Compatability with Science

How much do most Objectivists agree with modern science?

Are there any disagreements with modern science? (e.g. some Christians disagree with the theory of Evolution)

How much do most Objectivists agree with modern science?

Are there any disagreements with modern science? (e.g. some Christians disagree with the theory of Evolution)

I don’t speak for all of Objectvists, but as far as I know it is incorrect to “disagree with science”.

One may have reason to disagree with a conclusion, a specific way of doing science. As an over all method however science is always legitimate.

I mean, an Objectivist might disagree with some conclusion of quantum physics, or a theory of neurology. He would have to do so on the basis of evidence or specific methodology though.

I have heard some Objectivists argue that science is in shambles today because it is done incorrectly and often reaches conclusions based on faulty premises.

Christians disagree with Evolution because they take faith over science at least in that matter. Objectivists may disagree with certain conclusions, methods, or premises because they believe it is not science done correctly.

I approve of Science, I don’t agree or disagree with it. Science is a method. If applied correctly, it will lead to the right results. I see no room for disagreement, with that. So, in my view, Objectivism is entirely “in agreement” with Science (the method of establishing truth).

I do disagree with some scientists, of course. Global Warming is probably the greatest travesty of science, but there are some others. Sometimes scientists jump to conclusions, try and sell a hypothesis as fact, even falsify evidence or circumvent the scientific method in some other way.

Scientists are just like the rest of us. Like any other people, they should be judged on an individual basis, not as a group. So I might also mistrust some scientists, without flat out disagreeing, in the event that I am not well versed enough in everything they do to actually prove it is all wrong. If someone shies away from independent peer review, or is caught in a lie, their results should never be taken as fact, no matter how adamant they are about them.

The things I may disagree with much of the scientific community on I am probably just more confused than in contention with. In general, most Objectivists don’t like some theories of quantum physics. As Ellison pointed out, global warming is rather frowned upon as well. But Objectivism is in no way against science.

I can’t imagine what “modern science” would be. If you mean the methods, then the methods are not modern, they are hundreds of years old (or more). If you mean “the sum of all conclusions”, then nobody agrees with the sum of all conclusions – that would imply that there are no scientific controversies (which there certainly are).

How much do most Objectivists agree with modern science?

Are there any disagreements with modern science? (e.g. some Christians disagree with the theory of Evolution)

If the science is scientifically valid, which means it accurately explains and represents reality in a scientific context, an Objectivist is morally bound TO agree with it, because it is core to our morality that we do not deny reality. We are radicals for honesty and integrity because we are radicals for reason.

You may, however, have to work quite hard to prove that a particular branch of science is valid - but if you can prove it, we have to accept it.

Is there something in science (of any age) you feel contradicts reality?

Objectivist ethics centres around the total and correct understanding of the facts of reality. as long as modern scientists are still loyal to the truth and not merely acting on the payroll of a biased loan granter then no objectivist would have any reason to disagree with their logical conclusions. the problems arise when scientists are found to have faulty premises or invalid logical connections.

(e.g. some Christians disagree with the theory of Evolution)

Oh so flattered by your comparison…

Objectivist ethics centres around the total and correct understanding of the facts of reality. as long as modern scientists are still loyal to the truth and not merely acting on the payroll of a biased loan granter then no objectivist would have any reason to disagree with their logical conclusions. the problems arise when scientists are found to have faulty premises or invalid logical connections.

This seems to presuppose Objectivist logical infallibility. While it is clear that such disagreements come about due to the acceptance of “faulty premises or invalid logical conclusions” of scientists, it seems equally possible that this could sometimes be due to the same errors on the part of Objectivists. While I’m sure you accept this, I do find it curious that this obvious possibility is completely absent from your post.

This seems to presuppose Objectivist logical infallibility. While it is clear that such disagreements come about due to the acceptance of “faulty premises or invalid logical conclusions” of scientists, it seems equally possible that this could sometimes be due to the same errors on the part of Objectivists. While I’m sure you accept this, I do find it curious that this obvious possibility is completely absent from your post.

He didn’t suggest Objectivists’ would never disagree with a logically sound conclusion, only that they wouldn’t have any reason to do so. So why would he mention the possibility of Objectivists being in error? What’s that got to do with the subject?

