Had debate with student today. i was accused of using circular reasoning by presenting objectivism like this:
"Man isn’t like any other animal. A dog doesn’t choose to be a dog. It is a dog and it will live like a dog automatically. A man is born human but has to choose in order to live like a human.
- response: but how do you know what’s human?
- Let’s start by saying a man’s life is his highest value
- response: who says so? why?
- Because if man chooses to value anything other than his own life, man will, in general, eventually die. This is because he must prioritize his life first in order to do things that advance it - ie, productive work.
- response: ok, but man doesn’t have to choose HIS life as his own value. He could choose others lives as his own value, and do productive work for each other.
- No because that’s not what we observe is man’s nature. When I breathe, I breathe into my own lungs, no one elses. WHen I eat, I consume into my own stomach, and etc. In other words, we are obviously designed to serve our selves.
- response: that doens’t prove it’s truly our nature to be selfish
- Well, consider that in nature when we do things that advance our life, we recieve the psychological response of happiness. In fact, productive work which advances our life is the only time we ever receive this feeling (not short-term pleasure, that’s a different feeling).
-
response: flat out denial. Also, it was said that one could be happy by injecting drugs into his system. Some people become happy by different things, so we can’t use this to observe our nature.
-
overall response: I’m just using circular logic by assuming that man’s life is his own highest value and then using subjective claims in nature as “proof” for my pre-conceived claim.
Where did I go wrong?