C & C: Coronavirus #4

51 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

The principle of it I think is a good thing. Make the most out of an otherwise bad situation, and this is especially true of politics. Whether or not the person applies the principle morally is another question.

Right, that’s why I said radical reform.

That’s a loaded way to phrase it, but sure, the silver linings of the coronavirus are a godsend for any political persuasion. It is a perfect opportunity to demonstrate how a free market could respond to such a situation. The free market is on hiatus precisely because no free market minded person in political office (or activist) I have seen has used this as an opportunity. The opportunity is going to waste. 

I always enjoy how even handed you are, Eiuol. Or is that naive? From past encounters, I notice you don’t seem to have seen that ONE particular political ideology is looming, above all others, with intentions of taking permanent power.

This is NOT “a godsend for any political persuasion.” A national state of emergency (pandemic or war) in a free or semi-free country (as with “emergency ethics” for an individual), is the antithesis of creative productivity, employment, flow of goods and money and profits (etc.etc.) which free market capitalism requires. During an emergency, collective-combined-cooperative actions are essential, in order to end the situation quickly as possible to return to normal (and yes, as secondary, the free-er capitalist economy shows its worth: it will have the greater creative flexibility and assets to withstand an emergency and recover faster.)

Crisis is not the normal state for nation (and individual), its the anomaly.  

The article I linked specifies to take advantage of this period of anomaly, to attack capitalism while it’s down, so to speak, and you cannot read that?

22 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

In an attempt to articulate some of the common elements that paved the current Covid-19 path to such a rapid ascent:

Climate, trees, animals, now 2019-nCoV are all things which cannot appoint a spokesperson, nor voice up objection, taking automobiles which require drivers to operate into account as an exception.

  • The climate is changing and will destroy us all if something is not done about it.
  • The renewable resource of trees must be kept from being cut down, with an overlap into the animals having a place to live (spotted owl, a newt, etc.)
  • “Animals have rights too,” say the animal rights activists, “and where here to defend them.” (at the peril of violation your rights.)
  • 2019-nCoV will destroy us all if something is not done about it.

“Paved … the path to such a rapid ascent”. I like that. 

An actor voiced recently, “the virus is the Earth fighting back” - or similar. Therefore, the Earth is conscious, and mankind is a blight upon it.

Never let it be said that many or most secularists aren’t as supernaturalist as any religionists. 

55 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

The article I linked specifies to take advantage of this period of anomaly, to attack capitalism while it’s down, so to speak, and you cannot read that?

"However, as argued by Naomi Klein in her 2007 book The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism, catastrophes do not always go the way of the shock doctrine path; in fact, it’s possible for a crisis to become a catalyst for a kind of evolutionary leap. These moments of shock are profoundly volatile. We could see working people either lose ground or earn progressive wins in issues that may have seemed impossible just a few weeks earlier. With millions of people already facing unemployment as a result of the crash, there has never been a more obvious case for getting policies such as universal basic income and the abolition of zero-hour contracts into the political agenda. We need to use the space that this potentially devastating virus has created for a kind of disaster socialism: to put right what we have previously gotten so wrong."

That’s from the article.

Don’t be so narrow about it. The part that I bolded sounds mostly good to me. Socialist leaning changes aren’t the only possible changes to make. You could implement whatever radical change you want, radical politics isn’t just for leftists. 

If you think capitalism has been beaten down, then you just aren’t noticing that the only thing beaten down is the mixed market economy which you wouldn’t even call capitalist anyway. And the parts that are most broken are endless bureaucracy.

50 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

“Paved … the path to such a rapid ascent”. I like that. 

An actor voiced recently, “the virus is the Earth fighting back” - or similar. Therefore, the Earth is conscious, and mankind is a blight upon it.

Never let it be said that many or most secularists aren’t as supernaturalist as any religionists. 

I didn’t see that take when I initially stated it.

. . . that paved the path of the current Covid-19 response for such a rapid ascent.

Mr. Smith, in The Matrix, compared man to a virus when he was speaking to Morpheus. That’s not the reference you likely intended however.

5 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

 

Mr. Smith, in The Matrix, compared man to a virus when he was speaking to Morpheus. That’s not the reference you likely intended however.

Idris Elba, a fine actor, usually smarter than others: https://metro.co.uk/2020/03/22/idris-elba-coronavirus-planets-response-humanitys-damage-12438077/

14 hours ago, Boydstun said:

“Leaders around the world have passed emergency decrees and legislation expanding their reach during the pandemic. Will they ever relinquish them?

Since most won’t, the desired know-how is going to be, how does the population regain its rightful freedom. Strong positive self esteem is going to be necessary at a minimum to fight for what one deserves. A clarity is going to be necessary that allows for the confidence and sense of deserving to exist.

The autocratic leaders will always exist and they will push the boundaries. What is happening is a calamity that only some see because it is not like an earthquake or tornado that has immediate harmful consequences. The new way of thinking is that a government can in fact print checks and won’t go bankrupt immediately. So it is legitimate for a leader that wants votes to say “my checks will be bigger than the opposition”.

