Are Objectivists victims to the Psychology of the common-sensical?

SL, I quoted what you actually said and the missing premises you mention are contained in knowledge of the Oist philosophy which your post demonstrate ignorance of.

 

I explained that " You will not be able to transfer meaning this way without denying the context the concepts used from “common sense” (which aint psychology!) originated". You want a process of conceptualization/abstraction that skirts reduction.  You want abstraction disconnected from hierarchy, without a foundation on first level concepts. You want to turn the special sciences into a floating abstraction free from the criticism of the foundational science of Philosophy.

 

In forming concepts of hypothetical entities the concepts you use to define them,if valid, will ALL be integrations of sense data. Otherwise, “You are applying a concept from our present level of knowledge to a level on which you deny it suddenly.” The entire way you describe and even named your thread shows lack of understanding of Oist epistemology.

 

For now Ill post some quotes from ITOE for you to ponder:

 

 

“And you know what else is crucially important? When you talk about discovering the ultimate constituents of the universe, remember that in order to discover them, no matter by what calculations or by what machinery, you had to bring them to your perceptual level. You would have to say “this particle” is that which acts in such and such a way on subatomic particles, which act in such and such a way on atoms, which act in such and such a way on molecules, and all of that results in a material object such as this glass as distinguished from other material objects such as this ashtray. Unless you bring it back to the perceptual level, it’s not knowledge. That is what has to be kept in mind always in speculating about ultimate causes, which have to be discovered by some, at present, unknown means. You still always have to bring it back to your sensory-perceptual level, otherwise it’s not knowledge”

“Measurement is the identification of a relationship in numerical terms—and the complexity of the science of measurement indicates the complexity of the relationships which exist in the universe and which man has barely begun to investigate. They exist, even if the appropriate standards and methods of measurement are not always as easily apparent nor the degree of achievable precision as great as in the case of measuring the basic, perceptually given attributes of matter. If anything were actually “immeasurable,” it would bear no relationship of any kind to the rest of the universe, it would not affect nor be affected by anything else in any manner whatever, it would enact no causes and bear no consequences—in short, it would not exist.

The motive of the anti-measurement attitude is obvious: it is the desire to preserve a sanctuary of the indeterminate for the benefit of the irrational—the desire, epistemologically, to escape from the responsibility of cognitive precision and wide-scale integration; and, metaphysically, the desire to escape from the absolutism of existence, of facts, of reality and, above all, of identity.”…

" The process of measurement is a process of integrating an unlimited scale of knowledge to man’s limited perceptual experience—a process of making the universe knowable by bringing it within the range of man’s consciousness, by establishing its relationship to man. It is not an accident that man’s earliest attempts at measurement (the evidence of which survives to this day) consisted of relating things to _himself—_as, for instance, taking the length of his foot as a standard of length, or adopting the decimal system, which is supposed to have its origin in man’s ten fingers as units of counting.

It is here that Protagoras’ old dictum may be given a new meaning, the opposite of the one he intended: “Man is the measure of all things.” Man is the measure, epistemologically—not metaphysically. In regard to human knowledge, man has to be the measure, since he has to bring all things into the realm of the humanly knowable. But, far from leading to subjectivism, the methods which he has to employ require the most rigorous mathematical precision, the most rigorous compliance with objective rules and facts—if the end product is to be knowledge.

This is true of mathematical principles and of the principles by which man forms his concepts. Man’s mathematical and conceptual abilities develop simultaneously. A child learns to count when he is learning his first words. And in order to proceed beyond the stage of counting his ten fingers, it is the conceptual level of his consciousness that man has to expand."…

 

“ Everything that we discuss, everything, is <ioe2_194> done from the human viewpoint and has to be, because there is no such thing as “reality in itself.” That is one of the concepts of Kant’s that we have to be very careful of. If we were omniscient like God, we would still have to perceive reality by our God-like means of perception, and we would have to speak of exactitude from that viewpoint. But “things in themselves”—as separated from consciousness and yet discussed in terms of a consciousness—is an invalid equivocation. .”..

