I can’t say I would express things as you have. I haven’t seen any such tendency from professional Objectivist philosophers who give lectures on physics. Usually they stick pretty hard to the philosophy of science and only reject things on the basis of metaphysical truths being violated. As far as a forum goes, it isn’t a professional sphere, it is conversational for people to give their ideas, speculations, or whatever. It isn’t expected that what someone says in this fourm will be an original contribution to physics. People just like to put out ideas of how they understand things and have it criticized by others to think and grow thereby or just because they are curious of what other people think. If you think people are unfairly rejecting a physicists interpretation of his experiment, ask them why the object and then refute them.
Perhaps there are professional objectivist philosophers who have enough of an understanding of physics to give lectures and who are diligent and serious about investigating science in an unbiased manner… it would be unfair for me to attribute to them something I have noted generally. There are always exceptions.
It would help if you had a couple examples. I’m not all that into science, so I haven’t noticed what you’re talking about, having not followed the OO.com threads that I guess you’re referring to.
Of course, all new data must be cross-examined against what we already know, and the further we have to travel in our minds to cross-examine, the more difficult. But not that difficult – that’s why we use concepts, after all. So again, examples?
Since I am not playing the blame game I will not identify the sources or individuals but generally go over the types of “rejections” I have noted:
-
General relativity
-
nonlocality
-
anti-matter - total conversion of matter into energy
-
objective randomness (probability with no hidden variables)
-
quantum tunnelling and nuclear decay
-
dual nature (wave particle) of very small (low mass) particles, atoms etc.
-
QM in general
I have not observed the same hostility towards knowledge and science and indeed their application in engineering and the multitude of “magical” gadgets we enjoy today from any other civilized group. Lawyers, dentists, authors, even Catholics seem more open on average to the knowledge of Physics than layperson objectivists. It is as though there is an overarching psychological phenomenon at play.
I think it is tied to extending the “common sense” approach of critical thinking (which in association with logic as such is incredibly useful) to a kind of “judge things using common perception” policy, i.e. a day-to-day perceptual standard is used to judge scientific evidence.
By way of illustration think of the famous Rutherford experiment:
Rutherford discovered the general structure of atoms from his Gold foil experiment. He bombarded gold foil and found from the results that solid metal is mostly “empty” space, being an arrangement of nuclei which are capable of scattering particles which bombard the target, separated by expanses of space many times greater than the size of those nuclei through which particles simply pass though. Most of the mass of the gold was concentrated at these tiny places (nuclei) and these were arranged, “disconnected” and apart from each other.
This clearly flies in the face of common every day experience in a number of ways but primarily strikes at the heard of the every-day concept of “solidity” itself.
Imagine a fictional person at the time appealing to common “sense” (perceptions) alone:
“Solid things are by definition continuously solid, they are not made of holes, they certainly are not MOSTLY empty space, clearly we can see this because objects do not pass through each other -> Logic dictates that were solid objects mostly empty space they would easily pass through each other routinely. I have never seen a steel ball pass though a table. As for this matrix of spaced apart nuclei, this is impossible. Were the nuclei themselves solid, still, solid things do not hold each other “up” without touching each other. Even if we tried to arrange newly understood magnets in an arrangement of some permanence, there is no stable matrix position and orientation which allows construction of a stable “thing”. This man would have me believe that this quite solid table (speaker slams fist on the table) is actually 99% empty space? This man implies, nay is explicitly stating, that Solid things are not and indeed never have been, Solid. Such an idea is a contradiction in terms. It is nonsensical. Next he would have us believe that these Nuclei of his also are mostly space, populated by even smaller entities (or perhaps even point singularities) whizzing about tied together by mysterious “forces”, and thereby have us dispense from the universe the concept of solidity ENTIRELY for none of the individual things of which things are made would take up any space at all! I will not believe that solidity is an illusion somehow arising from things which do not possess it. THIS (Slams fist again) my friends I believe in… Not the nonsense this so-called scientist has asked us to swallow.”
There are innumerable problems in the thinking here. I will not try to identify them all. I think anyone can grasp my point. We have a conception of solidity which is based on human perception at the level of interaction with matter (macroscopic) we are capable of. THAT conception constitutes knowledge of the way interactions at our level actually “work” and as such is not incorrect. Solid things are not “porous” in that they do not admit fluid or dust to pass through them, nor are they capable of being passed through each other. Solid things are continuously divisible into other solid things and solid things actually “take up space”. It is not that objects “appear” solid, at our level of experience they ARE continuously solid and do not possess any “empty spaceiness” properties at our level of interaction with fluids or other solids.
The FACT that this common sense conception of “solidity” does not hold on the microscopic (atomic) scale, nor indeed is it an attribute of any fundamental entity which makes up solid things, does not invalidate the whole of our knowledge nor even that knowledge of solid objects per se. The experiment augments our knowledge. Far from the knowledge that everything solid is made of mostly point like particles interacting over expanses of space banishing the concept of “solidity” from the universe, it informs our knowledge of the reality of solidity. It tells us WHY solid things behave the way solid things do (we actually need to add more knowledge re negative electrical charge between the nuclei to really understand, but knowledge of nuclei and empty space forms part of the total knowledge needed.). The sum of our knowledge of reality also is entirely consistent with steel balls NOT falling though tables, etc..
Acceptance and subsequent integration of knowledge gained by science here requires that we do NOT abandon reason, deductive and inductive logic, careful experimentation, but DOES require that we abandon day to day human “PERCEPTION” level assumptions about the universe, some which SEEM like “common sense”. This is a fine distinction with which perhaps layperson objectivists are somewhat challenged.
BTW The fictional person who spoke those words against the implications of the Rutherford experiment I equate with many objectivists in the way they treat modern science. I do not doubt that had Rand lived before Rutherford, this very type of “speech” would have been quite popular among objectivists (perhaps both laypersons and “professionals”).