Objectivism is "circular reasoning"

Had debate with student today. i was accused of using circular reasoning by presenting objectivism like this:

"Man isn’t like any other animal. A dog doesn’t choose to be a dog. It is a dog and it will live like a dog automatically. A man is born human but has to choose in order to live like a human.

  • response: but how do you know what’s human?
  1. Let’s start by saying a man’s life is his highest value
  • response: who says so? why?
  1. Because if man chooses to value anything other than his own life, man will, in general, eventually die. This is because he must prioritize his life first in order to do things that advance it - ie, productive work.
  • response: ok, but man doesn’t have to choose HIS life as his own value. He could choose others lives as his own value, and do productive work for each other.
  1. No because that’s not what we observe is man’s nature. When I breathe, I breathe into my own lungs, no one elses. WHen I eat, I consume into my own stomach, and etc. In other words, we are obviously designed to serve our selves.
  • response: that doens’t prove it’s truly our nature to be selfish
  1. Well, consider that in nature when we do things that advance our life, we recieve the psychological response of happiness. In fact, productive work which advances our life is the only time we ever receive this feeling (not short-term pleasure, that’s a different feeling).
  • response: flat out denial. Also, it was said that one could be happy by injecting drugs into his system. Some people become happy by different things, so we can’t use this to observe our nature.

  • overall response: I’m just using circular logic by assuming that man’s life is his own highest value and then using subjective claims in nature as “proof” for my pre-conceived claim.

Where did I go wrong?

  1. Let’s start by saying a man’s life is his highest value

…

Where did I go wrong?

I think I see one problem. Life is not man’s highest value, it is his standard of value. It is the value by which he judges all other values. It would be possible and probably likely that rational men would value some things more then their lives. It seems small but this is actually a very common and big misunderstanding.

I’ll take a stab …

“response: but how do you know what’s human?”

Volition.

"1) Let’s start by saying a man’s life is his highest value

  • response: who says so? why?"

In short:

Value - that which one acts to gain or keep

Values presuppose a valuer, a standard of value, and an alternative. (Of value to whom? for what? as opposed to what?)

For the valuer, man, the fundamental alternative is life or death.

Life requires specific action.

“2) Because if man chooses to value anything other than his own life, man will, in general, eventually die. This is because he must prioritize his life first in order to do things that advance it - ie, productive work.”

You touched on several of the things I’ve stated. My main gripe with this is instead of saying “A because 1, 2, and 3” you’ve said “A because if non-a, then …”

Also, it is not precise. Man can value things other than his life, but he can not choose other than his life as a STANDARD of value.

“- response: ok, but man doesn’t have to choose HIS life as his own value. He could choose others lives as his own value ..”

this is so easily assaulted … the easiest way is point out the extreme. if his standard of value is other’s life, it would be immoral for him to gain in any way from any transaction whatsoever. how long would he survive under these circumstances?

“and do productive work for each other.”

He just contradicted himself. This is TRADE … this is immoral by the standard of value he JUST gave you. According to his standard it would be “and do productive work for them while getting nothing in return”.

"3) No because that’s not what we observe is man’s nature. When I breathe, I breathe into my own lungs, no one elses. WHen I eat, I consume into my own stomach, and etc. In other words, we are

  • response: that doens’t prove it’s truly our nature to be selfish"

Are you trying to say that their is no such entity “others” ?

"4) Well, consider that in nature when we do things that advance our life, we recieve the psychological response of happiness. In fact, productive work which advances our life is the only time we ever receive this feeling (not short-term pleasure, that’s a different feeling).

  • response: flat out denial. Also, it was said that one could be happy by injecting drugs into his system. Some people become happy by different things, so we can’t use this to observe our nature."

Well, that’s because you’re wrong. The standard of value operating your emotional pleasure-pain mechanism is not automatic. If you are improperly wired, you might be happy, but you will not live a proper life. That is if you live at all.

