From an evolutionary perspective, volitional action (free will) and man’s ability to reason seem like they must be relatively recent occurrences. Chimpanzees, which are very close to us genetically, still lack these abilities. Being relatively recent, it seems to me that these abilities are probably not fully mature. Based on experience, it’s also increasingly clear to me that the degree of their presence in humans is not consistent. Perhaps that’s in the nature of an evolutionary change; the whole population doesn’t move along at the same rate or even in the same exact way.
What led me down this line of thinking is that I see these things in myself. I am generally a very Objectivist person. But I find that I have “automatic” (for lack of a better word) thoughts and feelings that occasionally pull me off-track. If I sit down and think about it, I can usually identify where I went wrong. But in the heat of the moment, it is sometimes an extremely difficult thing to do. I suspect the same is true for most people, to some degree.
At least part of the problem is cultural. Modern schools certainly don’t teach kids how to think. But I think it’s also deeper than that. I suspect that it might be impossible for many people to grasp reason and reality in any deep sense, and even if they do, applying it fully in their daily lives represents another huge challenge.
To help those of us who sometimes struggle with personal issues along these lines, I wonder if something like Objectivist-oriented psychotherapy would be useful. Not therapy in the Freudian sense – rather, help with thought processes and applying tools like induction and principles to our daily lives, or helping us recognize when we are drifting off into rationalism or empiricism. Maybe “philosophical consulting” is a more descriptive term. Does such a service even exist? Or am I the only one who feels this way?