Aristotle and Rand as Obsolete?

I’m just curious here if someone who has far more knowledge of O’ist epistemology than I could help me with this statement made by a supporter of modern non-local quantum theory.

“Quantum physics has been verified and reverified over the last century in more experiments than can be named: while one may debate what the experiments mean, nobody can deny what occurences have been observed (contrast this to the philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle who provided nothing observerable, only semantic arguments and assertions).”

This man keeps saying that Aristotle and Rand are useless and obsolete b/c of quantum theory which changed everything. He argues that they offered no reproducable scientific data to support their ‘semantic assertions’ and that the relativistic universe disproves everything they have to say. He denies the validity of axioms with this:

"Axioms schmaxioms. Just because someone asserts that such things exist doesn’t make it so. And this is a huge problem with most philosophy and psychology, they start from axioms (that are usually simply preconceived biases) and work from there. Meaning that what axioms you start with determine what conclusion you reach. Such argument has no objective truth since it is unmeasurable and untestable.

Which is also why you can have any number of different philosophies or psychologies (or geometries) that are internally consistent but are at odds with one another: since humans are the ones defining the starting axioms, human consciousness is ultimately creating the end result as well.

Since you can’t create for me any objective ‘existence-o-meter’, that can define existence without having been created by a human in the first place, all that is is mere assertion. Which is not argument or even evidence."

He finishes by saying that there can be no existence w/o the perciever and no science w/o the observer.

I know generally the errors that he is making but I was hoping for some greater specifics as to how to counter his above claims. I know someone who holds the views stated above is beyond convincing, I would like to know to be able to offer an alternative to others who might be seduced by his ideas, particularly his claim that axioms are useless b/c they can’t be proved. I tried to argue that they were the precondition of all proof but it just provoked the above statement.

Also, I have noticed so many people w/ a science background advance this kind of skepticism. Its everywhere.

Thanks

Here is a tactic suggested (I think) by Piekoff:

After his anti-axiom tirade, respond by saying calmly, “Thank you for agreeing with me and helping to prove that Objectivism’s view of axioms is correct.”

If he repeats his assertions, just repeat the statement that you are glad he agrees with you. Whatever he says, just state that you are glad he supports the Objectivist position on axioms.

If you continue this process he may at some point say something like, “Stop misrepresenting my position! I am not greeing with you, I am opposing you! My argument is what it is and is not something different!”

You then point out that any claim to knowledge – even the claim that there are no valid axioms – implicitly assumes A is A.

I have never seen this change a determined skeptic’s mind. I have seen it create some questions and doubts in the minds of third parties that were otherwise sympathetic to the skeptic.

There are numerous ways to go about this.

One could say the same about science as well. Science is not measurable, it is a concept summarizing and systemizing man’s knowledge of reality. So, in his reasoning, science does not exist because it is not measurable.

Oddly enough it appears as though he is trying to label you as an advocate of primacy of conciousness when in fact he is guilty of such. Statements that claim something can only exist if it is measured or measureable and testable amounts to: perception is reality. Without the inclusion of axioms and concepts it means that what is seen is and what is not seen isn’t.

Ask him to measure emotions or reason. When he cannot validate reason from a scientific method(because science relies on reason) state that now reason does not exist and that therefore any claim of knowledge is impossible. Experiments are subject to subjective interpretations of the human mind.(Socratic method anyone?)

It could also be that he knows little of the use of metaphysics, that it is the most fundamental aspect of reality that all things share. Ask him questions regarding identity and conciousness and clarify the meaning of “existence exists”.

I do not have much time left but I will leave one last method specifically for an Objectivist mind and perspective. It concerns the fallacy of the stolen concept, that is, in Nathaniel Branden’s words “the act of using a concept while ignoring, contradicting or denying the validity of the concepts on which it logically and genetically depends.” I will leave it at that so that you and others may relate and reduce the Objectivist positions on your own.

http://www.nathanielbranden.net/ess/ton04.html

Here is a tactic suggested (I think) by Piekoff…

BTW, this tactic (known as “reaffirmation through denial”) was originally set forth by Aristotle (in Book IV of the Metaphysics, I believe).

