I’ve found a few minutes to come back after reading in OPAR the section “The Initiation of Physical Force as Evil.”
Let me quote a relevant paragraph first.
The only kind of “social pressure” that cannot be resisted by intellectual means is the kind that does not rely on intellectual means. If some group, governmental or private, tells a man: “Either you agree with us or we will clean out your bank account, break your legs, kill you,” then a cognitive process on his part is ineffective; no such process avails in counteracting the threat. This, this category of threat of harm - physical force and nothing else - is what constitutes coercion. This is what sweeps into the discard the victim’s mind.
What I want to know is this: does Peikoff here mean to say that for a reasonable man, there is absolutely no way out of this situation - that his only courses of action are to comply to the one with the gun or run away? Or does he mean that there are ways, only they are not to be morally evaluated/considered?
I think that there are ways, in certain situations, to do both - end the force being used against you, and keep your body and property intact - and to do so purely by intellectual means. As a general rule, you could first comply to the brute, and not only that but also leave him with the impression that you agree with him. I think that it is possible to say to someone “I agree” without actually believing it, if there is a good reason for it - for example, if you don’t he’ll either shoot you or empty your bank account. It is possible, by saying this, to gain the brute’s trust and when you do, you have him right where you want him - you then have the power to undermine his position as an initiator of force, to expose him and to bring him to justice.
Of course, not every brute is worth dealing with in this manner - for that there is the government and the courts. But when the brute is the government, the state, or whoever wishes to call himself that way, then there really is no way out - all you get to do if you’re not already in a prison, is to find a prison of your own and stay there until the madness is over. Is it not, in such case, the effort used to bring such government down worth anything? Is it not possible to infiltrate such government’s structure - work as one of them (hence the topic title) in order to bring them down when the time is ripe? It’s a risky course of action - but the alternative is to comply to their demands and live under their rule - or to run away (if there is such a place).
I saw in another thread a person asking about emergency ethics. Person 1 gives person 2 a gun to kill person 3 or die. What I’m suggesting, in effect is this: is it not ethical in such a situation, when you get the gun, to kill person 1?