[Mod’s note: I have split some posts from here into a separate “Life and an Ultimate End” thread, as they were less about how to respond to this subjectivist. - sN]
Me and a subjectivist are having email conversations about objectivism. Does his reply make any sense to you? I used the term “living life as an end in itself.” He asserts that there is no logical point in living. Is this because he doesnt understand that the choice to live (exist) is what constitutes all that follows (values… ect)
This is his response:
This “an end in itself” is a very convenient expression which allows you to fix meanings of everything else. “An end in itself” means that the purpose of X is X. In an ordinary situation, it would be: Y is the purpose of X. Put it in a form of function
Y = purpose(X);
“An end in itself” is:
X = purpose(X);
IF the equation above is valid, the “purpose” would have no meaning. It would simply be:
X = X;
Certain mathematical functions could actually return this result. If the function was:
function purpose(X) {
Y = X * X;
return Y;
}
you can then enter “1” as an argument, and the answer will be “1”, whereas “2” would return “4”.
The problem however with your use of the expression “an end in itself” is that you assume that you know when X = purpose(X) can happen and when it cannot. You say, in the case of “life”, it can be an end in itself, but in other cases it cannot. If I’m free to choose what can be an end in itself, any sort of argument can arbitrarily be settled by my choice. I could just as easily say, “Money is the meaning of life.” You ask, “But what is the point of money?” I then reply, “Money is an end in itself.” You can disagree and argue why money is not an end in itself, but I could also argue why life isn’t an end in itself.
o, “life as an end in itself” is not logical at all. I don’t see how this statement could logically satisfy the answer to the meaning of life.
The same goes for your use of the term “self-evident”. That’s a convenient word too. Whatever is “self-evident” is exempted from your logical investigation.
My position isn’t to assert that things don’t exist outside of our consciousness. My position is that no such proposition can be proven, and any attempt to prove it will necessarily lead to nonsense. You see my position to be “subjectivism” but I have no way of proving that either. The fact that you understand what I mean by “apple” does not prove “objectivism” nor “subjectivism”. For the sake of being practical, I could agree to accept your axioms and go on to discuss your model of the world, but at the same time, I could agree to accept the axioms set by the subjectivists and go on to discuss their model of the world too.
If you want to be ruled by logic, explain to me logically without using convenient expressions like “an end in itself” or “self-evident” to excuse yourself from having to explain something logically.