Arizona Bill 1062: The Right to Discriminate for religious reasons

To clarify, I am not making perfect the enemy of the good. [For instance, I’m happy with Institute of Justice style incremental-ism.] Some states are trying very narrow and unambiguous bills: saying that a person can refuse service to gay weddings. That would be far better than this ambiguous Arizona bill. 

 

I agree with Reason Being that the opposition to this bill was all on bad civil-rights grounds. It is too bad that almost everyone will see it as a victory for the civil-rights ideology. The religious lobby could easily craft a narrow and unambiguous bill along the lines that other states are trying, and if that goes through it will be a clearly targeted attack on the civil-rights ideology. Too bad the Christians allowed this opportunity to pass. 

 

(BTW, the bill is just two pages long)

 

When a supporter of the bill says that it does not allow a restaurant to deny service to a gay person, you should suspect what’s going on here. The proponents are hoping to fight this case by case, allowing judges to write law. [something the GOP loves to do, even though they claim that Democratic judges are pioneers in the area.]

 

The religious wing of the GOP is not clueless. So, do not assume they just happened to come up with a crappy bill. They are organized, long-term thinkers, who will keep pushing the envelope. They are experts at spinning this “rights” argument. For instance, they will say that a doctors should not be forced to give advice about terminating a pregnancy. Meanwhile, they will insist that a doctor who gives such advice must follow all sorts of rules that make it difficult to provide abortions! In states where they could not get their was on abortion, they come up with cynically spurious rules that they pass under the color of patient safety.

 

It is time to call their bluff.