 

“when we speak of measurement, we begin with a perceptually given unit, and that unit is absolute and exact [within the context of our means of perception]. Then conceptually we may refine our methods and we may measure such things as milliseconds and a part of a subatomic particle, which we can’t do perceptually. But the standard of these measurements, the base from which conceptual complications may later be derived, is that which we perceive directly on the perceptual level; that is what measurement means, that is its base. Therefore, when I say that for measurement there has to be a unit of measurement, I mean that even when you take a submicroscopic, conceptual type of measurement, that type ultimately has to be reduced back to our standard of measurement, which is the perceptually given, and nothing more or less.

With scientific development you might discover that, microscopically, the edge of this piece of paper is ragged and has tiny mountain peaks and valleys. That is not relevant to your [macroscopic] process of measurement, because you had to use the perceptual method as a start in order to get to your microscopic instruments of measurement” "

SL, I quoted what you actually said and the missing premises you mention are contained in knowledge of the Oist philosophy which your post demonstrate ignorance of.

 

I explained that " You will not be able to transfer meaning this way without denying the context the concepts used from “common sense” (which aint psychology!) originated". You want a process of conceptualization/abstraction that skirts reduction.  You want abstraction disconnected from hierarchy, without a foundation on first level concepts. You want to turn the special sciences into a floating abstraction free from the criticism of the foundational science of Philosophy.

 

In forming concepts of hypothetical entities the concepts you use to define them,if valid, will ALL be integrations of sense data. Otherwise, “You are applying a concept from our present level of knowledge to a level on which you deny it suddenly.” The entire way you describe and even named your thread shows lack of understanding of Oist epistemology.

 

For now Ill post some quotes from ITOE for you to ponder:

 

Plasmatic:

 

You’ve barraged me with a whole new set of “assertions” which I would rather defer response to until we have addressed the first set of assertions, the basis on which you rely to make, I am still trying to figure out.

 

 

Perhaps this discussion will benefit from a little focus.

 

Of:

 

1.  “You are talking nonsense above and do not understand what your words above actually mean in light of it.”

2.  “What you describe above is impossible!”

3.  “you dont know that logic is the formalization of MEANING”

 

I suggest we deal with 2, primarily because it is more “oriented toward reality” than the purported content of anyone’s mind.

 

I ask you to address directly:

 

A ) To WHAT are you referring when you say “What you described above.”

B ) What portion (or totality) of that “what is described above” is impossible

C ) Precisely WHY IS that “what is described” impossible.

 

 

Respectfully,

SL

I quoted what I meant by above and reiterated it to you when you asked for clarification.

Here it is again:

""But when it comes to imagining reality in comparison to common experience, we tend to rely too much on what we are perceptually accustomed to. Anything other than common experience must be analysed very carefully using sound inductive and deductive reasoning…

Let me restate. Although we always endeavor to describe the universe in a way which can intuitively understand, it may be that some phenomena of the actual universe are not in the set of “human intuition compatible” concrete’s (although understandable with abstraction/conceptualization), and hence imposing on that universe the requirement that all phenomena “should be” such that it is “human intuition compatible” may be nonsensical… indeed “human centric”… (earth at the center of the universe again…). We must understand reality as it is with what capacity we can, so it is in some sense “on our terms” and with our limitations we describe the universe, but the universe is the final judge of itself so to speak."

The above is full of errors. Edit: The impossible in it is the idea that meaning can be transferred to higher level concepts while denying their source and context in perception. That induction or deduction somehow allow us to bypass the foundation of perception to ALL HUMAN knowledge.

Now If you read the ITOE quotes I posted you will see that they address more of what you said than the above and thats why I posted them.

I’ve been thinking about this a lot, lately, and I think I understand the present malfunction.

 

SL, can what you are trying to convey be summarized as the assertion: “there may be entities within (and/or inclusive) aspects of the universe which are not logical”?

 

Because that’s what common-sense is; the informal use of on-the-fly logic.  Many people tend to make invalid assumptions while using common sense but that stems from lapses of judgment and shoddy reasoning.

Common-sense itself, if followed ruthlessly and rigorously enough, is the precursor to formal logic.  I think this is part of what Plasmatic is criticizing, based on 1. Common sense is amateur logic 2. Your username is strictly logical and 3. you’re criticizing common sense.

 

I do see where you’re coming from but I think the word you’re looking for is intuitive.

Things are not always exactly what they seem to be, at first glance (which I infer is the brunt of your argument, and is true) but human beings can find out the truth behind appearances. . . Through the use of common sense.

