I spent a lot of time during the 90’s on Usenet discussing philosophy. One of the things that really annoyed me was what I call the “hostile reader”. They were like cockroaches in the philosophy discussion groups, always there and always ready to pollute the discussion.
I encountered one such person on this site and, after his nature because clear to me, I put his username in my ignore list. (I also announced that I had done so, but it appears that he missed that.) But one day I checked the site without logging in, and I saw how he had responded to a couple of my posts. Ordinarily, I would have put his posts out of my mind, but they provided such a good example of hostile reading that I was unable to. After waiting several days (to avoid unnecessary emotionalism on my part) and after some thought, this post resulted.
The context was that DonAthos and I were having a discussion that was going nowhere. Over the years, I’ve learned that if a proper debate results in seemingly irreconcilable positions, the cause is probably not the bullheaded stupidity of one’s opponent, it is likely that there is at least one proposition that has not been debated, a proposition relied on by both debaters, which they have different views on. In order for the debate to progress, it is necessary to identify that proposition. So, I decided that I’d get a little Socratic and try a few questions to see if we might spot our real point(s) of disagreement.
My first question was, in relation to a situation I had described, “Do you think that it would be legitimate for you to use violence then?” DonAthos’ reply was to ask, “what do you mean when you say that the use of violence is ‘legitimate’”? He wasn’t sure which of the many meanings of the term I had intended, so he asked me.
Our hostile reader, by contrast, asserted that, “‘Legitimate’ is a stolen concept.” Of course, “legitimate” is not inherently a stolen concept; what he meant was that I had employed the fallacy of the stolen concept. He based this on the assumption that I had intended the meaning of “legitimate” that is associated with law.
I replied to DonAthos, “I meant ‘legitimate’ in the sense of ‘morally proper’”. The hostile reader then insisted that, “‘Legitimate’ hierarchically comes after moral knowledge.” and that I was “conflating the moral with the legal.” So, instead of accepting that I had used “legitimate” in the sense I had specified (see Merriam-Webster’s “conforming to recognized principles”), the hostile reader insisted that his definition was the one I had used.
DonAthos displayed the virtue of benevolence: He assumed that I had something sensible to say, and wanted to know what it was. What the hostile reader displayed was irrationality. He put words into my mouth (or, well, meaning into my words), for reasons that had nothing to do with advancing the discussion.
A hostile reader is different from a flamer, and is a lower form of life. The flamer is at least honest about his intent – he wishes ill to that which he flames. But the hostile reader is fundamentally dishonest. He uses the seeming of rational argument, but his goal is personal gratification by means of provocation. He isn’t looking to understand or to be understood; he wants to control.
In the current example, this is fairly obvious: The hostile reader tried to control the language of the discussion, by insisting that “legitimate” could only mean what he said it meant. No self-respecting debater would tolerate that sort of control, and many will respond by arguing against the hostile reader’s position. This is what that person wanted. Had I fallen for it, I’d have become embroiled in never-ending arguments, which would have gratified the hostile reader, but wouldn’t likely have done anyone else any good.
In my view, the correct response to the hostile reader is to remove him from the forum he disrupts. Failing that, ostracism works well. Like any troll, if he can’t get the emotional gratification he seeks, he’ll go elsewhere to get it. Arguing with him is a pointless waste of time, because he will only argue on his terms, and his terms are not intended to foster understanding.
Those who want to engage the hostile reader must do so with a firm statement of reality. Had I been so inclined, I might have said, “You may not dictate how I use the language, you may not impute to me meanings I am not using, and you will not provoke me into a fight. If you wish to contribute to this discussion, you will make an effort to understand what other people are saying and you will respond to their actual meanings, not what you want them to mean.” Repeat, mutatis mutandis, and probably ad nauseam. This is unlikely to generate a change in the hostile reader’s behavior, but it may render him impotent.