Given below is a hypothetical scenario involving 2 organizations, O1 & O2, and a group of individuals.
O1 believes in promoting Objectivism as a closed system whereas O2 believes in promoting Objectivism as an open system, or Open Objectivism (OO).
O1 also believes:
- OO is dishonest because it evades the fact that Objectivism is the name Ayn Rand gave to the philosophy she created during her lifetime.
- O2 is dishonest because its purpose is to use Ayn Rand’s name and the name of her philosophy, to spread ideas she never believed in, and therefore, did not include in her philosophy.
Now suppose there are individuals who want to contribute money to both O1 & O2. These individuals can be categorized as:
- those who have not seriously thought about OO & O2.
- those who think they don’t have to seriously think about OO & O2.
In other words, since both groups have not, unlike O1, morally judged OO & O2 as dishonest, they find nothing morally wrong with their wanting to also contribute to O2.
Given the above context, if both groups start contributing to O2, what is the proper course of action O1 should take?
- should O1 decline contributions from all of them since they are implicitly sanctioning OO & O2, which O1 believes are dishonest?
- should O1 accept contributions from all of them since they are, unwittingly not willfully, sanctioning OO & O2?
If so, is such an action morally consistent with its belief that OO & O2 are dishonest? - should O1, before accepting contributions from them, try to convince them to seriously think about OO & O2 and stop contributing to O2?
- should O1, if it chooses 3, and fails to convince some of them, accept or decline contributions from those who are not convinced and continue to support O2?
If it accepts, is such an action morally consistent with its belief that OO & O2 are dishonest? - should O1, if it chooses 3, only accept contributions from those individuals who are convinced by it to seriously think about OO & O2 and stop contributing to O2?