 

Now, I think what Plasmatic is trying to say (please correct me if I’m wrong) is this:

 

Human beings can only perceive the universe through human senses and human minds (i.e. logic).  We have no other way of knowing anything.

 

Now, he’s saying that it’s impossible for there to be anything we can’t understand, and that’s probably true (I won’t go there; unnecessary) but consider this:

 

If there were any entity (and/or) aspect of the universe which was imperceptible or illogical, could we ever actually be aware of it?  I’m not sure how well that corresponds to your actual argument but, if you follow that line of reasoning, I think it boils down to “We know that we cannot know anything” which IS impossible.

 

 

 

It isn’t a metaphysical problem; it’s epistemological (not WHAT exists but HOW we know it).  Furthermore, I think if you stop and rethink the concepts you’re using and your terminology, you’ll find that the disagreement is actually much smaller than you think.

That which is random is out-of-bounds to human knowledge; you cannot predict or understand it. 

For instance, you could tell me that there’s a 1/6 chance of a die landing on any given side or a 1/2 chance of a coin flip landing heads or tails; I assert that this doesn’t count as functional knowledge.

If you had to build cars or skyscrapers that way, we would end up “knowing” that only 1/6th of people who use them will die horribly.  If you planted crops with statistical and probabilistic knowledge, you would starve one year in six.

 

For something to “truly” be random is for it to be causeless (because there’s supposedly no reason for any one outcome, instead of another) which ultimately defies the law of identity.  Truly random particles would behave illogically.

 

That which has no identity is beyond the scope of human understanding; that which is out-of-bounds to reason, for all intents and purposes, doesn’t exist.

It’s semantically null to debate over the nature of things we cannot understand; it is as futile as debating how many angels could dance on the head of a pin.  So if there are parts of the universe which we can never understand, there is no reason whatsoever to discuss or even think about them.

 

If you can’t understand it then it’s a waste of time to try- if you cannot think about something then it “exists” in exactly the same way that unicorns do.

 

But, again, this isn’t metaphysical but epistemological.  Note that nowhere in here did I assert whether or not the Copenhagen Interpretation is true; all I’m saying is that even IF it’s true, it renders itself irrelevant to the whole of humanity and utterly meaningless.

1 Like

The above is full of errors. Edit: The impossible in it is the idea that meaning can be transferred to higher level concepts while denying their source and context in perception. That induction or deduction somehow allow us to bypass the foundation of perception to ALL HUMAN knowledge.

What’s wrong about it? What you quoted from SL seems exactly what a supporter of Oist epistemology would say. While intuitive understanding is useful to attain, trying to *make* everything intuitive is just a bad process of reason. To me, it’s saying “understand reality as best you can, don’t make assumptions based solely on intuition”. It’s necessary to use abstractions to get past being concrete-bound. Get past, not bypass.

 

SL, the only thing I might disagree in is “with our limitations”. Do you mean some things will never be understood, or do you only mean there is always more to learn?

Harrison: your comments look interesting but I am focused on an exchange with Plasmatic right now.  Please forgive me if I address them later.

 

Plasmatic:

 

You stated: 

“The impossible in it is the idea that meaning can be transferred to higher level concepts while denying their source and context in perception. That induction or deduction somehow allow us to bypass the foundation of perception to ALL HUMAN knowledge”

 

This is the very misunderstanding I thought you may have had.  I will be clear:

1   induction or deduction CANNOT bypass the foundation of knowledge which at its base is perception… the only link to reality.  I am not a rationalist, and as an objectivist reject all forms of mysticism, religion, Platonism, communism, primacy of consciousness…etc.  Induction and deduction … are my tools I use to make sense of my perceptions, conceptually in an integrated, noncontradictory fashion.

2   I do not deny that perception and our perceptual apparatus are fundamental to obtaining information from reality.  They are fundamental, in fact they are the ONLY tie a consciousness has to reality no many how many or few (blind deaf.. etc.) or how weakly that consciousness is able to get input from reality, that input IS all it has (inner self-knowledge, intuition, “remembering” platonic forms… are NOT sources of knowledge of existents.. these are introspective musings, delusions, and imaginings only).

 

 

These two things I state above ARE my philosophy.  The question arises: what have I said that could have been misconstrued to mean the exact opposite?

