I’m just curious here if someone who has far more knowledge of O’ist epistemology than I could help me with this statement made by a supporter of modern non-local quantum theory.
“Quantum physics has been verified and reverified over the last century in more experiments than can be named: while one may debate what the experiments mean, nobody can deny what occurences have been observed (contrast this to the philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle who provided nothing observerable, only semantic arguments and assertions).”
This man keeps saying that Aristotle and Rand are useless and obsolete b/c of quantum theory which changed everything. He argues that they offered no reproducable scientific data to support their ‘semantic assertions’ and that the relativistic universe disproves everything they have to say. He denies the validity of axioms with this:
"Axioms schmaxioms. Just because someone asserts that such things exist doesn’t make it so. And this is a huge problem with most philosophy and psychology, they start from axioms (that are usually simply preconceived biases) and work from there. Meaning that what axioms you start with determine what conclusion you reach. Such argument has no objective truth since it is unmeasurable and untestable.
Which is also why you can have any number of different philosophies or psychologies (or geometries) that are internally consistent but are at odds with one another: since humans are the ones defining the starting axioms, human consciousness is ultimately creating the end result as well.
Since you can’t create for me any objective ‘existence-o-meter’, that can define existence without having been created by a human in the first place, all that is is mere assertion. Which is not argument or even evidence."
He finishes by saying that there can be no existence w/o the perciever and no science w/o the observer.
I know generally the errors that he is making but I was hoping for some greater specifics as to how to counter his above claims. I know someone who holds the views stated above is beyond convincing, I would like to know to be able to offer an alternative to others who might be seduced by his ideas, particularly his claim that axioms are useless b/c they can’t be proved. I tried to argue that they were the precondition of all proof but it just provoked the above statement.
Also, I have noticed so many people w/ a science background advance this kind of skepticism. Its everywhere.
Thanks