of its contractual rights to Shank because she is hurt. But all claimants under Wal-Mart’s plans are hurt; some more than Ms. Shank. Is Wal-Mart to be made the sacrificial goat of choice for everyone who makes claims under its health benefits plan? I do not think one iota of moral blame can be attributed to Wal-Mart in this issue.

~Q

But all claimants under Wal-Mart’s plans are hurt; some more than Ms. Shank.

Nice summary Qwertz. This is the only statement I would take issue with. All claimants under Wal-Marts agreement are subject to the same treatment under the terms the agreed to beforehand. I don’t think characterizing a treatment you’ve agreed to as being “hurt” is correct.

The plan updates are similiar to the updates in credit card terms that most holders of credit cards get, which under the card holder agreement, all holders agree to accept as they are issued. This is a common approach with such plans. It does give the plan issuer substantial leeway in changing the program, but if one agrees to it up front, one can hardly complain, especially when the change in question was several years before the accident.

Aah, I see the confusion. That was Shank’s argument - “Wal-Mart should let me keep the money because I’m hurt in a particularly previous grievous way.” That’s the essence of her “appropriateness” challenge. I was responding that all persons who receive money from the plan (who are indeed all bound by the terms to which they agreed) have received funds because they incurred medical expenses in treating some such injury or illness covered by the plan. I meant to convey that all plan benefit recipients are “hurt” in the way that Ms. Shank is hurt - that they have some injury or illness that required treatment. Some of those recipients are undoubtedly in a more pathetic position than Ms. Shank. Therefore, pity for the claimants’ injuries should not be the grounds on which Wal-Mart should be asked to sacrifice its rights under the plan agreement.

So when I say “All claimants under Wal-Mart’s plans are hurt,” I do not mean that they are hurt by Wal-Mart’s plans. I mean that they would not be claimants unless they had (or thought they had) some covered injury or illness.

~Q

Edit: Spell-checking typo.

Gotcha. All claimants have been injured (by virtue of hte fact that they are claimants in the first place).

The article suggests that Wal-Mart ought to have made a sacrifice of its contractual rights to Shank because she is hurt. But all claimants under Wal-Mart’s plans are hurt; some more than Ms. Shank. Is Wal-Mart to be made the sacrificial goat of choice for everyone who makes claims under its health benefits plan? I do not think one iota of moral blame can be attributed to Wal-Mart in this issue.

I agree that Walmart shouldn’t sacrifice their contractual rights in any case, but I don’t understand why they act on a certain clause just because they have it. Why not just act on it when they have something to gain? Or did they gain something in this case?

The premise is that WalMart has an obligation to pay. Notice that in the middle of the article it randomly states “In 2007, the retail giant reported net sales in the third quarter of $90 billion.”

And also: “Who needs the money more? A disabled lady in a wheelchair with no future, whatsoever, or does Wal-Mart need $90 billion, plus $200,000?” the husband asked.

I agree that Walmart shouldn’t sacrifice their contractual rights in any case, but I don’t understand why they act on a certain clause just because they have it. Why not just act on it when they have something to gain?

You mean other than the $470,000?

This is probably a simply policy decision on Wal-mart’s case, because of the fact that the cost of the insurance program probably assumes that they collect their share in cases like these.

Qwertz, here’s a legal question if you’re inclined. Suppose that a company has a written policy with some contractual force that they require X of employees, but also suppose that as a habit they regularly require less than X (and it’s well known that nobody is actually held to the standard X). Suddenly in one case they elect to enforce the stricter standard against Jones. Would Jones have a legal leg to stand on, based on the claim that the de facto requirement was the less-than-X requirement, not that which was written on paper?

I assume you’re joking.

While I have no idea about the merits of this particular court-case, many health-care plans have clauses like the one mentioned in the story. Suppose I am in an bad accident and the auto-insurance of the car that hit me pays me $400,000 for health expenses and $600,000 for other pain and suffering. My own health insurance company can ask me to use that $400,000 for health expenses related to the accident before they start to pay. If they have already paid out toward the accident, then they are to be repaid from the $400,000.

If this was a case of someone wanting money from a corporation simply because they have it then you’d be right and I’d be joking. But for a corporation to rely on byzantine clauses undermines, though does not explicitly violate, the premise of consensual trade. My suggestion to isolate it economically through grassroots action of willing individuals holds merit.

Qwertz, here’s a legal question if you’re inclined. Suppose that a company has a written policy with some contractual force that they require X of employees, but also suppose that as a habit they regularly require less than X (and it’s well known that nobody is actually held to the standard X). Suddenly in one case they elect to enforce the stricter standard against Jones. Would Jones have a legal leg to stand on, based on the claim that the de facto requirement was the less-than-X requirement, not that which was written on paper?

Do you mean in terms of morals and ethics or in terms of actually winning a suit?

You mean other than the $470,000?

That’s before legal fees and other fees as well. I think legal fees amount to several hundred thousand dollars. That’s how much the “poor, sick” woman had to pay for her legal fees in her prior lawsuit.

This is probably a simply policy decision on Wal-mart’s case, because of the fact that the cost of the insurance program probably assumes that they collect their share in cases like these.

That’s what I figure.