 

 

 

I think perhaps it may be due to my identifying (attempting?) concepts not commonly referred to, or perhaps I have referred to something known in special circles according to some specific jargon which I have not used.

 

 

What is the hypothetically flawed objectivist (and by no means do I mean every objectivist) doing which I identify as a mistake?  Certainly, relying on perceptual input is NOT a mistake.  The pencil appearing bent in a glass of water is in no way “wrong” it is the way the light refracts through the water, enters the eye and is processed by the visual cortex.  The possible problem which can arise is the prescientific instantaneous judgement that the pencil must itself be bent.  It is in this sense only that I refer to “common sense intuitions” which can be erroneous if the whole of knowledge, experiments, analysis etc, is not integrated with the process of assessing the appearance of the pencil.  As an objectivist, maximal integration is my voluntarily chosen “duty” (not the best word but you get my meaning)

 

In a sense the error I am thinking of is focusing too much on or giving too much weight to common-sense “feelings” and intuitions  humans (including unwary objectivists) have, which interferes with proper cognition.  Feelings and intuition cannot form a  basis of knowledge… this is precisely my point. 

 

E.g.  We all know from specialized knowledge of the science of physics that atoms, nuclei and their surrounding electrons, exist and form all forms of everyday solid, gaseous, and liquid matter.  I know of no objectivist who rejects the concept of atoms, but we should recognise that there is an accomplishment involved in the acceptance of this fact.  We have had to forego the application of concepts such as solidity and “continuity of entity” as applicable to our interaction with “a ball of steel” and “a rock” at our time and length scales, when dealing with electrons, nuclei and atoms.  This is not trivial.  I note we used our rationality and our perceptual faculty to imagine, construct, conduct  an experiment and analyse the results to arrive at this state of counterintuitive knowledge. 

 

Perhaps it is only my intuition, but when I imagine things, entities in reality, something which is solid and continuous tends to appear in my mind: not something mostly empty, made of pointlike (if not actual point) particles interacting in a manner which gives rise to an arrangement which is static and yet utterly discontinuous and full of space.  

[[[As an aside: when writing this, my common-sense intuition is screaming “point particle… nothing is a point.. a point has no length, no area, no volume such a thing is impossible because … all things have volume are solid and are continuous…” I note this is circular and unsupported, then I have an infinite regression type argument with myself INVENTING spherical particles which are solid…for which there is no evidence whatsoever that they exist… soon I realise my intuition is simply not applicable and is simply not based on any data relevant to that which I am trying to apply it]]]  

This intuition (solidity and continuity) about the way the universe is, does work at the level of everyday objects we interact with and operationally makes perfect sense and in that sense is true.  I cannot pass my hand through a block of steel, and I can (on a macroscopic scale) divide it to my heart’s content.  This is useful knowledge and solidity is valid.  The concept of solidity, however, is simply inapplicable to electrons and nuclei which make up all solid matter. 

 

These things give rise to solidity but they do not themselves possess it.

 

To me this is an accomplishment in abstract conceptual thinking, knowledge of atoms as they are requires rationality and careful experimentation.  This does not involve the denial of the perceptual faculty but does in some sense require close examination and vigilance with respect to “intuitive common sense” so as not to permit it to lead us astray.

 

My open question was whether certain prescientific, non specialized knowledge or experience based “common sense intuitions” may influence judgements about science in the absence of the full body of knowledge which should be integrated to make a decision about it.

 

This kind of mistake may not in fact be a phenomenon attributable to Objectivists in general… my sample is very small.

 

I hope this resolves the misunderstanding of my meaning.

 

 

SL

 

 

 

1 Like

What’s wrong about it? What you quoted from SL seems exactly what a supporter of Oist epistemology would say. While intuitive understanding is useful to attain, trying to *make* everything intuitive is just a bad process of reason. To me, it’s saying “understand reality as best you can, don’t make assumptions based solely on intuition”. It’s necessary to use abstractions to get past being concrete-bound. Get past, not bypass.

 

SL, the only thing I might disagree in is “with our limitations”. Do you mean some things will never be understood, or do you only mean there is always more to learn?

Thanks Eiuol for getting what I was trying to say.

 

The kinds of limitations I am alluding to are not conceptual, I generally assume we have no limit to abstraction (although there may be a limit to how many things we can have in our mind at any one time). 

