After having a classical liberal vs. traditionalist conservative debate with a fellow student, I was asked these questions about objectivism:
- Paraphrased: So what if I’m born a billionaire? I can live my entire life without producing any value. Although man “in general” needs to produce value to live, if I’m born a billionaire I don’t need to ever and what if I had a different philosophy?
For one thing, being born with a billion dollars does not mean that you will automatically be a billionaire for the rest of your life. You need to at least be productive enough to know how to manage your money, and keep it safe, or at least to be able to distinguish people you can trust to manage it, from those you can’t. Then of course, there are the needs of life other than having money, some of which have been mentioned.
- ON HAPPINESS: If happiness is the achievement of one’s values, what if I valued stealing and looting? Would I be happy?
I think that this scenario is possible, for a certain type of depraved person, in an unusual type of situation. But it doesn’t matter, because happiness is not the standard of morality (Objectivism is not eudaimonism), life is. Happiness is the goal and reward for being moral, but not the standard (see “The Objectivist Ethics” in The Virtue of Selfishness, specifically pg 27, and pgs 32-33).
MY QUESTION: Was my answer adequate? Furthermore, is it in our nature to be happy by achieving what WE value or what nature REQUIRES us to value? In other words, if I brainwashed myself to value stabbing myself in the gut, would I be happy doinog so?
This depends on the context for your use of happiness. If you mean eudaimonia, or “the good life,” which is more than a simple, fleeting emotion, then achieving happiness is more difficult, and would require more objective virtues than it would if you mean hedone, or momentary pleasure. Unfortunately, we only have the one word in English, and sometimes people equivocate on what exactly they mean, so it’s sometimes helpful (in my experience) to use the more specific Greek terms. (Usually, when Ayn Rand uses the term, I think she means something closer to eudaimonia. But when a Pragmatist uses it, he probably means something closer to hedone).
She just means physical life, but a psychological side-effect of following the physical life values is happiness.
No–when Ayn Rand speaks of the “life of man qua man,” I believe she means, “the life proper to a rational being.”
The standard of value of the Objectivist ethics—the standard by which one judges what is good or evil—is man’s life, or: that which is required for man’s survival qua man.
Since reason is man’s basic means of survival, that which is proper to the life of a rational being is the good; that which negates, opposes or destroys it is the evil.
Since everything man needs has to be discovered by his own mind and produced by his own effort, the two essentials of the method of survival proper to a rational being are- thinking and productive work.