C & C: Coronavirus #4

@Eiuol I’m seeing 14-21 days, if the quibble is over “a few days” compared to “long enough”. Currently many community hospitals in America have reached their limit, bed-wise. The factors that led to this are going to be debated for years to come, contrasting it with the causes of WW1, WW2, or the “Great Depression”.

The medical field has had government intruding into it since the 1950’s. The FDA and other regulatory agencies serve as gatekeepers of varying degrees of objectivity in their approval processes. Medicare and government regulation requiring treatment complicate where finite resources are to be allocated.

How would this play out in a capitalist society? . . . why am I reading: “The proper action might be to limit ventilator use to a week at most.  If they don’t recover, let them die, since at that point it probably would not make a difference.”?

History reports what is, while fiction portrays what should and ought be. — Aristotle, paraphrased.

1 hour ago, dream_weaver said:

How would this play out in a capitalist society? . . . why am I reading:

Because I didn’t mention anything about the government making that determination. That would just be hospital policy.

1 hour ago, dream_weaver said:

I’m seeing 14-21 days, if the quibble is over “a few days” compared to “long enough”.

Any studies are probably for people not sick with a viral infection that has no known cure. So hospital administrators should make the determination of how long people should use a ventilator if they have covid. Besides, there are people on ventilators longer than 21 days anyway. In a crisis, I think it would be better to err on the side of preserving as many resources as possible. 

 

I am not finding a lot of info about the quality of ventilators and using them. But here goes. Several news stories report doctors saying there is a great shortage of ventilators in Italy. Do they have old ventilators or new cutting edge ones? No answer. I don’t see similar stories about shortages in Switzerland. Maybe in Switzerland there are more ventilators available, doctors know better how to use them, and/or they have better ventilators. Maybe hospitals in Switzerland are freer and more adaptive to getting supplies than they are in Italy.

Coronavirus’ ventilator demand: Who makes them and what will it take to get them? lists several ventilator makers. One of them is Hamilton Medical in Switzerland, which has raised its production in response to demand (link). Interestingly, the CEO says about his company’s devices:

“The new generation of these devices has a so-called closed-loop ventilation. This means that you almost only have to put the mask on the patient or intubate him. And then the device does everything necessary fully automatically based on pressure, volume, lung mechanics and other parameters that measure heart and lung functions, for example.

This relieves the physician from having to check again and again whether the device is set correctly or whether it needs readjustment.

And it provides additional safety, especially in countries where the expertise of medical personnel does not match the level in this country."

This article gives the impression that the ventilator must be used, or be designed, in the right way in order to give optimal controlled assistance to the patient.

This article shows a picture of one of these devices.

One thing that has struck me about the social impact of this outbreak is how much the character of the social response is altered by the advance in communications technology. In 1957-58 there was the pandemic of the H2N2 virus. I was only nine and didn’t retain much memory of it. According to the CDC note linked below, it killed about 116,000 people in the USA. That is twice the number of Americans killed in Vietnam. The population of the US in 1957 was about 172 million, whereas today it’s about 330 million. So percentage-wise, it would today be as if about 200,000 Americans were killed. I attach also a study I found on the US response to that pandemic.

https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/1957-1958-pandemic.html

https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/pdfplus/10.1089/bsp.2009.0729

1 Like

9 hours ago, Eiuol said:

That would just be hospital policy.

Which is currently massaged by government regulations. Hmm. Point taken.

Judge for yourself.

https://nypost.com/2020/03/28/coronavirus-patients-taken-off-ventilators-after-getting-experimental-hiv-drug/

CytoDyn’s leronlimab therapy used to treat New York coronavirus patients shows ‘immunological benefits’

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/leronlimab-used-seven-patients-severe-100010810.html  

This study estimates about 81,000 deaths in the US from Covid 19 over the next four months. Hopefully, we’ll all be around to see how close the author got in this prediction. And hopefully not near so many. As of this morning, about 2,200 have died in the US.*

http://www.healthdata.org/sites/default/files/files/research_articles/2020/covid_paper_MEDRXIV-2020-043752v1-Murray.pdf 

 

1 Like

You don’t want to catch the virus, you don’t want to pass it on (if you have). This basic principle is well covered by one’s rational self-interest. Self-responsibility, consciousness, self-awareness and mindfulness of others’ lives. Implicitly, most people know this. Except, universal panic has taken hold.