 

There are many ways in which we are limited… one that comes to mind is visualization which I think is a big part of how we think, and this is limited by our internal visualizing apparatus which deals easily with one and two dimensions, reasonably well with three (because we live in it), but for example, if we need to visualize four or more dimensional data, without some sort of specialized training, we need to take a cross section (three dimensional cross section so to speak) in order to “see” a bit of the whole thing… Immediate and autonomous pattern recognition also is something which is limited by our cognitive capacity… we are much better than more primitive animals.. but we have limits. 

 

Again due to our ability to abstract and with use of mathematics and such we can solve these sorts of complex problems which we cannot instantaneously and automatically process just by looking at them.  

 

I am not a psychologist so the above is speculation…

That which is random is out-of-bounds to human knowledge; you cannot predict or understand it. 

For instance, you could tell me that there’s a 1/6 chance of a die landing on any given side or a 1/2 chance of a coin flip landing heads or tails; I assert that this doesn’t count as functional knowledge.

If you had to build cars or skyscrapers that way, we would end up “knowing” that only 1/6th of people who use them will die horribly.  If you planted crops with statistical and probabilistic knowledge, you would starve one year in six.

 

For something to “truly” be random is for it to be causeless (because there’s supposedly no reason for any one outcome, instead of another) which ultimately defies the law of identity.  Truly random particles would behave illogically.

 

That which has no identity is beyond the scope of human understanding; that which is out-of-bounds to reason, for all intents and purposes, doesn’t exist.

It’s semantically null to debate over the nature of things we cannot understand; it is as futile as debating how many angels could dance on the head of a pin.  So if there are parts of the universe which we can never understand, there is no reason whatsoever to discuss or even think about them.

 

If you can’t understand it then it’s a waste of time to try- if you cannot think about something then it “exists” in exactly the same way that unicorns do.

 

But, again, this isn’t metaphysical but epistemological.  Note that nowhere in here did I assert whether or not the Copenhagen Interpretation is true; all I’m saying is that even IF it’s true, it renders itself irrelevant to the whole of humanity and utterly meaningless.

 

I agree with pretty much everything you are saying.

 

 

You stated: “For something to “truly” be random is for it to be causeless (because there’s supposedly no reason for any one outcome, instead of another) which ultimately defies the law of identity.  Truly random particles would behave illogically.”

 

Agree: the particular result of a “truly” random outcome or choice must be causeless (at least insofar as the randomness goes).

 

Any outcome that is causeless “ultimately defies the law of identity”.  This conclusion I am not sure I agree with… although the logical part of my brain says I should agree with it.  The problem is that if I do, free will may be threatened.

 

 

Here is my reasoning which I borrow from an argument about free will and determinism put forth by a friend (he advocates that free will exists and choices are first causes in reality):

 

1.  A person is an entity in reality. (non mysticism)

2.  A person has consciousness and volition (denial of determinism) and although made up of ultimately constituent elements of reality (denial of mysticism) is not determined by the ultimate constituents of reality (material) making up the person.(assertion of nonmaterialism)

3.  All entities A in reality are such that A is A and A acts in accordance with A’s nature, hence a person is that person and will act in accordance with that person’s nature.

4.  Volition and denial of determinism implies not only that a person not be determined by the constituent elements of reality making up that person, not be determined by external existents, but also (in order to assert that the person always “could have chosen otherwise”) that a person’s choice not be determined completely based upon the particular nature of the person at the time of the choice (the exact same person after all is not compelled to make only one choice because  they could have chosen otherwise),

  1. Freewill requires therefore that the person’s choices, although perhaps limited, are ultimately not determined by anything, i.e. volitional actions/choices are first causes.

  2. By definition first causes, are not determined, and are therefore in one sense causeless (as between the at least two choices the person could have chosen “otherwise”).

 

Looking at this defence of free will I see the same conflict with the law of identity.  The same kind of problem you identify with random outcomes from a single state.  Something A, changes state or form in accordance with it’s nature to a set of outcomes/choices which are not caused (determined) by the nature of the something A at the time the change occurred.  The range of possible choices may be determined by the nature of A but the specific (random) outcome is not.

 

If I am to accept the idea an entity such as a human can be a first cause or make a truly causeless choice, then why in principle can’t an electron undergo a causeless outcome out of a set of possibilities?