Also, Jason–I could be wrong, but isn’t that quote you’ve attributed to Branden actually originally Ayn Rand’s formulation of that fallacy?

I would like to point out that the truth of the Objectivist axioms is observable in the same way scientific evidence is… in fact they are observed in the very act of observing. Heres how:

In order for something to be observed there must exist something to be observed, there must exist something to be observed, and there must exist a consciousness to observe it.

Their truth may not be proven, however, since all arugments rely on them (including scientific ones).

The guy wants axioms to be testable? What’s a test?

From m-w.com: “the procedure of submitting a statement to such conditions or operations as will lead to its proof or disproof or to its acceptance or rejection.”

If he accepts testing, he accepts the axioms. He accepts that there can be evidence toward a conclusion, i.e. facts, i.e. things which exist. He accepts that those have identity, since otherwise they could both support and undercut a statement simultaneously, and testing would be impossible. And he accepts consciousness, since there has to be somebody to accept or reject the statement (as well as to make it in the first place).

It’s rare that you run into somebody who literally and explicitly denies the axioms. Usually, they’re just denying that they’re axiomatic. Showing them that any attempt to undercut them must presuppose them is often useful. Incidentally, you could pick a number of things from what he says to do this: testing is not at all unique.

You can explain what the “axioms” are: inescapable, undeniable, indisputable, and indispensable facts of reality.

He seems to have mistaken the EIC axioms to be what “axioms” are today in mathematics (or in a formal axiomatic system in general): arbitrary statements from which all other propositions are deduced by a given set of deductive rules.

In Objectivism the statement “existence exists” is the fundamental axiom, not because all knowledge can somehow be deduced from it, but because it is the fundamental fact that underlies ALL other facts.

Before anything can be proved, there must exist the statement to be proved, the consciousness who is to prove it, and the evidence with which it is to be proved. There must also be such things as “truth” and “falsity”, since the purpose of “proof” is to determine the truth-value of a given statement.

“Testing” is a method of proof, one that presupposes the primacy, independence and existence of reality, and the validity of laws of logic.

How could he not understand that?

Also, Jason–I could be wrong, but isn’t that quote you’ve attributed to Branden actually originally Ayn Rand’s formulation of that fallacy?

My quote was from Branden’s essay, The Stolen Concept, which is included at the end of my original post. Hmmm, I looked through OPAR and found a reference to it(#17, ch4 Objectivity) which then referred to me to AS, pg 964. Skimming over that page all I got out of it was Galt talking about the moral/practical dichotomy and the unprincipled cowardice of evil. I will look it over again in more detail later…

As far as I know, it was Branden who discovered the fallacy. I have not read ITOE and a few other non-fiction works of Ayn Rand, but what I have read has not provided any indication or evidence that she originally discovered it.(though Peikoff does state the opposite in OPAR)

Link: The Stolen Concept

How could he not understand that?

Believe it or not he doesn’t and wont. Here are some exerpts from a lengthy reply he made when I basically outlined everything you pointed out above.

“If you’re having trouble with this, here’s an easy real world experiment. Flip a coin and catch it on your arm under your hand. Now, you can’t tell whether the coin is heads or tails. Intuition tells us that it must be one or the other but intuition doesn’t count. This is science and only real world observation matters.”

Notice his insistence on ‘only observation matters.’ Sounds like a wierd form of radical skepticism; although he’ll accept observation but not reality.

“Let’s say that it has a 50% chance of being one or the other (it really doesn’t but let’s say). The math of quantum physics would say that not only does each outcome have that possibilty but that, util you make an observation (look under the hand, feel the top of the coin), the coin is actually BOTH heads and tails simultaneously. This is visualized by two overlapping probability waveforms. Your observation collapses the state vector (from two overlapping waves into a single discrete point of observation) and causes the reality to occur.” :slight_smile:

Here he states that observation determines reality; and he states it w/ such conviction. Wow.

