Objectivism is concerned with the whole of reality, not some arbitrary slice of it. Likewise, the Objectivist ethics must be applied within the relevant context that includes all facts that impact a situation. In your example, there is no mention of how one comes to be starving – it’s just put out there, with no grounding to the rest of reality. In modern life, free people don’t starve, and feed themselves quite handily without needing to resort to theft.
Well if you want a “for example” story, see the one above, it’s pretty good. Or, we could also talk about a hypothetical city on a coast that is hit by a devastating hurricane, leaving people without food (or shelter) starving outside of locked (flooded) stores without clerks, free people in the modern world.
No, to state that one should never steal is one instance of saying that one ought to act on principle. It is never rational to steal because theft violates the principle of individual rights, and it is always irrational to violate rational principles. In other words, being rational requires being principled.
What about not acting on the positive right to life? That’s the issue here, what if acting to sustain one’s (self-interested) right to life violates another’s (self-interest) right to property? Also, just in case I misunderstand you, if rights are universal (for everyone, everywhere, all the time) then how do you justify them without recourse to a notion of universal reason (romanticized Nature, God, Mind, Absolute Knowing, etc.)? It sounds a lot like a very slight modification of Kant’s Categorical Imperative. It wrong to steal because if everyone did it all the time humanity would destroy itself in contradiction (for the same reason that it is wrong to lie or kill, etc).
For validation of this, I recommend listening to Peikoff’s free lecture on ARI’s website.
Based on the fact that man’s existence qua man (achieving values long term) requires that he use reason, and that using reason involves forming principles (recognition of cause and effect), and that theft requires violating principles, which means violating morality, which means violating reason, which means evading the facts of reality.
That’s good, and thanks for the link. Though I don’t understand how “man qua man” necessarily has anything to do with value, or if it means something like Man by way of rationality (after all Man, not woman or child, is the Rational Animal for Aristotle) is what constitutes value in Man. Since we have defined Man as the Rational Animal (distinguished from the rest of the Animal kingdom by rationality), the best Man is the most Rational (unlike the other Animals). Is that what that means? As far as recognition of cause and effect, I like that, but is there one recognition of cause and effect, or many? It seems to me that not only do many causes result in particular effects, but that folks have different ways that they express causal relations. We inherit and change these communal notions of cause and effect over time as desire for new effects emerges. But that is about desire or is that what reason is? That seems to me to be what people in the real world act out of, that is desire what they want to do, reason is an after thought and varies from person to person according to their own (self-interested) desire.
As for potential thief and the property holder, if stealing results in the starving man being fed he has fulfilled his own self interest by staying alive; while denying another his right to property (but they still have their life). Would it be moral for the starving to ignore their own self interest and deny themselves their right to life, or should they act in their own self-interest and steal, and stay alive?