In #27 Strictly Logical said

2   I do not deny that perception and our perceptual apparatus are fundamental to obtaining information from reality.  They are fundamental, in fact they are the ONLY tie a consciousness has to reality

 

 

 

Does this not suggest a separation between self(consciousness) and ‘reality’?

SL, first let me say that I should have had you define intuitions, as I never use that term and I think it has a host of negative uses. However I was NOT focused on it but your use of common sense. I’ll leave it be but you seem to have used intuition now in a couple of different senses. I used the context of your post to surmise what you meant which amounts exactly to:

 

We have had to forego the application of concepts such as solidity and “continuity of entity” as applicable to our interaction with “a ball of steel” and “a rock” at our time and length scales, when dealing with electrons, nuclei and atoms. This is not trivial. I note we used our rationality and our perceptual faculty to imagine, construct, conduct an experiment and analyse the results to arrive at this state of counterintuitive knowledge.

Perhaps it is only my intuition, but when I imagine things, entities in reality, something which is solid and continuous tends to appear in my mind: not something mostly empty, made of pointlike (if not actual point) particles interacting in a manner which gives rise to an arrangement which is static and yet utterly discontinuous and full of space.  

[[[As an aside: when writing this, my common-sense intuition is screaming “point particle… nothing is a point.. a point has no length, no area, no volume such a thing is impossible because … all things have volume are solid and are continuous…” I note this is circular and unsupported, then I have an infinite regression type argument with myself INVENTING spherical particles which are solid…for which there is no evidence whatsoever that they exist… soon I realise my intuition is simply not applicable and is simply not based on any data relevant to that which I am trying to apply it]]]  

This intuition (solidity and continuity) about the way the universe is, does work at the level of everyday objects we interact with and operationally makes perfect sense and in that sense is true.  I cannot pass my hand through a block of steel, and I can (on a macroscopic scale) divide it to my heart’s content.  This is useful knowledge and solidity is valid.  The concept of solidity, however, is simply inapplicable to electrons and nuclei which make up all solid matter.

 

The above is exactly what I understood you to be claiming/arguing for. This is a description of trying to use concepts from one context and dropping that meaning while imputing it to another one. Here, as in your description I quoted before, you want to discard the perceptually gained meaning and impute the concept to hypotheticals in a way that the previous meaning will not transfer.

 

To paraphrase a physicist I know: “The first job of the scientist is do decide what concepts to apply to his observations”.

 

I have understood you and I reject the notion of particles having zero extension.

 

edit: I should have just quoted this first:

 

Acceptance and subsequent integration of knowledge gained by science here requires that we do NOT abandon reason, deductive and inductive logic, careful experimentation, but DOES require that we abandon day to day human “PERCEPTION” level assumptions about the universe, some which SEEM like “common sense”.  This is a fine distinction with which perhaps layperson objectivists are somewhat challenged

Your use of “assumptions” noted

Louie, see my above post. Just to clear up something, what I’m describing is not anti conceptual (concrete bound) but affirming the absolute need to preserve conceptual hierarchy and abstract in a way that is valid.

Are Objectivists victims to the Psychology of the common-sensical?

Some, probably. I doubt everyone going around arguing against various QM theories is qualified to form an opinion on the subject. 

 

That doesn’t have anything to do with whether the Objectivists who are qualified, and have spoken on this in a well reasoned manner, are right or wrong. Why not just focus on their arguments? People’s psychology is irrelevant to scientific debates.

In #27 Strictly Logical said

2   I do not deny that perception and our perceptual apparatus are fundamental to obtaining information from reality.  They are fundamental, in fact they are the ONLY tie a consciousness has to reality

 

 

 

Does this not suggest a separation between self(consciousness) and ‘reality’?

 

In this context I use “reality” to refer to existence as independent of the perceiver or thinker.  So I guess I am excluding introspection.  Don’t get me wrong mental contents are not outside of reality but they are not to be confused with the external existents which exist in reality.  The map is NOT the territory.  Consciousness is a part of reality but is of course located within a tiny subset of existence whether you measure in constituents, space weight etc.   I am using integration here… we know consciousness exists within the confines of the skull.  Or at least the nervous system.  We have not observed human consciousness, in relation to reality, matter, substance,… elsewhere.  So “separation” is at least by localisation.  BUT I am not saying mind and body are separable, the mind and body are not separable (other than on death… when the body continues and consciousness ceases to exist).

