I was noodling on this topic last night, and went back to Fact and Value as well to try to see if I could integrate anything into my previous position, which I still hold. David brought up some interesting points as well, and I thought I’d add some observations.
The question as I understand it is what is the status of seemingly “useless” information to the Objectivist relationship between Fact and Value. I continue to think that the particular magnitude of a value judgement associated with a fact is less important than the fact that the value judgement is a necessary extension of the fact, as such. That the fact implies the value judgement and that values (as per Peikoff in F&V) “are a type of facts; they are facts considered in relations to the choice to live.”
So if one is able to show that the magnitudes of value judgements are in fact variable, that is, some things are more valuable than others, that their relationship to ones survival are more important than others; That fact in an of itself opens up the possiblity of relatively useless information. It doesn’t matter whether the information is 0.0000001% useful or 0% “useful”. That in my book is as good as useless, and in fact already implies some oughts of it’s own based upon what David has said.
So I looked around just to see if I could see things that would provide inductive evidence of such a situation. I came up with two things that seem to provide some evidence for the idea that “useless” information does not conflict with the O idea of Fact and Value.
a. the concept of justice
b. the price mechanism in markets
In both of these contexts, the magnitude of the value of something is variable. However, the need and requirement to judge in relation to man’s life is absolute, in every case. One considers worth and price in every buy decision. In some cases worth is much higher than price, and so the ought is to buy. In some it is reverse and so ought is to not buy. BUt there are grades of this, and the ought is strong or weak depending on this analysis. And we know that there are value judgements in markets that lead to indifference among choices. THis does not however negate the idea that an evaluation in context is critical.
Same is true when looking at justice. The magnitude of the “earned” varies, but the need to evaluate does not. We can look at punishment and reward systems in any facet of life to understand that the magnitude varies, but the fact that a judgement was made to be able to assign a magnitude does not.
So to me, the idea of a “useless” fact does not in the least bother me with regard to Fact and Value. Evaluations are made that result in a magnitude of value, and that is what Peikoff is referring to in Fact and Value.
Is there any such thing as “neutrality” in terms of whether an “is” is a good “is” or a bad “is”? If good and bad are opposites, I don’t see how a thing that is, in fact, not good is anything other than bad. But I don’t pretend to actually be able to make correct identifications on all facts. Thus every “is” implies an “ought”, but not not every “ought” implies a “recognizes”. This, IMO, is where the is-implies-ought equation seems to run astray. Where I differ from SN’s view, I think, is that the things that seem to be neutral are ones where you simply do not know enough to be able to say whether it’s good or bad. For example I don’t know if an explosion on Raxicoricofallapatorius is good or bad for me. I’m not disinterested in having the answer, I simply don’t have any way of getting the answer, and I’d have to trade in some major values in terms of free time in order to know the answer. So a seemingly neutral value is an undetermined value.
This is a really fundamental point, but I’m not sure that the distinction between neutral and of very little positive value is the important one. What you have pointed out is that the process of evaluation is not costless. Therefore, epistemologically, the ought that is implied by every fact is the mechanism to evaluate such facts. As you’ve said this is iterative, and the elimination from consideration of a seemingly useless fact early on in the iterations is in fact a valid ought. That is certain facts, even though you don’t know all there is to know about them, in a proper process should not warrant the same level of consideration as others, and eliminating them early from consideration may actually be the proper valid mechanism of evaluting them.
You say you are not disinterested, but at least you are less interested than in spending time on other facts, yes? The whole idea of necessitating motivation as part of effective communication is in fact a recognition of the fact that people rightly consider those things that they believe are more relevant to their own contexts.
I would take issue with your statement of “not being disinterested” so maybe you can help me understand your lingering interest and what value you place on that fact. If Snerd tells me there’s been an explosion on a remote planet, it’s not that I’m interested at all, but that based upon my context and the evaluation I’ve made, I’m completely uninterested in pursuing that fact any farther as it relates to my flourishing. That is, the ought for a useless fact is that one should not waste time on it until such time as its relevance is apparent. The little bit of curiousity I might have about it might warrant pursuing it as part of a casual discussion over coffee, but not in any other capacity, and really not as an end in itself apart from some other goal (let’s say the enjoyment of pleasant, stimulating conversation with someone I value). As Peikoff says in F&V, “Cognition apart from evaluation is purposelessness; it ecomes the arbitrary desire for “pure knowledge” as an end in itself.”
This also integrates with things I see around me, especially as it deals with motivation. I find the ruthless expunging of useless information a trait that is of value, and especially apparent with those who place a high value on their time. One of the tidbits that I learned in business school (and it goes to the above discussion on motivation as well) was the use of the “Executive Summary”. That is, in any communication “upward”, the summary, the punchline if you will, should be summarized on page 1, in the first minutes of a dialogue, and in as essentialized form as possible. This is because good businessmen don’t want their time wasted. They anger at it, rightfully so (that is justifiably)!