I have read a book criticising today psychiatry. It was named Toxic Psychiatry and was written by Peter Breggin. Breggin describes the state of todays psychiatry and they major opinions.
They are following:
Today psychiatry is primarily concerned with body (brain). It contends that every psychical illness is due to some sort of chemical imbalance and that it can be cured by pills, electroconvulsive therapy or other form of biological treatment. It doesn´t pay attention to any form of psychological reason for illness. Moreover psychiatrists hold the right of treating patients without their own consent. All medicaments can cause some side effects. In Breggin´s opinion they are working by dampening of emotions so the mentally ill person doesn´t feel as bad as he did before because he has lessened capacity to feel anything. Finally Breggin maintains that psychiatrists try to show public just facts supporting their theories and opinions and that they even manipulate researches because they are paid by pharmaceutical concerns.
What I want to know is whether someone has the experience from the field of psychiatry and what are your opinions on the issue.
Consider the fact that there are two different fields that deal with mental health: psychiatry and psychology. A psychiatrist is a physician that, basically, specializes in neurological disorders; his purpose is to medicate you. A psychologist, on the other hand, deals with cognitive disorders, and cannot prescribe medication. So, it sounds like the problem is that people don’t have any means of telling whether they require a psychologist or psychiatrist. If I have schizophrenia, I don’t want a psychologist telling me it’s all in my head, likewise if I’m unhappy with my life because of unresolved conflict with my family, I don’t want a psychiatrist giving me happy pills that will only mask the problem, not help it.
When I was depressed several years ago, I had a strictly cognitive disorder, however it’s not always easy for your primary-care-giver to discern this fact as he or she doesn’t have a lot of context on your personal life. So, the course I was given was to try a mild anti-depressant to see if it helped (it didn’t, really), and undergo therapy (which also didn’t help, but that was because I’m almost bitterly self-reliant even when I’m not handling my own problems).
If the only option you are given in a similar situation is medication, you need to get a second opinion, unless your actual neurological disorder is diagnosed.
Still, there’s not a dichotomy between neurology and psychology. For example, a schizophrenic, while certainly in need of medication, might also benefit from therapy. And many cognitive problems, such as depression, do in fact cause chemical changes in the brain that can be helped with medication (in addition to therapy).
So I think a good psychologist should have some familiarity with psychiatry (at least enough to recognize when a psychiatrist’s expertise is needed, and to recommend one who specializes in the problem), and a good psychiatrist should have some knowledge of psychology.
And in my experience, the good ones do have this kind of knowledge. I think in one of Peikoff’s DIM Hypothesis lectures, he talks about the modern tendency of some doctors to overspecialize, to the exclusion of recognizing things outside of their specialty, and seems to reminisce about the days when you could go to one doctor who would treat you for everything. So, as an overall trend, there might be something to it.
But I agree with Megan that a psychiatrist should first and foremost be a specialist in neurological problems and medicine, whereas psychologists are needed to be skilled in cognitive disorders and effective psychotherapeutic techniques.