What we are seeing pronounced by media and governments is a drive, that already built steam prior to the pandemic,  to collectivism and self-sacrifice. Your life is not as important as others. “Together” we will defeat the invisible enemy. We owe the other. In part this explains why previous epidemics/pandemics like the Swine flu only a decade ago, didn’t get anywhere near the same hysterical attention as now, although deadly to hundreds of thousands. One hopes not this time round. Life carried on, almost regardlessly. I think we’ve passed the balancing point to where the cure is worse than the disease, and on a scale of major values we are moving into perpetual sacrifice.  i.e. given up a value for a lesser or non-value. The value is everyone’s freedom to act, the lesser is eternal security. The disruption and losses to billions of lives will not be easily recovered for the survivors. Many people will die, anyway.

On Sky (another channel dedicating 24/7 coverage, as if nothing else matters and nobody else is suffering and dying) a prediction today that the UK shutdown will have to be extended, perhaps until “June at least”. Bad enough for Britain, that will permanently cripple weak economies like mine here, since we are sure to mimic the UK’s policies. Then what? Poverty, business and industry collapse, (further) shortages of water and power, civil disobedience, riots, police and army force

Better (with a little hindsight) that home self-isolation had been voluntary - for a citizen himself to self-assess. Particularly, those elderly, and those with existing respiratory, cardiac, etc. health risks - and of course for those who have symptoms or know they’ve contracted the virus. This combined with ongoing government advisement to take all the well-publicized precautions, hygiene, “distancing”, etc. for personal safety, and providing many more testing stations. The virus would run its course among the healthier in a population, preserving the continuity and energy vital to life and enterprise. Too late now of course. A brighter note, the confidence that “man’s mind” will prevail. 

1 hour ago, whYNOT said:

You don’t want to catch the virus, you don’t want to pass it on (if you have). This basic principle is well covered by one’s rational self-interest. Self-responsibility, consciousness, self-awareness and mindfulness of others’ lives. Implicitly, most people know this. Except, universal panic has taken hold.

Yes and no. A healthy under 50 year old may decide they want to be exposed right now and take their chances rather than when they are sick or when the medical system is overwhelmed. Clearly a risk with dire consequences if it goes wrong, but when chances of death is 2 percent, and reward is immunity after that, it may look good to some.

1 hour ago, Easy Truth said:

Yes and no. A healthy under 50 year old may decide they want to be exposed right now and take their chances rather than when they are sick or when the medical system is overwhelmed. Clearly a risk with dire consequences if it goes wrong, but when chances of death is 2 percent, and reward is immunity after that, it may look good to some.

I like to use the motoring analogy. We get into our cars every day implicitly knowing the risks. When 1.25 million get killed on the roads every year - I didn’t look at serious injuries (many more) - why hasn’t WHO declared that a pandemic? Banned autos, for example? It’s a risk (maybe 2 per cent and more over one’s lifetime?) I take and as does everyone, knowing that their livelihoods, pleasure and mobility depends on cars. As does the economy. (But you drive well, and defensively, anticipating danger, avoid being too close to other cars, watch weather and road surfaces, concern yourself with not causing damage and injury to other people, as you primarily protect yourself, and keep you car in good condition - identical with precautions you’d take in this pandemic). :wink:   

In an attempt to articulate some of the common elements that paved the current Covid-19 path to such a rapid ascent:

Climate, trees, animals, now 2019-nCoV are all things which cannot appoint a spokesperson, nor voice up objection, taking automobiles which require drivers to operate into account as an exception.