In addition to that, this is not the last pandemic or even the last wave of this one.

1 Like

14 hours ago, Eiuol said:

"However, as argued by Naomi Klein in her 2007 book The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism, catastrophes do not always go the way of the shock doctrine path; in fact, it’s possible for a crisis to become a catalyst for a kind of evolutionary leap. These moments of shock are profoundly volatile. We could see working people either lose ground or earn progressive wins in issues that may have seemed impossible just a few weeks earlier. With millions of people already facing unemployment as a result of the crash, there has never been a more obvious case for getting policies such as universal basic income and the abolition of zero-hour contracts into the political agenda. We need to use the space that this potentially devastating virus has created for a kind of disaster socialism: to put right what we have previously gotten so wrong."

That’s from the article.

Don’t be so narrow about it. The part that I bolded sounds mostly good to me. Socialist leaning changes aren’t the only possible changes to make. You could implement whatever radical change you want, radical politics isn’t just for leftists. 

If you think capitalism has been beaten down, then you just aren’t noticing that the only thing beaten down is the mixed market economy which you wouldn’t even call capitalist anyway. And the parts that are most broken are endless bureaucracy.

By a ‘perfect’ standard, the mixed market economy - in endless admixtures - falls far short of what free marketers and individual-rightists would find acceptable. So the temptation I sometimes notice in these circles to throw all away until ‘perfection’ …“comes along”. In the now, in reality, in our own lives which is all that counts, the compromised market and some individual freedom is all that ‘we’ have and can use as the base for improvement. I suggest also, that today, in the US specifically, “endless bureaucracy”, regulations, restrictions, interference, is vastly more the province of the broad “left” and Democrats. That’s verifiable in dozens of cases in Congress lately, several which I heard and read about.

Therefore - going by your take - the Left, is what is contributing  to the “parts that are mostly broken”. Here in SA, with its far and neo-Marxist left occupying the political center,  most parts are broken and not even debatable. But then many aspects in socio-politics are so more graphic here. Subtlety and nuance doesn’t provide the cover it does in other countries. One sees things clearer.

“We need to use the space that this potentially devastating virus” .. etc" is ominously threatening.

That is not something to be cavalier about. This is rank opportunism in the blatant bid for mind control. It is obvious and visible. In among a proper concern for lives, disingenuously the (Leftist, would you believe?) media everywhere has been pushing the panic/alarmist button past any rational limits, without precedent in the previous pandemics. 

Now we have a better idea why.  

6 hours ago, whYNOT said:

I suggest also, that today, in the US specifically, “endless bureaucracy”, regulations, restrictions, interference, is vastly more the province of the broad “left” and Democrats.

Then you’d be wrong. American bureaucracy is an interesting monster, and not at all limited to the government. Do you even know all about the internal policies to hospitals that’s filled with so much bureaucracy? That’s what I’m referring to.

6 hours ago, whYNOT said:

I sometimes notice in these circles to throw all away until ‘perfection’ …“comes along”. In the now, in reality, in our own lives which is all that counts

I’m talking about taking an opportunity to do something. A time has come along to make a radical change. People should take that opportunity. It sounds to me like you are afraid somebody else wants to make good out of an otherwise bad situation, while you don’t have a plan to do anything at all different than usual. 

55 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

7 hours ago, whYNOT said:

I suggest also, that today, in the US specifically, “endless bureaucracy”, regulations, restrictions, interference, is vastly more the province of the broad “left” and Democrats.

Then you’d be wrong. American bureaucracy is an interesting monster, and not at all limited to the government. Do you even know all about the internal policies to hospitals that’s filled with so much bureaucracy? That’s what I’m referring to.

Isn’t the bureaucracy in technically non-governmental organizations such as hospitals largely a result of government requirements?

58 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

7 hours ago, whYNOT said:

I sometimes notice in these circles to throw all away until ‘perfection’ …“comes along”. In the now, in reality, in our own lives which is all that counts

I’m talking about taking an opportunity to do something. A time has come along to make a radical change. People should take that opportunity. It sounds to me like you are afraid somebody else wants to make good out of an otherwise bad situation, while you don’t have a plan to do anything at all different than usual. 

I don’t know how much we can accomplish politically in this crisis, since there is very little political support for the needed kind of reforms.  People who are in a position to influence the policies and practices of technically non-governmental organizations such as hospitals may be able to achieve some improvements, although this will be limited by government requirements.  People who are in a position to start new companies may be able to accomplish something.

We can also look for opportunities to use this crisis as a teaching tool.

3 hours ago, Doug Morris said:

Isn’t the bureaucracy in technically non-governmental organizations such as hospitals largely a result of government requirements?

I’m sure that’s part of it, but I don’t think we can say that bureaucracy is exclusively caused by government requirements. It’s not as if removing government requirements would also eliminate excessive bureaucracy. Requirements might be something like accepting a form of insurance, or the way money must be allocated for beds. But I would bet there is a certain culture of bureaucracy embedded within hospital policy that exists apart from the government. I say that because of my own experience with hospitals, in terms of making appointments, multiple phone calls just to get a single test, things like that. I mean, as far as I understand, hospitals have developed alongside governments within healthcare in the US, so I’m not sure you could ever disentangle the way government and healthcare interacts. That’s what I mean by a culture of bureaucracy - there are long lists of rules and hierarchies to get through because that seems to be what hospital administrators have learned.