 

I am also assuming for example that a potentiality for human consciousness (a baby’s nervous system), IF devoid ENTIRELY of any senses, sight, hearing, touch, smell, taste, will NOT have any knowledge of reality.  Whatever activity occurs in that system might in fact not EVEN amount to consciousness until it is given the chance to experience through the senses reality and develop into a consciousness. 

OR Take the case of a fully conscious objectivist adult.  If all those senses were cut off that adult is no longer in touch with reality.  He or she remembers and knows certain facts of reality, has introspection, imagination, feelings, and thoughts, and some of the facts he or she knows will not have changed, and perhaps that person could even think of something new (relying on memory) which would correspond to reality (an invention or a new principle of science) but informationally they are still severed from reality.  So consciousness can also be separated in terms of information.

 

 

It is in this way that I mean the senses are the only tie (this might be the word which is misleading… would “window” be better?) on reality (external reality independent of the conscious mind perceiving/conceiving it)

Some, probably. I doubt everyone going around arguing against various QM theories is qualified to form an opinion on the subject. 

 

That doesn’t have anything to do with whether the Objectivists who are qualified, and have spoken on this in a well reasoned manner, are right or wrong. Why not just focus on their arguments? People’s psychology is irrelevant to scientific debates.

 

I tend to notice things… some observables of which are at the limits of my capacity for observation.. “subtle patterns in groups of people” are a type of category of observable which I am often unsure of and would like to know other people’s opinions.  I generally have a burning need to understand (this is intensely personal, afterall it is MY life, my knowledge, my guide to action etc), part of that need, valid or not, is wanting to understand how other people think and why… the “principle of the dean” applied widely.

 

I agree that the general population of Objectivists are likely no better or worse a representation of those objectivists “who are qualified”, than those in the nonobjectivist general public are a representation of those nonobjectivists “who are qualified”.

 

What I think I am “observing” is that Objectivists who are not qualified, seem to tend they think they know more than they do or at least that they overestimate what they can conclude from the little knowledge (specialised) that they have.  A sort of epistemological overconfidence?

If I am to accept the idea an entity such as a human can be a first cause or make a truly causeless choice, then why in principle can’t an electron undergo a causeless outcome out of a set of possibilities?

A human being a “first cause” means the human mind would be causeless. It’s basically a form of dualism. So, yes, free will as you described it is threatened. But that description is untenable with anything about how reality works. If one is capable of making *any choice at all* and even a first cause, it has no identity at all - capable of everything and anything without any particular identifiable attribute. The “causeless” mind is something Rand often addressed quite vociferously, so finding more on the Objectivist perspective is easy. To take some more modern philosophical arguments, free will describes a level of abstraction on something like an information processing level (similar to how one describes processes of a computer). Particle physics is a totally separate level of abstraction, there is no free will there, it doesn’t need to be to describe how particles work. That’s a lot like what you were saying about solidity in the first post. It doesn’t make sense to talk about solidity with regard to particle physics, but it does at a level of whole entities.

 

This is getting a little off-topic, so if you want, I’ll discuss this in another thread. There is a thread like this side-topic already, but I don’t recall the title of it.

A human being a “first cause” means the human mind would be causeless. It’s basically a form of dualism. So, yes, free will as you described it is threatened. But that description is untenable with anything about how reality works. If one is capable of making *any choice at all* and even a first cause, it has no identity at all - capable of everything and anything without any particular identifiable attribute. The “causeless” mind is something Rand often addressed quite vociferously, so finding more on the Objectivist perspective is easy. To take some more modern philosophical arguments, free will describes a level of abstraction on something like an information processing level (similar to how one describes processes of a computer). Particle physics is a totally separate level of abstraction, there is no free will there, it doesn’t need to be to describe how particles work. That’s a lot like what you were saying about solidity in the first post. It doesn’t make sense to talk about solidity with regard to particle physics, but it does at a level of whole entities.

 

This is getting a little off-topic, so if you want, I’ll discuss this in another thread. There is a thread like this side-topic already, but I don’t recall the title of it.

