I got into a debate on Maclin Horton’s blog, where he rants about Ayn Rand, after recently finishing Atlas Shrugged. I’m a bit stuck on how to respond to the following, that was posted by Rob G:
Ok, then – you’re a logical positivist, which tenet is equally self-refuting: you cannot prove by empiricism or logic or a combination of the two, that the only things you can know are what you know by empiricism and/or logic. It’s still circular reasoning – all you’ve done is make the circle bigger.
I’ve responded with the following, although it’s not written particularly well and I do not think it will be persuasive:
Yes, it is an assumption, but it is a direct result of other assumptions - axioms - that are necessary to be able to make any statement or know anything. For examples: the law of noncontradiction, or the law of identity. You claim something can exist outside logic, but for you to even make that claim requires you to assume the tenets of logic - the axioms that I have stated above. That is why they are axiomatic. For you to even assert that you know something, and that you arrived at that knowledge with means that are outside reality, outside logic, outside of reason, requires you to assume the axioms of logic. You deny the very axioms that you utilize in making that denial.
I guess my problem is how to respond without appearing to define the limits of knowledge outright. While I agree that knowledge should be limited to that acquired by logic and reason combined with evidence, my purpose here is a persuasive argument, which does not resort to referencing that limitation, but which shows the problem with removing those limits. Any suggestions?