8 hours ago, Doug Morris said:
Would Aristotle object to the following proof that 0 times any number x is 0?
Prior Analytics isn’t about proper argumentation, it’s concerned with Aristotle’s formal system of logic and how deductions are formed within that system. I avoid the word syllogism because apparently (according to translation notes) the meaning of that term has been distorted after centuries of translations such that we associate in English the word syllogism with a specific type of deduction, even though Aristotle was actually only referring to arguments within his deductive system. Topics and Rhetoric deal with the way arguments are used.
Also, in your example, you used a rule twice, you didn’t use a premise twice. In this case, a premise would be an entire line in what you wrote out. After I read the translator’s notes, apparently I misunderstood. I’m still a little unclear (this is not unique to me simply as a student of Aristotle, even Aristotle experts find Prior Analytics difficult to interpret because it is such an ambiguous text). But I think he was saying using a shared premise twice. Let me explain:
A > B
B > C
B > D
A > D
So sometimes it might appear that C leads to D, whether it be due to deception or error. Again though, I might be misunderstanding.
17 hours ago, Eiuol said:
It still doesn’t seem like he means deduction here in the sense he has been using the word. It might be a translation thing.
It’s interesting that the translator says that the ancient Greek word _epagogee _is traditionally translated as induction because in Latin people translated it as inductio. Apparently that Greek word means “to lead into” or “bring in”. It is probably better to think of the term induction here as reaching conclusions about a genus from a species.
2 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:
I’m not sure you have connected each step in this hypothetical “proof”.
I’m trying to reserve these threads here for questions and discussion about my particular readings on Aristotle. But, I want to point out that from a modern perspective, there are often better and more efficient ways to express logical statements than Aristotle. Boolean logic for instance helps things a lot, as does the idea of operators. For better or worse, Aristotle system would work like Doug’s example, even though your reply is definitely a better deduction. Fortunately, he takes his system as one that can develop over time.