"I think it’s interesting that you continue to dredge up ideas that are thousands of years old, especially when they are ceasing to have much merit or truth in the ‘real’ world.

I mean, Plato posited all of his platonic concepts (Wilson points out that, by this logic, there must be some ideal platonic horseshit) but neither you nor I has or will EVER interact in the real world (i.e. the world of our actual senses) with such a thing. It’s philsophy, it’s not reality.

A book you may enjoy, also by Wilson is “Natural Law” since many silly ideas come straight out of old school non-relativistic Platonic and Aristotelian thought processes. The idea that something might or even could be good, right, bad, or wrong for all individuals (i.e. moral law, religious law) is based on such propositions but ignores modern relativistic thinking." :dough:

Here an absolute disdain for philosophy and Aristotle as ‘silly.’ And of course there are no absolutes; never mind the fact that he just uttered one.

Now here’s the kicker; this guy is one of the best respected names in the field of nutrition and fat loss. He’s written incredibly logical books detailing all the processes involved in nutrition and muscle building. He is an exellent empirical researcher yet he holds views like the above. People can have all kinds of contradictions.

It can make your head spin.

You can post back to this guy and tell him it really boosts your confidence in the rationality of man to have someone of his stature agree with you on such weighty philosophic matters. Tell him it is so refreshing to see him so persistantly assert that existence exists, that existents have identity, and that consciousness is what identifies that identity.

Tell him you are impressed with the number of examples he provided in his note which demonstrate just how fully and fervently he accepts each and every one of those axioms. For instance, he tells you to flip a coin:

Flip what? Something which exists (Existence exists. Check)

What is that something? A coin. (Existents have identity. Check)

What identifies the coin and the flipping? He does. (Consciousness identifies existents. Check)

He tells you Plato said x:

What spoke? Something which exists (Existence exists. Check)

What is that something? A man. (Existents have identity. Check)

What identifies the man and the speaking? He does. (Consciousness identifies existents. Check)

He tells you to read a book:

Read what? Something which exists (Existence exists. Check)

What is that something? A book. (Existents have identity. Check)

What identifies the book and the reading? He does. (Consciousness identifies existents. Check)

In each of these instances, he claims something exists.

In each of these instances, he claims that the something has identity (he tells you to read a book, not a coin, or a man or a bird, etc).

And in each of these instances he says he is conscious of the identity of these existents which he references.

Tell him you have never seen such a promising practicioner of these principles, and that you are again impressed to see someone embrace them with such zeal.

Tell him though that really, you don’t need any further convincing of those axioms. Tell him he doesn’t have to keep reiterating them to you over and over and over again. Tell him he he doesnt have to keep trying to validate those axioms for you because you already accept their validity.

Tell him that you are simply happy that he accepts them too.

:slight_smile:

“Let’s say that it has a 50% chance of being one or the other (it really doesn’t but let’s say). The math of quantum physics would say that not only does each outcome have that possibilty but that, until you make an observation (look under the hand, feel the top of the coin), the coin is actually BOTH heads and tails simultaneously. This is visualized by two overlapping probability waveforms. Your observation collapses the state vector (from two overlapping waves into a single discrete point of observation) and causes the reality to occur.” 

I have great difficulty accepting that anyone sincerely believes this sort of nonsense. Call me naive. If he really believes this, then it means anyone following this man’s expert nutritional advice on fat loss, nutrition and muscle building would simultaneously get fatter and skinnier, stronger and weaker until the instant they stepped on the scales or tested their strength – at which point all of his advice would kick in and collapse reality in the direction his book suggests. I’d like to see him state such a thing with a straight face.

If you decide to try RadCap’s example of “reaffirmation through denial”, please let us know how he responds.