Certainty is 100%. There is no such thing as certainty that is less than 100% validated. See “Certainty as Contextual,” Leonard Peikoff, Objectivism, pp. 171-175.
I stand corrected.
I am still unclear what it is you want to accomplish. Do you want to understand all of Aristotle’s philosophy? Or is there some particular tenet of his philosophy that you want to understand?
I want to understand the parts of his philosophy that I feel have merit - his metaphysics, his epistemology, etc. I originally posted my question to ask of some advice as to which parts did in fact have merit to them.
Assuming you and I mean the same thing by “certainty,” then I would say you could not attain certainty even about one tenet without investing thousands of hours. And if you want certainty on all of Aristotle’s vast philosophy, you might not achieve it within a normal lifetime – unless perhaps you are a philosophical genius.
I don’t know about that…I don’t think one needs to invest 1000’s of hours to understand and be certain about the fact that A is A. At least I don’t. Understandably, the process of induction does take a very long time to complete, years upon years - if that is what you are referring to.
No one, unless he is an expert having invested great amounts of time into validation, can achieve certainty in the tenets of a specialized science. History is a specialized science. History of philosophy is a branch of that science.
I agree.
What you can do is achieve some confidence from relying partly on trustworthy secondary sources (which you have assessed somewhat yourself) and partly on some direct knowledge (for example, a first-year Greek course, combined with time invested in studying not only a particular text but the commentaries and debates dealing with it).
I agree.
Is it more important to you than your central purpose in life? Or, are you considering making it your CPL?
I have never considered my choice of reading a crucial aspect of my goals in life, or CPL. I honestly don’t understand where you are coming from. I do not intend to read Aristotle to level that, let’s say, a graduate student, or (from what I can gather) you would read it at. I simply want to understand the basic tenets of Aristotle’s philosophy - the philosophy that inspired the Renaissance and Enlightenment.
I don’t know what you mean by “what ‘all the fuss is about’.” Could you define that – and tell me why you care about it enough to invest years of your life into it?
That was a joke. The “fuss” I was referring to was all of the references to Aristotle I have read in AR and LP’s work; and additionally on this website. Wow, I didn’t know I had made such a commitment. I want to understand his work, that is all I am saying. I never said I want to make a career out of it, or write a book.
I still do not understand your motivation – a motivation so strong that you are willing to invest possibly your whole life (“as much time as necessary”) if you are pursuing certainty of a subject as large as a whole ancient philosophy in all its details. I simply do not understand how anyone could have such a powerful interest without it being his central purpose in life.
Again, I don’t understand where you are getting this! I didn’t know that reading and grasping Aristotelian ideas was such an endeavor - to the extent you are making it out to be! Please clarify my thinking, if it is!
If I have not answered your questions, please ask again. I am still in the stage of gathering background – for context. I look forward to further discussion of these issues.
I appreciate your thoughts; and I do as well.