This seems to presuppose Objectivist logical infallibility. While it is clear that such disagreements come about due to the acceptance of “faulty premises or invalid logical conclusions” of scientists, it seems equally possible that this could sometimes be due to the same errors on the part of Objectivists. While I’m sure you accept this, I do find it curious that this obvious possibility is completely absent from your post.

Objectivists fully recognize that we (human beings) are capable of error.

The statement “Objectivist ethics centres around the total and correct understanding of the facts of reality” does not imply infallibility. It simply states the demand that we seek the most total and correct understanding possible in the given context. As a concretization (sp?) of the concept, consider the atom. For generations, theory strongly suggested but did not prove that some “tiniest” particle existed which made up the building blocks of all matter. Until the last century (if my knowledge of scientific history is correct), the “atom” was considered as small as we could go. The electron telescope showed us with undeniable proof that atoms are made up of even smaller particles.

We were, therefore, in error that atoms were the tiniest particles - but not in error that all matter was made up of atoms. That understanding of the facts of reality was correct - as correct as possible in the circumstances.

Re: Jake Ellision,

I’m not really sure what you mean. Objectivists could have many “reasons” (if we are using this word in a non-idiosyncratic way) for rejecting logically sound conclusions, and some could even be rational. Again, unless you (and he) are using the word “reasons” in some idiosyncratic or technical sense, your statement suggests that whenever Objectivists are in error regarding the correctness of a logically sound conclusion, the error is brought on by arbitrary and thoughtless grounds (without reasons). It seems very unlikely to me that this is what you mean, given the value Objectivists place on using reason (which entails having reasons) to determine their positions. I really can’t think of a way to interpret your comments in a way which doesn’t seem obviously false. In fact, Objectivists almost certainly sometimes do reject logically sound conclusions (even the best of them), and they almost certainly have reasons (which I’m sure they consider valid) for doing so.

I think that the possibility of Objectivist error quite plainly relates to the subject of how disagreements between Objectivists and scientists might come about, which I take to be the subject of his post.

Re: Greebo

Everything in your post seems reasonable to me. As I said in my previous post, I already assumed that CMac accepts Objectivist fallibility. I just found it curious that this possibility was not listed for instances of disagreement between Objectivists and non-Objectivist scientists.

Objectivists could have many “reasons” (if we are using this word in a non-idiosyncratic way) for rejecting logically sound conclusions, and some could even be rational. Again, unless you (and he) are using the word “reasons” in some idiosyncratic or technical sense, your statement suggests that whenever Objectivists are in error regarding the correctness of a logically sound conclusion, the error is brought on by arbitrary and thoughtless grounds

I took Jakes “reason to do so” ,as meaning reason as the process of identifying the facts of reality. In other words no valid reason, not simply any old “reason” arbitrary or not.

Re: Jake Ellision,

I’m not really sure what you mean. Objectivists could have many “reasons” (if we are using this word in a non-idiosyncratic way) for rejecting logically sound conclusions, and some could even be rational. Again, unless you (and he) are using the word “reasons” in some idiosyncratic or technical sense

I’m using it as defined in Merriam-Webster’s Online dictionary: a rational ground or motive.

There are other definitions, but this is the only one that can be applied while having the sentence make sense.

Objectivists could have many “reasons” (if we are using this word in a non-idiosyncratic way) for rejecting logically sound conclusions, and some could even be rational.

If there’s a rational reason to reject the conclusion outright, then it’s not a logically sound conclusion in the first place.

The above posts can be boiled down to the last posted argument:

If there’s a rational reason to reject the conclusion outright, then it’s not a logically sound conclusion in the first place.

I don’t agree with this. It seems to me that we might rationally reject a logically sound conclusion through understandable ignorance. A belief is rational if it is justified, but justified beliefs are not always true. In some cases, an argument might be logically sound, but we could lack definitive evidence for the truth of one of the premisses. In such a case, a person could still rationally support other logically possible and plausible conclusions which would later turn out to be false.

The above posts can be boiled down to the last posted argument:

I don’t agree with this. It seems to me that we might rationally reject a logically sound conclusion through understandable ignorance. A belief is rational if it is justified, but justified beliefs are not always true. In some cases, an argument might be logically sound, but we could lack definitive evidence for the truth of one of the premisses. In such a case, a person could still rationally support other logically possible and plausible conclusions which would later turn out to be false.

Objectivism rejects any form of analytic synthetic dichotomy. There is no logical-factual difference in Oism.