Existence exists subsidiary thread

There are few here, that I am aware of, that are considered “professional” philosophers. I’m a draftsman by trade and profession. Even within the craft of draftsman, I specialize in applying measurement theory (consider it a form of measurement inclusion, rather than of measurement omission.)

 

I do not specialize in automobile repair. I hire specialist to work on my automobile. If I required legal counsel, I would hire an attorney. A unique aspect about philosophy is that I cannot hire a professional philosopher to do my philosophical thinking for me. I have to adopt my own abstract principles (a tough science to master) in order to apply them to the particular concrete situations that I encounter.

 

It is by philosophic principles I evaluate a potential mechanic, attorney, dentist, etc., as being qualified to defer the requirement of learning how to do a particular task for myself to a specialist.

 

Philosophy, on the other hand, does not work this way. Each individual has to learn to evaluate what Is true or false for themselves. Epistemology is the science which deals with such a task, and no epistemologist can perform this task for you. To let someone else decide what is true or false for you is to default on the responsibility of determining such an important issue for yourself.  Essentially, it would amount to taking somebody else’s word for granted, or on faith.

I agree, Gred, and you made an excellent point overall. I am interested in your measurement inclusion now. How do you do it?

 

Guys, I get it now. I apologize–that was dumb of me to ask you those questions. The mistake that I made was that I conflated my concept of “object” with your concept of “existent,” completely ignoring that your definition subsumes my objects, or concretes. I probably ignored your full definition because my main principle is Object–Context, where Object is equivalent to Existence. I asked it from the point of view of my model. An orange is a collection of tissues (lev.6), and a man is a body (lev.8). But this is only the left side of the model. What about the contexts?

So, when I swipe with my hand, all of this that I see I call an environment, not existence.

An environment can only be considered an entity as a noun. However, from ITOE:

““concrete” versus “entity,” the units are the same, but the concept “entity” distinguishes entities from attributes, while the concept “concrete” distinguishes entities from abstractions”

And Rand agreed.

Now, an environment, whilst an existing context, is neither a concrete, nor an entity, nor an attribute, nor an aspect, nor a consciousness, nor an action, nor an event, nor a phenomenon. An environment is the physical content of my field of awareness. Now, an environment may be considered a unit or a relationship. What do you think? Is an environment an existent or existence for you?

I agree, Gred, and you made an excellent point overall. I am interested in your measurement inclusion now. How do you do it?

Here’s an overview of the dimensioning and tolerancing philosophy used.

Here’s an overview of the dimensioning and tolerancing philosophy used.

I don’t understand why it’s called a philosophy. It’s only geometric rules used for engineering.

GD & T, is a set of abstract general principles (geometric rules) used to guide the application of dimensions interrelating features in accordance with part/assembly functionality.

 

Philosophy is a set of abstract general principles that are used to guide the mind when assessing or addressing particular concrete situations.

GD & T, is a set of abstract general principles (geometric rules) used to guide the application of dimensions interrelating features in accordance with part/assembly functionality.

 

Philosophy is a set of abstract general principles that are used to guide the mind when assessing or addressing particular concrete situations.

If that’s the way you see it, then OK. Peculiar, nonetheless.

If that’s the way you see it, then OK. Peculiar, nonetheless.

It pays the bills. 

You are being awfully guiet. Have you blanked out on my questions?

 

Here is an exemplar of logic:

Premise 1: All men are mortal.

Premise 2: Socrates is a man.

Conclusion: Therefore, Socrates is mortal.

 

We know that existence is existent, or existent is existence. There can be one or many existents, so quantity does not matter. Then we have:

Premise 1: All existents are existence.

Premise 2: An orange is an existent.

Conclusion: Therefore, an orange is existence.

 

Am I being illogical as before?

Premise 1: All existents are existence.

Premise 2: An orange is an existent.

Conclusion: Therefore, an orange is existence.

 

Fact:  all dads are boys.

 

Premise 1: all boys are dads

Premise 2: my three-year-old son is a boy

Conclusion: my three-year-old son is a dad.

 

—edit:  I was recently explaining to my son what’s wrong with your logic and it did not take him this long to understand.

1 Like

Fact:  all dads are boys.

 

Premise 1: all boys are dads

Premise 2: my three-year-old son is a boy

Conclusion: my three-year-old son is a dad.

 

—edit:  I was recently explaining to my son what’s wrong with your logic and it did not take him this long to understand.

So, maybe you can teach me some, as well. Existent, then, is not existence, but existence is existent. Can you explain to me what’s the extra in existence that is not existent?

You’re equivocating on the relationship between existents and existence.

 

While all oranges are existents, only some existents are oranges. The units of existence are all existents, including the existents that are not oranges.

 

Do not take this as denying the existence of an orange. The existence of an orange only demonstrates that an orange is one existent of existence.

 

If you are really interested in learning about ontologically based logic, I would recommend Peikoff’s “Introduction to Logic”. At 35¢ per minute, it’s cheaper than a new automobile buys you at ~50¢ per mile (based on amount of time to walk a mile vs. drive one at 60 m.p.h. or a mile a minute [calculated around 1985]).

You are being awfully guiet. Have you blanked out on my questions?