5 hours ago, Doug Morris said:

People who are in a position to start new companies may be able to accomplish something.

I don’t think that would be enough. Radical political change is necessary. But people also need to come to terms with the deep bureaucracy embedded within American industries. Corporate bureaucracy is a thing as well.

30 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

but I don’t think we can say that bureaucracy is exclusively caused by government requirements

Granted, but market forces push for “lean and mean” systems. Unnecessary (excessive) bureaucracy is not added because a business wants to make money. The excessive bureaucracy is either through bad management or governmental pressure. 

52 minutes ago, Easy Truth said:

Granted, but market forces push for “lean and mean” systems.

Market forces don’t push one way or another on their own. A bureaucracy exists because someone thinks it’s better than not being there. Their goal is efficient bureaucracy, and like you, they would say that excessive bureaucracy is just caused by bad management. But the whole problem is bureaucracy in the first place. Sets of rules that a computer could follow, and divergence is unacceptable. Someone believes that it works better than the alternative of being hands-on and adaptive. Also, since a hospital is not completely driven by profit (why do you think they receive donations?), bureaucracy can be viewed as a way to keep things under control so that resources are not wasted.

Bureaucracy I think only exists insofar as the people who use bureaucracy in their administration are not competent or creative enough. They don’t know any better.

16 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

Market forces don’t push one way or another on their own.

Not sure why you don’t see this. An environment of competition “pushes”.

Free market forces push to bring down prices or to get more for the same dollar.

vs.

Governmental protectionist action push to increase prices and increase income for the ones it is protecting.

A bureaucracy is basically size of management. Some management size is optimum. Excessive bureaucracy, is too much or unnecessary management. By definition this is dead weight. It should not exist at all.

23 minutes ago, Easy Truth said:

Free market forces push to bring down prices or to get more for the same dollar.

No, not if there aren’t any people who know how to do this while also using money efficiently. But in a way, bureaucracy is the name of the game in America. Not only that, but America manages to have so much bureaucracy in healthcare, and without socialized medicine.

I think there are cutting edge pharmaceutical companies based in the US, and the US is pretty innovative when it comes to treatments and creating new treatments. But hospitals? They are a mess.

13 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

Not only that, but America manages to have so much bureaucracy in healthcare, and without socialized medicine.

What about Medicare and Medicaid? What degree of encroachment is needed to cross the threshold from non-socialized medicine to socialized? Or is this, perhaps, a case of separating the healthcare industry from the insurance side of the healthcare industry?

I guess I would just say it’s not as socialized as the ones in Europe. You might be right though, that the insurance side of things should be considered something different than healthcare per se. If anything, if we split the two up, socialized insurance is much worse than socialized medicine.

Healthcare and health insurance are not uniform in Europe. 

Switzerland doesn’t have a Medicare-like system. Health insurance is not tied to employers. The government subsidies its purchase, but people buy their own health insurance. Italy and Spain are highly socialized.

Switzerland’s per capita spending on healthcare is much higher than Italy’s and Spain’s. Switzerland is #2 in the world, USA being #1.

Switzerland is doing much better than Italy and Spain against the coronavirus. The latest stats show Switzerland’s cases/population is about 110% of Italy’s and about 90% of Spain’s. Italy’s death/cases is 4.5 times and Spain’s 3.4 times Switzerland’s. 

France and the UK seem somewhat less socialized than Italy and Spain. France and UK death rates are less than Italy and Spain, but much higher than Switzerland. Ironically, WHO ranks France #1, Italy #2, Spain #7, and Switzerland #20 in healthcare (UK #18). 

Twisted news about ventilators

On 3/30/2020 at 6:09 PM, Boydstun said:

For Autocrats, Coronavirus Is a Chance to Grab Even More Power 

Selam Gebrekidan in NYT 3/30/20

“Leaders around the world have passed emergency decrees and legislation expanding their reach during the pandemic. Will they ever relinquish them?

“In Hungary, the prime minister can now rule by decree. In Britain, ministers have what a critic called ‘eye-watering’ power to detain people and close borders. Israel’s prime minister has shut down courts and begun an intrusive surveillance of citizens. Chile has sent the military to public squares once occupied by protesters. Bolivia has postponed elections.

. . .

“Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha of Thailand has assumed the authority to impose curfews and censor the news media. Journalists there have been sued and intimidated for criticizing the government’s  response to the outbreak.

. . .

The measures taken by Israel are quite draconian. How necessary for a dense population in a small area, clearly the cause of the fear, isn’t certain. But the nation isn’t any autocracy (like a few that it has been lumped with by the writer), It’s Knesset demonstrates a (chaotic, many would say) solid democracy with all peoples represented and a free Press. If one knows the general Israeli character, one could be certain there would be a huge public outcry if these emergency precautions were extended just a month or two past the worst of the pandemic.