"- overall response: I’m just using circular logic by assuming that man’s life is his own highest value and then using subjective claims in nature as “proof” for my pre-conceived claim.

Where did I go wrong?"

Circular isn’t the word for it, but I see what he’s driving at. The concepts of life and value are inseperable. The concept of life make the concept of values possible. How could you seperate them? Of value to whom? For what?

Read The Virtue of Selfishness by Ayn Rand.

Further, make sure the student which you are talking to actually understands what you are saying. It is evident from what you have written that he does not. Also be aware of cognitive dissonance. You are presenting concepts so contradictory to what he has likely been taught his entire life.

I did a whole post on this this afternoon, but the malfunctioning board sent it slinging into the netherworlds.

It’s great to see people trying to defend Objectivism. I spent years trying to do philosophical detection during an argument, and it is not an easy thing to do. I’m still not good at it, but I commend you for working on it.

My $0.02 (and it’s probably not worth more than that)

a. based on the limited information on the students responses, you’ll have a hard time taking his/her retorts and trying to reason with them. The person appears to be pretty subjective in his/her thinking and this can be a pretty slippery task to pin them down. Everything comes down to “how can you know”, “that’s not necessarily so”, “'it doesn’t mean everyone has to”, etc… Concretize concretize concretize, pin them down to reality. Dont’ spend time going through a long chain of reasoning. Tease out their position and make it look foolish by bringing reality in every chance you get. You started out right I think, life is the standard (although, the “let’s start by saying” makes it sound like a math proof where you are starting out with an arbitrary assertion).

b. I think you blew it at 2, by not making your point more forcefully. Man MUST choose his own life as a value. Even if he values others he cannot foresake his own needs in favor of theirs. If he does, he will die. You can’t really get around this argument. He must serve his own life, literally, to sustain himself, before he can value any one else’s. He cannot value anyone else’s life, to exclusion of his own, or he will die. Reality dictates that he must value his life, and he must value it more than anyone else’s. This is not arbitrary, this is concrete and inductive.

c. I think your point #3 is a waste. Nate has some nice reasoning on a response to his “work for each other” point.

d. Point 4 tries to reason from an effect, happiness, that the cause must be so. This is tough slogging and uphill against a subjectivist. It will seem to him/her to be circular, because he won’t see why it MUST be so. All sorts of things could cause happiness, why is yours so fundamental???

“I did a whole post on this this afternoon, but the malfunctioning board sent it slinging into the netherworlds.”

same here. guess I’ll have to become a premium member soon to help get this claptrap working. *grin*

"Nate has some nice reasoning on a response to his “work for each other” point.

I’m coming along quickly. *grin*

Also, if he says something like “well, you should consume a minimum in order to be able to continue to provide value for others” then you can also cite the result of the full realization of this “moral ideal”.

Now you have all of humanity spending the whole of their time producing for “others”, yet consuming the minimum they “need”. Producing for whom? Fully realized, no one can benefit (as they don’t NEED it) except non-entities like “others” or “god”. (or in reality, dictators or similar)

Had debate with student today. i was accused of using circular reasoning by presenting objectivism like this:

"Man isn’t like any other animal. A dog doesn’t choose to be a dog. It is a dog and it will live like a dog automatically. A man is born human but has to choose in order to live like a human.

  • response: but how do you know what’s human?
  1. Let’s start by saying a man’s life is his highest value
  • response: who says so? why?
  1. Because [etc…]

The problem is that you’re trying to deduce Objectivism from higher principles here.

The answer to “how do you know what’s human” is inductive – you look at the world, you subsume percepts into concepts, according to genus and differentia. You can’t deduce “what’s human” from some higher principles. Once you form the concept of “human”, you will see that it is hierarchically derived from the concept “animal”, which comes from the concept “living being”. And all living beings, by their nature (as you have formed this concept using induction) strive for values, and for all living beings (not just humans) their life is their highest value. And it all goes from there.