Here is an exemplar of logic:

Premise 1: All men are mortal.

Premise 2: Socrates is a man.

Conclusion: Therefore, Socrates is mortal.

We know that existence is existent, or existent is existence. There can be one or many existents, so quantity does not matter. Then we have:

Premise 1: All existents are existence.

Premise 2: An orange is an existent.

Conclusion: Therefore, an orange is existence.

Am I being illogical as before?

If x is an element of the set of all men, then x is mortal.

Socrates is an element of the set of all men. Therefore, Socrates is a man.

Everything else you said is nonsense.

You’re equivocating on the relationship between existents and existence.

 

While all oranges are existents, only some existents are oranges. The units of existence are all existents, including the existents that are not oranges.

 

Do not take this as denying the existence of an orange. The existence of an orange only demonstrates that an orange is one existent of existence.

 

If you are really interested in learning about ontologically based logic, I would recommend Peikoff’s “Introduction to Logic”. At 35¢ per minute, it’s cheaper than a new automobile buys you at ~50¢ per mile (based on amount of time to walk a mile vs. drive one at 60 m.p.h. or a mile a minute [calculated around 1985]).

I think you are saying that.all definitions are not interchangeable. So:

 

  1. Existence is Identity, but NOT Identity is existence.

  2. Existence is existent, but NOT existent is existence.

  3. Existence is everything, but NOT everything is existence.

  4. Everything is something, but NOT something is everything.

…

My interpretation:

Metaphysics is physics, but physics is NOT metaphysics.

 

Maybe I can connect it with what Rand said:

“Prof. F: So Objectivism holds that there are first-level concepts?

AR: Epistemologically, not metaphysically” (ITOE, 151). Physics is NOT metaphysics. OK.

“Prof. A: […] First-level concepts don’t stand for your knowledge of the existents, they stand for the existents themselves.

AR: Right” (152). Metaphysics is physics. OK.

“AR: the concept “existence,” at least the way I use it, is in a certain way close to the concept “universe”—all that which exists” (167). Metaphysics is physics. OK.

“AR: When you say “existence exists,” you are not saying that the physical world exists, because the literal meaning of the term “physical world” involves a very sophisticated piece of scientific knowledge at which logically and chronologically you would have to arrive much later” (169). Physics is NOT metaphysics. OK.

“[AR:] But now what’s the difference between saying “existence exists” and “the physical world exists”? “Existence exists” does not specify what exists” (170). Metaphysics is physics. OK.

 

What I gather is that you indeed believe that definitions are not interchangeable, except when they are synonymous.

If x is an element of the set of all men, then x is mortal.

Socrates is an element of the set of all men. Therefore, Socrates is a man.

Everything else you said is nonsense.

Interesting. So, the set of all existents is NOT existence.

There are three related logical operations (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_table):

  1. Logical identity (one value);
  2. Logical implication (two values);
  3. Logical equality (two values).

You definitions take (1) as if it were (2). Your axiomatic concepts are always true, but everything else is either true or false. You ignore, however, that by (3), if a non-axiomatic concept is true, such as an orange, it is equivalent to your axiomatic concept. If it is false, then the equivalence is false. But you do not like (3), since it can be false and can go in both directions (it’s a double implication, not a single one, which is (2)). Of course, your definition of the axiomatic concepts as always true is a belief that fragments logic by selectively picking only one side. Any value can be either true or false, and if your identity is false, it’s not a false identity, but merely an identity with a false value.

Interesting. So, the set of all existents is NOT existence.

No! An element of a set is not the entire set. You have conflated, in your original analogy, an element of a set with the entire set, you have trouble with quantifiers.

No! An element of a set is not the entire set. You have conflated, in your original analogy, an element of a set with the entire set, you have trouble with quantifiers.

Ah. Then this is not the fallacy of equivocation, rather it is the fallacy of composition.

Ah. Then this is not the fallacy of equivocation, rather it is the fallacy of composition.

How can it be a fallacy of composition when the set of all existents is also not existence? It makes no difference whether a part or a set of parts is not the whole of your axiomatic concept.

No! An element of a set is not the entire set. You have conflated, in your original analogy, an element of a set with the entire set, you have trouble with quantifiers.

You missed the point that the conclusion was false only because premise 1 was incorrect. I flipped your definition, but otherwise the reasoning was correct. The problem was with my misunderstanding of the definition (specifically, it’s monoconditional nature).

How can it be a fallacy of composition when the set of all existents is also not existence? It makes no difference whether a part or a set of parts is not the whole of your axiomatic concept.

I would settle for the fallacy of division here. Logic is not my fortè.

. 

I would settle for the fallacy of division here. Logic is not my fortè.

. 

Maybe so. It is peculiar, though, that a true statement will be: everything is not existence.

 

Would it be valid for me to equate my term everything to existence?

Fact:  all dads are boys.

 

Premise 1: all boys are dads

Premise 2: my three-year-old son is a boy

Conclusion: my three-year-old son is a dad.

 

—edit:  I was recently explaining to my son what’s wrong with your logic and it did not take him this long to understand.

Congratulations to Harrison for answering and disproving the original premise that started this thread!