Do you mean in terms of morals and ethics or in terms of actually winning a suit?

It is a legal question (a combination of precedent and probability).

But for a corporation to rely on byzantine clauses undermines, though does not explicitly violate, the premise of consensual trade. My suggestion to isolate it economically through grassroots action of willing individuals holds merit.

In what way is this “byzantine”? Rather, it is standard practice, and is termed “coordination of benefits”. It comes from the nature of insurance. Most non-life insurance policies are meant to make the insured “whole” after they suffer some damage.

Consider this example: You get hit by an driver. It is his fault according to the police report. You had exchanged insurance numbers at the scene, and you submit your claims to his insurance company. His company replies that he had allowed his insurance to lapse, and was therefore uninsured. Since you have “uninsured-motorist coverage”, your insurance company picks up the bill. Can your insurance company sue the uninsured motorist to recover the money they spend? They surely can.

Now, consider a slightly different example. After denial by his insurance company. The guy realizes that he gave you his older number at the scene. So, he gives you his latest insurance details, and this company pays. However, in the meanwhile, your own company has reimbursed some bills. Does your company have the right to get its money back and let the other person’s insurer pay instead? Of course it does.

The Wal*Mart situation is no different. If it is, I’d be interested in knowing how. Perhaps I haven’t understood all the facts.

This is not a case where Wal*Mart is doing something of questionable morality just because it happens to be legal. What they are doing is completely legal and moral. The money they paid was not a lottery winning, it was health-insurance. If the responsible party pays up instead, Wal*Mart should get its money back.

progressive1: Sometimes it makes sense to pursue a case even if the legal costs outweigh the final award. Insurance companies do this with fraudsters all the time. The reasoning is that doing so improves the odds of future situations going one’s way. The payoff comes if one takes along-term view.

Do you mean in terms of morals and ethics or in terms of actually winning a suit?

Also, assuming it isn’t obvious, I think it would be immoral for a company to have an ostensive policy for employees which systematically ignores until it decides to spring a trap. If a company doesn’t intend to have such a policy, it should delete the policy from the book; if it has it, it should enforce it. If, in the worst case, if feels it needs the discretion to enforce at random, then the policy should state that it may or may not be enforced, on a whim. To pretend to have a policy but systematically ignore it is dishonest and a sign of a very unprincipled way of looking at the world.

Qwertz, here’s a legal question if you’re inclined. Suppose that a company has a written policy with some contractual force that they require X of employees, but also suppose that as a habit they regularly require less than X (and it’s well known that nobody is actually held to the standard X). Suddenly in one case they elect to enforce the stricter standard against Jones. Would Jones have a legal leg to stand on, based on the claim that the de facto requirement was the less-than-X requirement, not that which was written on paper?

I’m not a lawyer. However, from my little work in the commercial area, I know that courts do interpret de facto practices that vary from contractual terms as implicit modifications in the contract. If Wal-Mart had terms contractually and didn’t enforce them or arbitrarily did so, then the plaintiffs might have a leg. That is another reason for making it simply a policy decision. If it is in the contract then it needs to be enforced in all cases.

Suppose that a company has a written policy with some contractual force that they require X of employees, but also suppose that as a habit they regularly require less than X (and it’s well known that nobody is actually held to the standard X). Suddenly in one case they elect to enforce the stricter standard against Jones. Would Jones have a legal leg to stand on, based on the claim that the de facto requirement was the less-than-X requirement, not that which was written on paper?

Standard “this is not legal advice; for legal advice, consult a licensed attorney” disclaimer applies.

Having that contractual force is pretty rare. A standard like this would never appear in a contract for employment unless the standard was objective and non-discretionary. Provisions in contracts that say “Party A may take adverse action Y if Party B’s performance is not satisfactory to Party A” are generally not enforceable because the make the contract a nullity - Party A isn’t really agreeing to anything.

Lots of employees are at-will, meaning there is no written agreement. Such employees may be fired without cause at any time, so a general policy of requiring X will be left to the discretion of the employer, and arbitrary enforcement will not help employee keep his job - employer has a right to fire employee for whatever reason or no reason at all. If employer has a policy in a handbook and uses it in supervising at-will employees, then it has no contractual or legal force - it can usually be enforced arbitrarily.

Even in the (now rare) situation were an at-will employment becomes a contractual one because of a carelessly drafted employee handbook, such a standard in the handbook would be very unlikely to carry any weight. It’s just not the sort of thing that gets imputed into the agreement in those cases. Which are now rare, because employers know how to avoid losing their at-will termination powers to poorly drafted handbooks.

On the off-chance that you do find an agreement with such a standard in it, the agreement will almost always control. There is a doctrine that might help employee under certain circumstances: waiver. Employee must show that employer’s past failure to enforce the requirement constituted a waiver of employer’s right under the provision. It’s usually hard to do, but in an ongoing employment relationship it can be a bit easier.

~Q

** Double Post! **

Incidentally, waiver is the reason Wal-Mart acted on the contractual provision at issue here. If Wal-Mart does not exercise the contractual right, it may lose it in the future. Not only is there the “if we let one get away with it, others will think they can get away with it” problem, but there’s the legal waiver doctrine which will see to it that others do get away with it. Lots of them.

~Q