Objectivism asserts that the initiation of force is wrong because it controls people. If you put a gun to someone’s head and demand something, their love of their own life compels them to obey; in this way you disable his mind and his means of survival.
I agree that it’s wrong, but I don’t see how it actually controls people.
If someone puts a gun to someone else’s head and demands something, I wouldn’t blame them if they were to comply, but frankly I think it’d be best if they grabbed the gun and turned the whole situation inside-out.
In any concrete situation (not principles but actions; their physical application) there is always a third option, and a fourth, and a fifth, if you can think of them.
So, if you want someone to do something, I don’t think coercion will accomplish it- just look at every law that people break, all the time. I think that to actually control someone, as in successfully getting them to fulfill your desires, you have to recognize their mind; you have to reason with them and find out what they desire.
Taken to its logical conclusion (with that premise) to control someone would entail trade, commerce and Lassiez-Faire Capitalism.
Is this fallacious? If so, how?