 

Very interesting.  If you started a thread about free will I would be very interested in participating although I would have limited ability to contribute.  I’ve done some reading on consciousness and how a nonreductive fundamental science might emerge on the subject but “free will” itself is not something I read much about.  To my mind, we will have developed an understanding of consciousness and free will and thereby solved both “puzzles” only when we reach a point in time at which we could create an artificial system which we would know, because of the way we have “configured” it, that it has consciousness and free will. i.e. we could with confidence answer “how do you know that it has”/“why does it have” both consciousness and free will.

edit: I should have just quoted this first:

 

Quote

Your use of “assumptions” noted          

 

My wording has an ERROR.  I do not mean we must abandon “ALL” day to day human perception level assumptions in ALL contexts.  This would be disastrous and implies throwing out far too much.  We of course must retain day to day understanding of percepts in order to deal with the world and deal with our, let me call it, “extended perceptual apparatus” which is our scientific instrumentation. 

 Plasmatic:

 

You stated:

 
The above is exactly what I understood you to be claiming/arguing for. This is a description of trying to use concepts from one context and dropping that meaning while imputing it to another one. Here, as in your description I quoted before, you want to discard the perceptually gained meaning and impute the concept to hypotheticals in a way that the previous meaning will not transfer.
 
To paraphrase a physicist I know: “The first job of the scientist is do decide what concepts to apply to his observations”.
 
I have understood you and I reject the notion of particles having zero extension

 

If I understand you correctly, you are asserting that I have done the following:

 

1.  With knowledge of the experiment I “want” to discard the perceptually gained meaning of solidity

2  I imagine a hypothetical to which solidity does not apply, point like particle

  1. I foist this point like particle  as proof that the concept “solidity” is not universally applicable to all existents in all contexts

 

Does this capture your take on my words?

 

 

Let me summarize what I think I actually was doing:

 

  1. assessing what the results of the Rutherford experiment say about the nature of every day existents (mostly space, made of an arrangement of discrete entities rather than being a single extended continuous entity) 

  2. observing that our perceptual level intuition about solidity of every day objects (no holes, continuous) is not compatible with reality as it is (insofar as objects actually do have holes and are not continuous)

  3. observing that the only basis for both the perceptual level intuition of solidity and the concept of solidity is our everyday perception of everyday objects and our interactions with them at our length and time scales.

  4. identifying that given the new understanding why and how “solidity” as a property of objects arises from its constituents, it would be a mistake to attempt to impose upon those constituents themselves which cause solidity, the property of solidity because this begs the further question “what causes that kind of solidity?”

  5. identifying that point like particles are consistent with the mechanisms giving rise to solidity of everyday objects at our time and length scales and need not be solid (extended, no holes, continuous) themselves. i.e. point like particles are completely consistent with a complete integration of the Rutherford experiment and our everyday interactions with reality and require no infinite regress of kinds of solidity and their mechanisms.

 

 

I tend to notice things… some observables of which are at the limits of my capacity for observation.. “subtle patterns in groups of people” are a type of category of observable which I am often unsure of and would like to know other people’s opinions.  I generally have a burning need to understand (this is intensely personal, afterall it is MY life, my knowledge, my guide to action etc), part of that need, valid or not, is wanting to understand how other people think and why… the “principle of the dean” applied widely.

The “principle behind the Dean” is that the Dean is a second-hander. I don’t see the connection with the thread’s subject (which, correct me if I’m wrong, is about the fallacy of appealing to common sense).

 

I also still think it’s pointless to have a conversation about what percentage of a vaguely identified group of strangers is committing this fallacy.

I agree that the general population of Objectivists are likely no better or worse a representation of those objectivists “who are qualified”, than those in the nonobjectivist general public are a representation of those nonobjectivists “who are qualified”.

Objectivists who don’t understand the Physics of this DON’T represent Objectivists who do. Period.That’s what I said. If that’s what you’re agreeing with, it really shouldn’t take that many words to say it.

 

What I think I am “observing” is that Objectivists who are not qualified, seem to tend they think they know more than they do or at least that they overestimate what they can conclude from the little knowledge (specialised) that they have. A sort of epistemological overconfidence?

It’s not over-confidence, it’s lack of confidence in one’s ability to actually figure things out, which causes people to take shortcuts instead. It has nothing to do with Objectivism. Quite the opposite, I find that Objectivism tempers this inclination to refuse to think things through logically, by teaching Epistemology.