  • The climate is changing and will destroy us all if something is not done about it.
  • The renewable resource of trees must be kept from being cut down, with an overlap into the animals having a place to live (spotted owl, a newt, etc.)
  • “Animals have rights too,” say the animal rights activists, “and where here to defend them.” (at the peril of violation your rights.)
  • 2019-nCoV will destroy us all if something is not done about it.

Take a look “From the left”, “disaster capitalism” and how anti-capitalists, in effect, “not let a good crisis go to waste”. A reasonable question I ask: is this coronavirus a godsend to the far left?    https://merionwest.com/2020/03/23/slavoj-zizeks-end-of-capitalism-and-the-coronavirus/

3 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

Take a look “From the left”, and how to “not let a good crisis go to waste”:

Obviously I disagree with Zizek on what should be changed, but he would be right to think that a crisis is a really good time to push even harder for a radical reform - because people would be more inclined to question what they think.

Another from Merion West I haven’t fully read yet, but seems agreeable:

https://merionwest.com/2020/03/24/balance-is-needed-in-the-fight-against-the-coronavirus/

The Atlas Society presents: “My Name Is Coronavirus.”

https://atlassociety.org/commentary/commentary-blog/6394-my-name-is-coronavirus

13 minutes ago, merjet said:

 “My Name Is Coronavirus.”

I think I would have enjoyed seeing the actions of Ignorance producing the fruits of Want featured in place of the new viruses of panic and fear.

* An obtuse reference to Charles Dickens, “A Christmas Carol”

Coronavirus #5

1 Like

20 hours ago, Eiuol said:

Obviously I disagree with Zizek on what should be changed, but he would be right to think that a crisis is a really good time to push even harder for a radical reform - because people would be more inclined to question what they think.

The quote attributed to Rahm Emanuel, “You never want to let a serious crisis to go to waste. What I mean by that is an opportunity to do things that you think you could not do before”.

You can’t see the cynical opportunism here? A serious crisis - or when a society is at its most fragile and uncertain, is the chance to grab more political power - Emanuel, as good as says.

This is not about fixing minor flaws in the system, definitely not what the author above proposes.

Here: “… ultimately, as the market spirals towards an unparalleled collapse[!!] , the prospect of an other system stirs.”

The free market is in hiatus - temporarily - and the writer can’t hide his glee at the prospect of capitalism weakened and overthrown.

I asked a question - anyone: Is this coronavirus a godsend to the far left?

Not one, but scores of intellectuals match the above author’s ideology and opportunist lust for power while free enterprise is briefly on the back foot. Simple observation tells you.

 

34 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

You can’t see the cynical opportunism here? A serious crisis - or when a society is at its most fragile and uncertain, is the chance to grab more political power - Emanuel, as good as says.

The principle of it I think is a good thing. Make the most out of an otherwise bad situation, and this is especially true of politics. Whether or not the person applies the principle morally is another question.

34 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

This is not about fixing minor flaws in the system

Right, that’s why I said radical reform.

34 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

I asked a question - anyone: Is this coronavirus a godsend to the far left?

That’s a loaded way to phrase it, but sure, the silver linings of the coronavirus are a godsend for any political persuasion. It is a perfect opportunity to demonstrate how a free market could respond to such a situation. The free market is on hiatus precisely because no free market minded person in political office (or activist) I have seen has used this as an opportunity. The opportunity is going to waste. I’m aware of people talking about it, but not of people meaning to do something about it.

For Autocrats, Coronavirus Is a Chance to Grab Even More Power 

Selam Gebrekidan in NYT 3/30/20

“Leaders around the world have passed emergency decrees and legislation expanding their reach during the pandemic. Will they ever relinquish them?

“In Hungary, the prime minister can now rule by decree. In Britain, ministers have what a critic called ‘eye-watering’ power to detain people and close borders. Israel’s prime minister has shut down courts and begun an intrusive surveillance of citizens. Chile has sent the military to public squares once occupied by protesters. Bolivia has postponed elections.

. . .

“Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha of Thailand has assumed the authority to impose curfews and censor the news media. Journalists there have been sued and intimidated for criticizing the government’s  response to the outbreak.

. . .